‘When is enough, enough?’; Parents seek answer on overdose death

Posted

SHELDON – Tony Nichols has waited for six months to hear how his son died at the Northwest State Correctional Facility.

“Why are they being like this to a family in Vermont?” he said this past Wednesday standing outside the Franklin County Courthouse surrounded by Vermont’s media. “When is enough, enough?”

Tony’s son, Jeff Nichols, was arrested back in September on an aggravated domestic assault charge and lodged after 3 a.m. He was found dead 27 hours later from a fentanyl overdose. In the subsequent six months, Jeff’s parents – a couple from Sheldon – have been knocking on proverbial doors at the statehouse to try to get answers on what happened in that 27-hour time span. 

Meanwhile, the Vermont Department of Corrections saw 11 deaths among the state’s incarcerated population in 2023, with seven being attributed to natural causes. Two of the 11 died of drug overdoses at the Northwest State Correctional Facility.

“We want an independent investigation into the death of our son,” Nichols said.

Looking for answers

From Nichols’ perspective, the state hasn’t done enough to explain what happened in his son’s last hours. 

Back on Sept. 9, Tony Nichols and his wife, Kim, had been visiting Florida to bring their granddaughter Ayla to Disneyland when they got a call from Jeff from jail that weekend. They considered arranging a way to post bail, but the two decided they could wait until Monday’s arraignment. He was safe, Tony Nichols said. 

Jeff Nichols was found unresponsive in the intake area of Northwest State Correctional Facility a day later. It was the second overdose death of a person at a Vermont prison in 2023. 

Tony Nichols said he was aware of his son’s past struggles with opiates. Jeff had been in a car accident in 2004, and he had a history of relapse and recovery in the subsequent decades.  But Tony isn’t sure where the fentanyl came from that killed his son.

He contends that Jeff got the drugs from inside the jail, instead of bringing it with him. He also questions why DOC personnel weren’t paying more attention when his son began to overdose, or why no one raised the alarm if drug use was going on.

“My son threw up in that cell,” Nichols said. “He needed medical attention.”

According to a DOC press release, medical staff did attempt to resuscitate Jeff via CPR and Narcan, as well as called for emergency medical services, but staff were unsuccessful in reviving Nichols.

To get more information on what led up to those minutes, Nichols has been making calls. The Defender General’s Office, the Department of Corrections and Vermont State Police all launched investigations into what happened that day, but Nichols said he keeps receiving the state’s explanation that they can’t release info from an ongoing investigation.

Nichols said he did eventually get in touch with Vermont State Police detective Ben Weed to discuss the case, who provided some details. They’ve also pulled their son’s autopsy report and medical records to see what other info they could glean about their son’s final hour. The picture, however, remains incomplete for the family. 

“It's just another routine for (the DOC),” Nichols said. “There's so many deaths around them. It's just another routine day for them.”

For those who recognize the name, Tony Nichols was a founding member of Southbound, a classic country band that had played in the 1980s and 90s., and he could recall running into Gov. Phil Scott back when Scott used to manage the Montpelier bar, Legends, in the ‘90s, he said. 

He also remembers the governor coming to the Franklin County Field Days, where Southbound performed. But now, he wants a call back from Scott as the family looks for closure to a death that happened at a state institution.

“For (Scott) not to call me? For him not to go the extra mile and get everything I need? Unacceptable,” Tony Nichols said. “Please remember that my son was innocent until proven guilty. We do not know what happened in there.”

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here