What’s shaking in the sugarbush? Q&A with maple researcher, Mark Isslehardt

Posted

FRANKLIN COUNTY — Steam rises once again across Vermont this March, as maple season gets its start. 

Traditionally, Vermont families begin harvesting and boiling at the start of this month as Vermont’s weather rolls through the cold nights and warmer days needed for sap flow, but climate change continues to add an asterisk to what’s been typical.

But how is that actually shaking out in the sugarbush?

To better understand today’s climate challenges, the Messenger reached out to Mark Isslehardt, UVM Extension’s maple specialist, with a few questions around how different weather patterns are changing Vermont’s maple industry.

Q: How important is sugarmaking to Franklin County?

A: Franklin County is synonymous with maple production. This has several explanations but simply put, there is the resource (maple trees), climate/weather (to support ample sap flow) and an abundance of knowledgeable, skilled families and individuals willing to do the hard work to produce this unique food product. To illustrate the point, according to USDA published data, if Franklin County were its own state, it would be the #2 maple-producing state in the U.S. after Vermont.

The producers who are responsible for making and marketing this crop have consistently adopted new technologies and practices to keep their yields high and looked to new ways to produce the syrup with less and less energy costs. There has also been a dramatic expansion in the number of taps and gallons of syrup over the past 25 years.  

This is often unknown to those outside of the maple community. Reasons for this could be that maple is produced during a relatively short period of time (approximately four to eight weeks) in the late winter/early spring and unlike field crops that can be seen from the roadside, production takes place largely out of sight, at night or off main roads.

Q: How is maple production changing over time? 

A: Broadly speaking about climate, it is very important to identify the timescale in question. I tend to begin discussions on this topic by breaking things down into something like: short term (less than 5 to 10 years), medium term (between 10 and 200 years) and long term (more than 200 years). There is no hard and fast rule … but it's more about identifying things that are happening now versus issues that are looming or appear to be likely to impact the forests currently in production for maple – and then for long-term issues – that threaten the relative competitiveness of the species and their potential reduced importance caused by a significantly changed climate and less suitable habitat. 

I also want to be clear that predicting sap flow with a high degree of confidence is simply not possible given the many factors that contribute to this unique phenomenon.

Q: Has Franklin County identified any major impacts due to climate change? 

A: Trends statewide suggest that the climate favoring ideal sap flow weather has shifted earlier in the calendar year than was experienced previously. We see tapping occurring earlier than what has been considered “normal” and generally operations are expecting to get the season started several weeks to in some cases months before what has been traditionally considered the start of the sugaring season. 

 It is very important to follow up that statement with an acknowledgement that there have been significant changes in how maple is produced which can add to the trends of an earlier start that has less to do with climate/weather and more to do with how individuals run their operations. We have seen producers reporting they begin tapping in December or January whereas historically tapping was something that occurred at the end of February or beginning of March.

In the 25 years from 1997 to 2022, the average size of maple operations in Franklin county increased from 2,500 trees to just under 9000. This is about a 3.5x increase in operation size. What is interesting is that the actual number of operations has only increased by 35% (275 in 2022 up from 203 in 1997).

Q: What can we see? What can we measure locally?

A: Trends in the yield (gal of syrup/tap) have been increasing over the past 25 years across the US, and Franklin County has seen similar patterns. In 2002, the average yield in Franklin County was 0.22 gal syrup/tap. Twenty years later, that yield had climbed to 0.37 gal syrup/tap. This represents a 65% increase in yield. Possible explanations for this trend include increased vacuum level, improved tubing materials sanitation practices and better leak checking/repairs. It is now common practice to replace the spouts annually whereas scrubbing/rising was standard practice previously. Research suggests that sanitation in and around the tap hole has important impacts on yield from year to year.

Q: How will incremental climate changes impact Vermonters? What might people notice? 

A: Perhaps the most significant short term threat to maple production will come in the form of abnormal and sustained, extremely high temperatures during the sap collection season. Vermont and most of the US saw an example of what this could look like in 2012 when we had five days in the 70 degree range in the middle of March. One of the impacts of this unique atmospheric event was a very early onset of the microbial contamination that is often associated with the very end of the sugaring season and is partially responsible for tap holes ceasing to run. This essentially becomes a physical blockage of the taphole, and in 2012, it was combined with extremely low quality syrup being produced. Luckily for Vermont producers we have not seen another year with quite as many impacts (except to a much lesser extent some producers in 2021). 

Middle term risk would include all the short-term risks plus increases in any natural disturbances (high winds leading to loss of crop trees, significant ice damage, etc.) and impacts from invasive species. Drought events are significant in that they essentially stop new growth, reduce stored energy reserves and can combine with other stressors to send trees into a decline that, in some cases, could result in mortality. Long term risks will be a combination of impacts to the relative competitiveness of maples in the forest ecosystem (sugar maple especially is a somewhat sensitive species that tends to not compete well outside of its ideal climate niche). So disruptions in the precipitation (too much or too little) could reduce sugar maples dominance in sugarbushes. 

That being said, we see more and more sugar makers tapping red maples. Research from UVM has shown that red maples can produce similar volumes of good quality syrup as sugar maple. This combined with the fact that red maple has a much wider range of sites it can compete well on suggests that retaining more red maples can help producers diversify their sugarbush and improve resiliency while not significantly sacrificing production.  

Q: Could climate change stress on maple trees and higher yields hurt the industry in the long term?

A: This is a very important consideration. We as humans become very familiar and tied to the landscape and climate we experience during our short lifetime. Unlike many in agriculture, sugar makers harvest their crop from long-lived, perennial plants (maple trees) that can live for 200-300 years. It is very difficult to see changes over time, especially when there has been dramatic changes in how something like maple has been produced during that time. Are maple producers aware of changes? Yes, and they consistently raise concerns about what is to come. At the same time however, the technology and practices adopted by many producers has allowed them to see an actual increase in yields. This is not to say that these adaptations will continue to be effective (Ex: many producers in 2012 were using good practices and still saw very low yields as a result of the extremely high temperatures). 

Fundamentally, forests are in competition for light, water and nutrients. With thoughtful forest management, humans can have impacts on the forest to favor a certain mix of species and encourage healthy growth and resilient ecosystems but it takes work and does not always result in a direct increase in production. Sugar makers are in the woods year round and many are making the investment to keep production going into the next generation. 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here