What to do with the Stone House?; St. Albans Town looking for resident input

Posted

ST. ALBANS TOWN – What should be done with the St. Albans Bay Stone House?

After raising funds for years and spending many meeting minutes chatting about potential solutions, the St. Albans Town Selectboard is looking to move forward with an update of the bay’s historic building. 

But the big question remains: What should the town do with it?

As the conversation evolves, Town Manager Casey Toof said they’re trying to beef up local committees to better hear from local residents and neighbors about what they’d like to see before putting their plans together.

“We already know that the Stone House needs a new roof, ADA-accessible bathrooms and to be revamped to make it better, but we don’t want to make all these decisions without the public’s input,” Toof said.

Latest at the Stone House

Originally built in 1933 by the Civilian Conservation Corps to serve as a bath house for beach-goers, the Stone House has evolved as a quasi-public meeting space, often used as a central hub during park events.

But could it be more? Some ideas were kicked around at the town’s Aug. 17 selectboard meeting, but most people agreed on wanting to find a way to transform it into a more useful seasonal space. 

Toof said some potential approaches on the shortlist include adding some sort of kitchen into the space, where a caterer could store or heat food up for events. Weatherproofing would also help extend the use of the building into the colder months although completely insulating it for year-round use is likely off the table, he said. 

Instead, the most immediate concerns remain an upgrade of the bathrooms to make them more accessible and finding a fix for the structure’s slate roof, which is close to 100-years-old.

St. Albans Town has consistently held back from making such changes in the last few years, largely due to cost. The slate roof, especially, is something of a special feature due to its association with Vermont’s slate quarries, although Laura Trieschmann, Vermont’s historic preservation officer, said there could be alternatives worth exploring, such as simulated slate or different types of asphalt roof to ensure the building gets used.

Cost also doesn’t top the list of concerns for historic preservation efforts, Trieschmann said, as state officials are trying to maintain the historicity of the building, ensuring its most historic aspects are considered as part of the decision-making process. State and federal grants, too, are usually available to help cover related historic preservation costs if a town can prove the need.

And until the state knows what the town wants, it can be hard to know exactly how to help, as the state’s role is to ensure the best use of historic properties within the bounds of local needs.

“We want people to be able to use it, not to put it in a museum,” Trieschmann said. “But they still need to come up with a vision.” 

Town actions so far

The town has done some work to the Stone House in recent years. Back in 2018, an effort was made to refurbish the structure’s windows and doors, and the town updated the bay park’s walking path to encourage more general use. 

At that time, the town administration had also been considering a few upgrade options – such as raising the Stonehouse roof to allow in more light – although the administration’s focus eventually settled on the erection of a new town hall instead of moving forward with a major Stone House renovation.

The changes to the bay park since then have mostly included piece-meal improvements, including updates to the park’s ballfields, as well as the installation of a new onsite well. Toof said they completed the work this past spring, and they’ve been monitoring the new well to ensure it will meet Stone House needs.

The next stage for the Stone House refurbish, however, will likely be in bringing in more information to come up with a vision for the building. To do so, Toof said they’ll be looking for community input on the Stone House by setting up new avenues to receive the information. One focus will be on beefing up the town committees, including the parks & recreation committee and the historic preservation committee, by recruiting new members.

Toof said the town will also be releasing a QR code with an associated survey form that can be filled out by residents in the near future. A similar effort to track people’s ideas about Cohen Park’s future played out this summer, he said.

With that info in hand, the town will then have a better way forward to pull in the funds needed, depending on the work, as state and federal grants regularly track the public input process.

During the board’s last meeting, public works director Kevin McAleer said he was also lining up some professional resources to help inform the conversation, reaching out to a few historic consultants to get quotes on a potential historic structures report. Toof said they’ve also been in early conversations with various historic building experts, including architect Laz Scangas, to see what could be done.

Knowing the community’s desires for the property, however, remains a large part of the puzzle before the town will be able to present a larger plan. 

“From what was heard from the state, we’re going to have an easier path forward if we have a grand plan,” Selectboard Vice Chair Bryan DesLauriers said.

As for any costs, that will depend on what people want – and what bids end up coming down the line. An estimate from 2022 put the cost of a larger refurbishment at $1.5 million. Four years later without a plan in place, it’s harder to identify any sort of price-tag until residents can weigh in with what they’d like to see the building become.

“We’re working toward answering that question hopefully in the next few months,” Selectboard Chair Jack Brigham said. 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here