What did we get out of the Afghan war? Zilch.

Posted

Some very wise person once said that "history first repeats itself as tragedy and then as farce."  We now have a sad confirmation of that idea with the release by The Washington Post of "The Afghanistan Papers" revealing decades of bald-faced lies by Presidents George Bush, Barak Obama, Donald Trump and their top military commanders to bamboozle the American public into tolerating a seemingly endless war costing trillion of dollars and thousands of American lives.

   Sound familiar?  Think Vietnam and The Pentagon Papers! Think LBJ and Nixon and General Westmorland!  Think of 60,000 American lives and an estimated two and a half million Vietnamese dead!

   The Afghanistan lies were told in public to soothe the electorate while in hundreds of private interviews officials like Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld under Bush,  and National Security Advisor  Lieutenant General Michael Flynn under Trump understood the futility of the war but were too cowardly to jeopardize their careers to say so.  As a result thousands of American young men and women, and hundreds of thousands of Afghans died unnecessarily.  

   In the haste to avenge the horror of 9/11 we invaded Afghanistan to destroy Al Qaeda and to capture Ben Laden.  That was largely accomplished in two years. Al Qaeda and Ben Laden were pushed into Pakistan where he was ultimately killed.  But the Afghan war continued for another fifteen years against an enemy that prompted even a war hawk like Rumsfeld to ask: “Who are the bad guys?”  As for our Intelligence Agencies General Flynn remarked: “Intelligence gets watered down to the point that it is useless.”

   We desperately needed an enemy and the Taliban fit that role nicely - brown-skinned turban wearing religious fanatics.  And where has all this waste of treasure and lives gotten us - not even bragging rights as we approach withdrawing all our troops and the inevitable take-over by the Taliban.  One important unintended consequence of this folly is that before we intervened, years ago, the Taliban eliminated all opium poppy production. After American troops sent them running poppy production revived and increased four-fold making Afghanistan the world’s largest producers of opiates.  That has come back to haunt us.

Al Salzman,

Fairfield

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here