What are restorative practices? Maple Run educators go all-in to create community, good behavior

Posted

ST. ALBANS/FAIRFIELD — When students returned to BFA-St. Albans following COVID-19’s remote learning, Mike Campbell felt like he was teaching middle-schoolers, not high-schoolers.

“They really were not at the maturity level, and it was impacting learning tremendously,” said Campbell, a 25-year social studies teacher.

Some students, not all, were acting out – having outbursts, looking at their phones and generally misbehaving. In an effort to curb that behavior, Campbell and other teachers in the Maple Run Unified School District turned to restorative practices.

“When a student acts out like that, there's some unmet need or some support they're not getting,” Campbell said. “They're not doing that because they're suddenly not a good person. It’s because some dynamic changed for them, and we need to change our approach.”

Walking into Campbell’s classroom today, you’ll see the desks are organized in a circle, and students' names and pronouns are displayed in front of them on handmade wooden blocks.

This creates community, he said, which is the foundation on which restorative practice is built.

“In essence, [restorative practice] is just building connections and a sense of community,” said Alexis Hoyt, director of student support services at Maple Run.

For her, 80% of restorative practice work is proactive. If students feel a sense of belonging in their classroom, they might be less likely to act out or cause harm to others. And if misbehavior does occur, Hoyt said there is more buy-in from students to repair that action because they feel connected to the community.

In the past two years, Maple Run has put heavy emphasis on this philosophy, because it believes results will follow.

Anna Lawrence, a senior at Northwest Career and Technical Center, said restorative practices empower her to take more ownership over her learning.

“It just makes students feel heard and like they're important, instead of just in this system of going to school every day,” she said.

About 67% percent of Maple Run district staff is trained in restorative practice, with approximately 400 having gone through professional development via the International Institute for Restorative Practices.

Twenty-three staff members are trained as trainers, and they’ve been helping their peers learn the skills. Hoyt said the goal is for 100% of Maple Run staff to eventually be trained.

Restorative practices in action

Stacey Tully, a 34-year teacher at Fairfield Center School before becoming a literacy specialist, is one of those “trained trainers.” She has been utilizing restorative practices for years, starting long before she knew there was a name for them.

In her fourth and fifth-grade classrooms, she started each day with a “morning meeting,” seated in a circle with her students. She shared the plan for the day, checked in with students’ feelings and reiterated expectations.

“It’s a time to build your classroom, build the community within the school that you want for the school year,” Tully said. “You put in a lot of time upfront, but you get a lot of it back.”

Today, Fairfield has taken that a step further and implemented dedicated restorative practice or “community” time on Wednesdays. Depending on the grade level, students develop a sense of belonging by playing board games or doing a physical activity.

Once a month during this time, sixth through eighth grade students assemble in the gym to recognize each other for following the school’s values. As a Positive Behavior Intervention School, Fairfield rewards students for good behavior with a fake gold coin, which they can cash-in for a cookie at Chester’s Bakery down the road.

“We work with little humans,” Tully said. “They're going to run through the hall, they're going to talk loudly, they're going to get into some trouble every now and then. But they know how we're going to respond. And it's not just that they're going to be yelled at.”

Instead, Tully and others think it's important to find out what’s going on beneath the surface. Did the student get into an argument with a parent last night? Did they have breakfast this morning?

“We're seeing more kids with anxiety, stress, trauma,” Fairfield social worker Kate Howrigan said. “There's a lot more that they're carrying, so I think the restorative approach allows their whole being to be put in the equation.”

Responding to students’ needs

Some people may think being attuned to students’ emotions is a “free pass” on bad behavior, but local educators believe consequences can still be delivered.

That might look like participating in a restorative circle, where perpetrator and victim are brought together to talk about the harm that was caused. Other times, a more traditional consequence, like in or out of school suspension is deployed.

“Just because we're trying to create communities of acceptance and provide all students and adults with a high level of support, that doesn't equate to not holding kids accountable,” Hoyt said. “You can do both.”

Howrigan thinks there is a time and place for traditional punishment, but she believes there is important learning to be had from a restorative conversation. Listening to the impact you had on someone can be hard to hear and often is a catalyst for growth.

About five years after the implementation of restorative circles, students at Fairfield now come to Howrigan on their own, asking to have one.

“I'll have kids who are having friendship issues…And I'll say, ‘What would be helpful?’ and they're like, ‘Can we do a circle?’” she said.

Lawrence said she and her peers in the Humans Services Program at NCTC are used to being vulnerable with each other. It’s awkward, at first, she said, but a few weeks into the school year, they feel enough of a sense of community to let their guard down.

“If you come in and you're having a rough day…and you're able to get that off your chest, it relieves that pressure and helps you do the work that’s in front of you,” she said.

Circles are just one way adults give students a high-level of support to meet the high expectations schools set.

Campbell said he’s always had high expectations in his classroom, both for academics and behavior, but recently, he’s discovered some students – especially post-COVID – need more help to meet that bar.

“I upped my game on hearing from them and on creating a community where they feel comfortable sharing what they need,” Campbell said. “I’m not giving up on any of the rigor…I’m thinking about how I can better help them get there.”

In his experience, restorative practices mesh well with another educational philosophy, universal design for learning. UDL presents the learning objective, but gives students options for how to master it.

“When I ask them what they need, I often hear more choice, more options,” Campbell said.

Students may not get to do what they want, but at least they’ve felt heard, and in turn, that creates the sense of community and belonging that leads to good behavior and strong learning.

“Great teachers do most of these things already, but we’re being more purposeful,” Campbell said. “It’s a way of being.”

 

international institute for restorative practices, maple run unified school district, northwest career and technical center, fairfield center school, restorative practices

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here