Mark Levine, Vermont’s Commissioner of Health, last week was asked whether there was a direct, measurable line between PCB levels in our schools and health consequences. He said there was not, that the data was insufficient to prove the connection.
Mr. Levine’s testimony was before the House Committee on Education where Julie Moore, secretary of the Agency of Natural Resources, recommended that the state slow down the pace of PCB testing in our schools. It was a blunt discussion; the state doesn’t have enough money to continue PCB testing at the current level. Thus, it seemed prudent to focus on the schools that might be most at risk.
But, as Rep. Peter Conlon, D-Addison-2, chair of the committee, noted: “Am I correct in saying this is really to handle the immediate mitigation of PCBs and does not speak to the long-term cost of required abatement?” Ms. Moore generally agreed that the testing timeline would extend through 2025. Mr. Conlon responded “this could be the mother of all unfunded mandates, and the cost of this could significantly increase property taxes for Vermonters.”
The mitigation costs and the lack of specificity in terms of the dangers of PCBs are finally coming together as legislators absorb testimony from the likes of Mr. Levine, etc., and the educational community, including parents and students.
There is a palpable sense of both fear and frustration. Several committee members made it clear to Mr. Levine and Ms. Moore that Vermont’s school system is fragile and further disruption could be devastating. One committee member asked Mr. Levine what he would choose, forcing a school into remote learning while the PCB issue was dealt with, or continuing the school year with students in school, in a building that has been the same for decades.
As Mr. Levine said, it’s not a question he can answer because they are not comparable. It’s also his job to champion any cause that improves the health of Vermonters.
But for members of the committee - and undoubtedly for other legislators - the concern for the state’s educational system is every bit as important as removing PCBs. Probably more so. As Mr. Levine noted, he can’t show the ill effects of PCBs on those who’ve attended Vermont’s schools. But anyone familiar with our schools - particularly teachers - can show you the ill effects of disrupting the school day, let alone the school year. And it's dramatic.
In testimony before legislators, Chris Young, the principal of North Country Union High School in Newport, described how his school bought $100,000 worth of carbon filters to help lessen the levels of identified PCBs in the air, only to find out that after installation the test results showed a higher level of PCBs, raising all sorts of questions in terms of testing. Running the filters is also loud, as the people at Bellows Falls Union High School learned. They drowned out the public address system. The Bellows Fall school has also set up tents as substitutes for classrooms.
Does that sound like an environment conducive to learning?
Does that resemble a postcard Vermont would like to send to prospective families looking at Vermont as a place to live and work?
There are four challenges that loom for Vermont’s schools: first, is the immediate impact of this year’s school budgets which could send property tax rates soaring, second, is the $6 billion backlog in school construction, third is the PCB issue and fourth is the valiant struggle just to get the academic quality of Vermont’s education system back to where it was before the pandemic.
In short, we have a mess on our hands. We need to prioritize the order in which these challenges can be addressed. They are not equal. They cannot be done all at once. That is the task before our legislators and the governor.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here