SWANTON VILLAGE — Will Swanton’s Veterans Memorial Bridge bridge be replaced? And how much disruption will it cause downtown Swanton?
The Swanton Village Board of Trustees are scheduled to consider those questions next Monday, July 28 after hearing information from Vermont’s Agency of Transportation.
Both options would help maintain the Veterans Memorial Bridge for at least 25 years, but the project costs differ by a few million dollars.
The Veterans Memorial Bridge has been due for an upgrade for a few years now after state engineers tracked increased deterioration around the bridge’s joints — which connect its span to the bank — as well as areas exposed to erosion, causing rusting and weakening of the bridge’s substructure.
What the state will do to fix the bridge, however, has been a big question mark for trustees, as the village is responsible for a portion of the repair costs under state law.
On July 14, they got some answers. After state engineers ran the numbers on a few different alternatives, project manager Tiffany Card reported the state’s cheapest options — as determined by annualized cost — were two alternatives to replacement.
AOT engineers proposed moving forward with upgrading the deck with a specialized high quality concrete to hold the bridge together for another 25 years, or they could replace most of the structure, outside of its foundational parts, to last 25 to 35 years.
The major differentiating factors between the two alternatives include the size and scope, as well as the various details around shut-down schedules.
Under the first concrete deck option, construction would last four months, with a 30-day shut down window. The overall cost would be roughly $2.35 million. The village would cover $58,770.
The second more extensive option would require eight months of construction, with roughly a 60-day shut down window and $6 million cost. For the second option, the village’s cost would be $117,535.
Trustees are scheduled to make the decision on Monday, July 28, during their next regular meeting.
They’d also be able to request particular changes to the alternatives — such as adding new railings — in order to get an end product they want.
“You own the bridge, so you get to decide the scope,“ Card told trustees.
After hearing the presentation from Card, the resulting conversation focused around how to defray impacts to bridge construction. Downtown business owners in the audience said they have concerns about losing business and customers during the shutdown — as it happened during Swanton’s latest bridge repair completed last summer — and they expressed the need to prepare for the disruption.
By the state’s count, roughly 10,000 vehicles per day travel on the bridge’s state Route 78, which helps feed customers downtown, as well as allows semi-trucks full of goods to proliferate throughout the region.
During the meeting, Swanton Town Selectboard member Steve Bourgeouis asked that the state reimburse, or somehow cover, those costs related to losing that traffic due to a bridge shutdown.
Project manager Jonathan Griffin clarified that’s not something the state typically does. Any number of downstream business owners and residents could make the argument the bridge closure has an impact, and it can be difficult to fairly quantify those effects for everyone, especially if the value of the impact is under contention.
Instead, the best approach tends to be communal recognition of the challenge and special consideration to bump up business traffic through special events or sales, he said.
With that said, the state did recognize the difficulty of closing the bridge. Both trustees and state engineers threw out a few options that could mitigate downtown impacts and traffic hold-ups at the bridge during construction.
For example, the state could require the bridge remain open one-way to keep vehicles moving, instead of backing up traffic as roadworkers let different lanes of traffic through. Or they could consider cutting down the overall project time by bringing in night crews.
Either way, the village still needs to decide their approach. No decisions were made Tuesday night as they battered around the various considerations.
Village Manager Bill Sheets, however, reminded the group maintenance costs would likely stack up over time, if the board moved forward with the more substantial replacement option.
Under the proposed timelines, the state could finish its planning within a few years with construction likely occurring sometime in 2028. The second alternative would be closer to 2035.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here