Vermont’s dairy industry is dealing with growth problems; DFA’s idling makes it more complicated

Posted

FRANKLIN COUNTY — The idling of the Dairy Farmers of America plant in St. Albans — scheduled to go into effect in mid-August — will have immediate impacts on the 80 people set to lose their jobs. 

The long-term effects on Franklin County’s dairy industry, however, have yet to be discovered. 

Vermont dairy farmers already face rising costs and stagnant production levels, as fewer and fewer people find a future in the state’s well-recognized industry. But will a reduction in close-to-home food processing increase those economic pressures?

“This is a time we need to be bold,” Vermont Secretary of Agriculture Anson Tebbetts told a group of dairy stakeholders last week. “This is the time we really need to dig in and be bold, swing for the fences, maybe? I think this is the time we need to do this.”

Macro challenges

Roughly 40 people found their way to North Hero’s Shore Acres this past Thursday to have a wide-ranging conversation about the state’s dairy industry in light of the DFA plant closure.  

The hour-and-a-half event, organized by Rep. Mike Morgan (R-Milton), brought together stakeholders from Vermont’s agriculture agency, legislative leaders and dairy farmers to learn more about DFA’s downstream effects and to get some answers around its decision to close the plant.

Tom Bellavance, who represents Vermont on the DFA board, provided the reasoning to the group. As states out west have taken advantage of major production gains, Vermont’s cow herd has stopped growing, he said. That’s pushed DFA to make changes to how they process their milk in order to capture evolving markets, and in the northeast, he said, that means preparing milk for protein powders and other fitness-enhancing drinks.

“What we really should be coming together and talking about is how do we make Vermont agriculture sustainable and competitive,” Bellavance told the group. “Those are the things we really need to be talking about.”

Within the New England region, Vermont’s dairy industry stands out as a major contender, with a higher percentage of workers and processing facilities concentrated in its rural areas, especially in places like Franklin County. As a result, about one-in-five of the state’s 400 dairy farms are located here.

Taking a look from a nationwide perspective, however, Vermont’s efforts are overshadowed by bigger players. 

In total, the United States has 9.23 million cows in its dairy herd. In just one year, while Vermont lost 1,000 head from its 113,000 cow herd, producers in other states jumped to capture increased demand felt from international actors, adding over 180,000 head of cattle – or Vermont’s entire herd and then some – to the nationwide production levels.

That’s left DFA – which has plants across the U.S. – with trying to find a way to add more value to Vermont’s milk as milk prices stagnate, Bellavance said. DFA’s solution was idling the St. Albans plant, so they could help redirect milk to a New Hampshire facility to better fulfill the regional demand for protein products.

“What we're seeing here in the Northeast is we're seeing a greater demand for those higher-value products, but we're seeing production stable,” Bellavance said.

Micro challenges

While Bellavance and DFA board member Harold Howrigan explained the reasoning behind the co-op’s move, state leaders encouraged the dairy farmers to identify the local levers state leaders can pull to try to improve the dairy industry. 

New York next door, for example, established a milk tax rebate program which Tebbetts said could be something worth exploring.

“Farmers don't have a lot of control left, but we do have some things that we can't control,” he said, later naming taxes, regulation, energy and workforce policy as areas where changes could be made. 

Vermont is also currently working through the development of an updated contracted animal feeding operation program as part of statutory reforms to make it easier to implement. A stakeholder group — comprised of farmers and related technical consultants — have been meeting regularly since the end of 2025 to hammer out concerns.

Many of the challenges mentioned by farmers, however, aren’t just concentrated in the dairy industry. Multiple dairy farmers in attendance spoke publicly on their concerns about inflating prices as well as the cost pressures put on the next generation.

“If you look at over 10 years and you factor 3% inflation, I’m not that good of a farmer,” farmer Walt Gladstone said. “I cannot beat inflation 10 years out. I’ve got to grow.”

And if state trendlines around consolidation continue, the next generation could face less opportunity. Amanda St. Pierre, a Berkshire dairy farmer and co-head of the Vermont Dairy Producers Alliance, explained how there are few educational opportunities in the state to push young people into the dairy industry, and the next generation often has to make compromises, like going to work or school out-of-state, to be able to make it. 

“It’s sad because they really are feeling now that Vermont doesn’t want them here,” she said.

She also expressed some concerns about the financial pressures felt by DFA while trying to navigate governmental regulations, which are carried by dairy farmers as co-op owners.

In 2025, for example, DFA was charged $210,000 in civil fees by state actors after the plant released untreated food waste into the St. Albans wastewater treatment facility on multiple occasions. The resulting fix — estimated to cost $3 million — wasn’t enough to eliminate DFA’s issues, as the new equipment caused sulfuric odor problems in the surrounding neighborhoods.

“When (DFA) puts in a $3 million upgrade, and it’s still not enough, and they’re going to face fines daily until they solve the problem, that’s a problem,” she said. “And that’s not a St. Albans problem, that’s now a state problem.”

St. Albans Town farmer Oliver Manning was more blunt about governmental overreach.

“The spoke that broke and kicked the wheel off the bike was, I think, the City of St. Albans,” Manning said, later calling out “Lake Street” as comparable to any DFA odor when it comes to the city’s appeal.

Legislative response

After hearing more details about the various issues facing Vermont’s dairy farmers, state legislators encouraged the group to become more politically involved, as Act 181’s controversial land use law proved that rural voices can have an impact on state decisions.

Otherwise, the statehouse tends to lean on the voices of nonprofit leaders and lobbyists to guide its policy decisions, State Rep. Lynn Dickinson (R-St. Albans Town) said. 

“They really don’t want economic development,” she said, referring to the liberal-majority statehouse. “The fact that you want to increase production is not something that they care about. It’s just not something they’re interested in any economic development.”

To better help dairy farmers, Franklin County’s delegation — which consists of Republicans — said they need more conservative voices and more conservative voters trying to make political headway to keep dairy farms working.

“We need to look at how we can achieve the goal of keeping our working lands going and thriving and increasing. I want to see land turn into working land,” State Rep. Greg Burtt (R-Cabot).

Without such rural spaces, Burtt said, the concern is the state will lose its special connection to dairy as a lynchpin of the Vermont brand. 

The point was well-emphasized throughout the meeting. While Vermont’s dairy industry faces more and more economic pressures, those in the audience emphasized they’re not going away anytime soon.

“I’m sure (national producers) would be happy if we just folded up our tents and went home. But we don’t want to do that. We can’t do that. It’s too important,” Howrigan said.

“We recognize family farms are essential to our economy, our landscape. They're the backbone, the fiber of what we see as Vermont. If we think of rural Vermont, that's what we think of.” Morgan told the group at the meeting’s start. 

“In the end, possibly there's some things we as legislators could take away from this that might lead to some meaningful policy down the road,” he added.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here