FRANKLIN COUNTY — At Northwestern Counseling and Support Services, medical director Dr. Harris Strokoff sees plenty of youth come through the doors with symptoms of a substance use disorder.
But their addiction isn’t to alcohol or drugs, it’s to a pocket-sized screen.
“Long story short, I'd say it's basically irrefutable that addiction exists when it comes to both social media and video games,” Strokoff said.
Concerned by this trend — and the correlating upticks in teen suicide and depression — the Vermont legislature made changes to education law this spring that modify how smartphones and social media can be used in local classrooms.
Signed by Gov. Phil Scott June 27, H. 480 states that starting this fall, Vermont schools can only communicate with students through district-approved social media platforms and cannot require students to use social media for out-of-school academic work, athletics or extracurricular clubs.
In addition, the bill requires the Agency of Education to develop a model policy that prohibits students from using cell phones and non-school-issued personal electronic devices from arrival time to dismissal. Vermont schools must implement their own version of the policy by July 2026.
“The things our cell phones can do today are amazing; however, the one area they seem to be very good at, is their ability to distract us from everything…” Scott said in a statement. “Taking a break from our phones is probably a good policy for all of us to follow — and hopefully, find that healthy balance we could all use a little more of.”
According to research collected by the office of former U.S. Surgeon General Dr. Vivek Murthy, up to 95% of young people ages 13-17 report using a social media platform. Nearly two thirds of teenagers use social media every day and one third report using it “almost constantly.”
Strokoff said youth who engage obsessively with social media can show symptoms of addiction, including tolerance, or a need to spend more and more time to feel satisfied, and withdrawal, when it's been too long since they last refreshed their feed or checked their notifications.
Studies compiled in the Surgeon General’s report show greater social media use can correlate with poor sleep, online harassment, poor body image, low self-esteem and higher depressive symptom scores.
“You can go online and see thousands of people who can draw better than you, dress better than you or are better looking, who have more money,” Strokoff said. “That comparison can create anxiety and angst and sometimes trauma.”
Rates of depression and suicidality — especially in teens — have been increasing in the U.S. for the last 15 years. That predates the COVID-19 pandemic, when isolation heightened symptoms, and aligns with the advent of smartphones and social media.
In 2023, Dr. Murthy called for warning labels to be required for all social media platforms, stating the channels are associated with significant mental health harms for adolescents.
“The mental health crisis among young people is an emergency — and social media has emerged as an important contributor,” he wrote in an op-ed for the New York Times.
Congressional action is needed to enact such labels. Lawmakers have not yet signed-off on the move.
In addition to hurting a student’s mental health, social media and phone use can disrupt social-emotional development. If students are heads-down, staring at their phones between class periods, they are most likely missing out on interactions with their peers.
“Important social learning happens in a school setting,” Strokoff said. “You learn how to make friends, how to argue, how to feel embarrassed, how to share, how to respect people.”
At Missisquoi Valley School District, what worries Superintendent Julie Regimbal is how the use of smart devices is diminishing younger children's attention spans. Preschoolers are entering the classroom more susceptible to distraction, she said, having already spent hours at home watching short, over-simplified video clips.
“Four and five-year-olds are quoting that stuff constantly,” she said. “It’s where their attention is going.”
That fleeting focus doesn’t mix particularly well with a preschool curriculum, which is usually focused on routine-building, social interaction and early literacy skills.
“If we can say it’s not allowed in school, then maybe families will delay how early they give their kids a device,” Regimbal said.
Cell phone use during the school day at Missisquoi Valley Union has been prohibited since January 2019. Principal Dan Palmer said the decision was spurred after he spent a single morning dealing with 11 phone-related incidents.
“I knew I had to make a change,” he said. “There were too many distractions in the classroom and we needed to stop, refocus on academics.”
After announcing the ban, Palmer experienced some pushback from parents and students, but overall, he said most everyone understood the change was for the best.
“It’s much like ripping a Band Aid off,” he said. “You set the precedent, get teachers, school leaders and parents on board, and say this is the way it is going to be.”
Since then, MVU staff have experienced students more engaged in the classroom and in the cafeteria. They are talking, laughing and working together.
Rep. Casey Toof (R-St. Albans Town) said the most powerful testimony on the issue he heard in the House Committee on Education came from students at Harwood Union High School, where cell phone use has also already been prohibited.
“One student came in and said he had planned to write his thesis on why he needed his cell phone,” Toof said. “But by the end of his research, he had proved himself wrong. He found it was actually more beneficial to put it away.”
But that doesn’t mean schools aren’t still dealing with phone-related issues. While phones are tucked away during the school day, they are usable on the bus and during after-school activities. And of course, students are still scrolling at home.
“We still have social media drama we have to deal with every single day, because they have it the rest of their lives,” Regimbal said. “To me, it’s not a school issue, it’s a social issue.”
Some parents at MVU and statewide have argued students need their cell phones for emergencies or so families can stay in-touch. School officials say parents should instead be calling the front office to get a hold of their student.
In Fairfax, the school board is looking to ban cell phone use before the state mandate goes into effect in 2026. This summer, the board is reviewing a policy that would allow a student to possess wireless communication devices on their person as long as during instructional time the device remains off and concealed.
“I support this, my staff supports this, but I think we also need to be mindful that this is an addiction,” BFA-Fairfax High School Principal Liz Noonan said during a board meeting in June.
Starting this fall, schools will not be able to require students to use social media to connect with educational offerings, athletics or other extracurricular activities.
For example, it was previously common for athletic coaches to communicate with students and parents through Facebook groups. Under the new law, that will have to change.
Regimbal said MVSD just purchased a new communication tool called Parent Square which will become its primary resource for information. Previously, the district had one platform for announcing snow days and other emergency closures, and another for teachers and parents to communicate. Now, all communication will funnel through Parent Square.
The district will still use social media, like its Facebook page, to share surveys, budget information and meeting dates with the greater community — but that information will also be available on Parent Square.
In letters to parents and staff, Superintendent Bill Kimball said Maple Run Unified School District will be reviewing its communication practices to ensure compliance with the new requirements.
“While we may need to make some changes, we remain committed to maintaining strong, thoughtful communication with students and families that reflects our shared values,” he stated.
When a teenager is experiencing depression or anxiety, psychotherapy can help. Talking one-on-one with a therapist can pinpoint root causes and provide that human connection some teens are missing. Engaging in therapy for eight to ten weeks has proven results, Dr. Strokoff said.
And while medication is sometimes necessary, he prefers to prescribe spending time outdoors.
“I am personally a big fan of taking big breaks from technology, whether that be summer camp or going hiking or fishing where we literally don’t have Internet access,” he said.
When that isn’t possible, parents should consider setting screen-time limits at home, allowing it in 15 to 30 minute bursts for younger kids. Better yet, wait until age 16 to give your child a cell phone, Toof and Strokoff agreed.
“As a father, I don’t think I need to get a hold of my kids every second while they are at school,” Toof said. “They’re learning, they’re with professionals.”
But it’s also undeniable that today, the Internet is everywhere. It’s hard to find a job, hobby or daily chore that doesn’t utilize it in some way.
“The Internet is part of our world and being the kid who has never once played a video game is difficult,” Strokoff said. “As parents, let’s think about when and how we introduce it.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here