Valuing the work: Primary care in Vermont looks for needed reform

Posted

FRANKLIN COUNTY — As a primary care physician for more than 30 years, Dr. Toby Sadkin has cared for people through every stage of life. 

“I just love taking care of people, babies through the elderly, and everything in between,” she said, seated at her desk at St. Albans Primary Care earlier this month. Her office is inviting and lived-in.  

“I enjoy getting to know people, to the best extent I can, and helping them through many aspects of their health and lives.” 

So many doctors get into the field because they feel similarly to Sadkin, but in Vermont, primary care has become a costly and challenging profession. 

“It’s a struggle to make ends meet,” said Sadkin, who in addition to seeing patients is also the practice manager of St. Albans Primary Care. She leads its staff and day-to-day operations. The practice serves over 7,000 patients a year. 

“Society does not value the work we do, and we cannot keep doing more with less and less,” she said.  

As longtime primary care physicians in Vermont retire, practices regularly find it difficult to replace them with new recruits, leading to less appointment availability and more patient visits to expensive emergency centers instead, putting stress on the larger healthcare system.

“When we can’t schedule same-day appointments, they have to go to urgent care for that cold and incur a higher copay, and the system will pay more,” Candace Collins, practice manager at Cold Hollow Family Practice in Enosburg, said.

Vermont is the most expensive place in the United States to receive healthcare due in part to too much treatment occurring at urgent cares and in hospitals.  

Recognizing that burden, the state has made some moves in the last year to support primary care. Back in December, the State of Vermont was notified it would receive more than $195 million in federal Rural Health Transformation program funding over the next five years. 

Some of those funds will be invested into primary care practices which offer additional support to patients through a community health team. In tandem, Gov. Phil Scott signed Act 173 into law June 18, which will study what it will take to increase payments to providers. 

“If we don’t pay them well enough, they’re not going to come,” Sen. Ginny Lyons (D-Williston), chair of the senate committee on health and welfare and the bill’s primary sponsor, said. “We’re working aggressively, at least I am, to make sure they have the resources they need to do the work.” 

Creating a Blueprint 

At St. Albans Primary Care, Dr. Sadkin works alongside two other physicians and five nurse practitioners. They are assisted by a community health team made up of a nurse care coordinator and a community health worker, who can help patients navigate insurance, social services, mental healthcare and more. 

“I honestly don’t know what we did before we had them,” Sadkin said of the community health team. “People need more than what I can do as a physician. I can write a prescription, but I have no idea if that person can afford it or pick it up. Their entire life at home might be falling apart, and it’s interfering with their ability to take care of themselves.” 

Community health teams provide preventative healthcare which can help keep further illness at bay. A nurse care coordinator can help a patient get the wheelchair they need, find assisted living or connect with a local food shelf, for example. 

St. Albans Primary Care receives some funding for its community health team from the Vermont Blueprint for Health. Sadkin’s team used to include a nutritionist as well, but she said the role became financially unsustainable. 

The state-managed Blueprint program has been in existence since 2006, and this past April, executive director Dr. John Saroyan kicked off its most significant investment ever into primary care. 

The initiative includes using some of Vermont’s federal RHT funding as a catalyst for increased per-person per-month payments to providers, so they can sustain and expand their preventative services. The goal is also to expand the number of practices who participate in Blueprint. Currently, about 70% of Vermonters pass through one of the state’s 124 independently-managed Blueprint practices. 

“We will invest in primary care by increasing the payments to practices, so their capacity to take on these higher levels of care coordination and preventive health for individuals is stabilized,” Saroyan said. 

After the kick-start from RHT funding, Saroyan said Blueprint will need to assess the progress made to justify future funding from state and commercial insurers.  

Act 173, passed by the legislature this session, states Blueprint must make recommendations for the payment changes by January 2027. For Sen. Lyons, this is the first step to making quality primary care accessible to everyone in Vermont. 

“Our goal here is to understand how we can make sure there's an equitable payment and reimbursement model for all primary care practices … so they'll stay put, or be attracted to parts of the state where there's a need,” she said. 

Sadkin, who has been following these proposals closely, approves of the ideas in theory, but is skeptical of the money actually materializing. 

Additional funding could help her add a nutritionist back to her community health team as well as a mental health counselor. But right now, the practice has no extra funds to spare, and adding more staff would mean taking from the salaries of current providers. 

“In concept, I think it's great. It would help us take the best care of our patients,” she said. “In reality, what will happen? I don't know.” 

Help wanted 

Cold Hollow Family Practice in Enosburgh has been recruiting for another provider for the last nine months. The office used to be a three-provider practice, but lately has been doing its best to serve 2,400 patients with one physician, Dr. Lorne Babb, and one nurse practitioner. 

“They don't want to move to Franklin County, and they don't want to drive to Franklin County,” Collins said of qualified applicants. 

Both Collins and Sadkin said the salary their independent practices can afford to offer new physicians is less than what they might find at practices affiliated with hospitals or in metropolitan areas. A quick Google search reveals a near infinite scroll of available primary care jobs in Vermont. 

With significant medical school loans to repay, compensation matters. 

The lack of applicants is not for lack of interest in healthcare jobs. In fact, the medical professions program at Northwest Career and Technical Center is at capacity and has a waitlist of eager high school students. 

“Tech centers and community colleges in our area are great at producing ancillary staff: medical assistants, nurses, etc., but we’re still relying on old-fashioned universities for the providers,” Collins said. 

In Vermont, about 60% of high school students go on to college or university. 

And even those who do pursue medical school often opt for a higher-paying specialty. Across the board, primary care does not pay as much as psychiatry, OB/GYN or general surgery. 

But those who do choose primary care in Vermont, Saroyan said, especially at a Blueprint-affiliated practice, will benefit from the support of a community health team and a variety of free opportunities for continued education and training. Throughout the year, Blueprint hosts a mix of virtual and in-person gatherings around a specific topic. 

Earlier this month, Blueprint invited physicians to an in-person training in Killington around substance use disorders. 

“We really do try to target our training and education to many different levels and many different disciplines, because … we know people are living longer and with different illnesses, and we know our youth are burdened by anxiety and many other things, so we really want to support providers, the practices, and then hence families and patients,” Saroyan said. 

Dr. Babb “fell in love” with Enosburg and Cold Hollow Family Practice right away, when he moved to the area following graduation from med school 1988. The job is important, because primary care is the foundation of the healthcare system, providing patients with a safe, supportive home base. 

“If they could come and try living in our beautiful small towns, they would see there are some real benefits to it,” Collins said. 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here