SWANTON – Should Swanton move forward with new sidewalks? After revisiting the project, the Swanton Town Selectboard wants to ask the community.
During the selectboard’s May meeting, project lead Bethany Remmers visited the board to relay the latest progress on Swanton’s sidewalk projects, but selectboard members had bigger questions about whether they’d like to move forward with the project due to high costs.
“I'm not sure that we can support this any further,” selectboard member Steve Bourgeois said. “ Perhaps it’s time for us to make a decision whether we’re going to move forward. … I’m very concerned about the ongoing cost.”
Selectboard Vice Chair Ed White agreed.
“It concerns me deeply, that the further we go and if we’re not able to get new funding, where the hell are we going to get the money,” White said.
Before making a decision, the selectboard wants to hear from the community. A public input session is scheduled for 7 p.m. on Tuesday, June 6, to be held at the Swanton Village Municipal Complex.
The primary length of sidewalk under contention this past May – if built – would extend along the northern side of Route 78 to give students better pedestrian access to Missisquoi Valley Union High School.
The initial scoping study for the project was completed in 2016, and the latest estimate sets construction costs at $622,000.
But the selectboard isn’t sure if community members still want the Town to move the project forward, citing potential cost amplifiers down the line.
For one, the most recent cost estimate doesn’t take inflation’s full impact into consideration.
Remmers said the latest engineer estimates use purchasing data from the last five years to inform the estimated price of construction, but selectboard Chair Earl Fournier said there are concerns about that number not being accurate due to rapid inflationary costs in the last few years, especially around infrastructure projects.
With that said, project organizers do already have some money in hand.
Back in 2019, the Town received $790,000 from a Vermont bike and pedestrian grant to help pay for planning and construction costs related to the project, and they’ve collected roughly $136,000 over the years to cover the 20% match required.
But the concern remains that the final bill could end up coming out to be even more than what the Town can cover.
“We’re a little bit concerned that this number probably doesn’t reflect what’s happened in the economy in the last couple of years,” Fournier said.
It’s no guarantee to solve the issue, but Remmers suggested applying for additional pedestrian grant funding by June 9 to cover any unexpected costs, especially as federal funds are made available.
Board members also expressed concerns on the potential future maintenance costs for the sidewalk. If the town is unable to contract the work, Bourgeois said they may need to invest in a sidewalk plow to keep the additional 4,000 feet of proposed sidewalk clear.
Town Manager Brian Savage said he’s been working on estimating those costs by speaking with other municipalities.
He said the Village of Swanton, for example, estimates that the average annual cost of per foot for their sidewalks is about 75 cents, but if the town got into the sidewalk business, Savage said the town’s average cost will most likely be much higher as there are simply less sidewalks.
Right now, the only sidewalks in Swanton sit along Bushey Street and Robinhood Drive, and they’re kept free of snow due to a gentleman’s agreement with the locals. If they build a new sidewalk, they’ll have to take care of those, too, Savage said, and they’ll most likely need to pay someone to do the work.
But pulling out of the project, at this stage, would also have its own cost. To pay for the initial scoping study, a roughly $64,000 federal grant was provided to the Town of Swanton, and if it withdrew from the project, the town would have to pay back 80% of it, or about $50,000.
The town could also choose to opt out of the project right before paying for construction, which would bring them through the rest of the permitting process. The overall price tag for leaving at that point, however, would be closer to $90,000 since the town would need to pay Northwest Regional Planning Commission to follow through with the permitting work.
As the conversation continued, Savage recommended the board hold on making any decisions at that time to better gauge community sentiment on the project.
The selectboard members agreed.
“I think I’d like to hear what they’d want to do more so than just five people,” selectboard member Cody Hemenway said.
Selectboard member Nicole Draper, who is also Swanton’s recreation director, stressed that there’s real benefits to follow through with the sidewalk project, as she often sees children walking to the high school along Route 78.
She also knows that sidewalks and community walkability are often cited as features that people want to see developed as towns grow.
“It’s something that people really look for when they’re moving to a community,” she said.
Fournier said he’s been thinking a lot about the sidewalk project, and he’s gone back and forth between keeping and canceling the project. But he’d like to hear what local people think before making a decision.
To help in that process, he asked the town to contact as many people involved with the project – the rec committee, the high school, the landowners and the business owners – for the public meeting. The more people there, the better it is for the town.
“If there isn’t a lot of public support for this project, then maybe we’re better off spending our money somewhere else right now,” he said.
Editor’s Note: This story was updated at 11:30 a.m. June 6 to supply more information about the history of the project and the viewpoints of selectboard members.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here