Universal school meals hopes to break down Vermont school meal barriers, raises funding concerns

Posted

FRANKLIN COUNTY — In the cafeteria of Georgia Elementary and Middle School, students line up to receive their lunch trays. It looks like a typical school lunch, but something is different from years past, when student pin numbers were loaded with money or dollars were held out to lunch ladies. 

Today’s lunch special? Korean barbecue. The cost? Free. Now, under Act 64, otherwise known as the universal school meals program, students across Vermont eat breakfast and lunch at no cost. 

And a few weeks into the school year, educators are already seeing the impact. Not only is the program aimed at reducing hunger, but also getting rid of stigmas and enhancing student learning. 

The question now: how sustainable is it?

History of Act 64

Passed by the Vermont legislature this past May, Act 64 went into effect without Gov. Phil Scott’s signature and guarantees “universal school meals” — breakfast and lunch to all public school students free of charge in Vermont. 

Rep. Erin Brady (D-Williston), vice chair of the house committee on education and a co-sponsor of Act 64, said the push for universal school meals has been around for years. A longtime goal of the organization Hunger Free Vermont as well as other legislators, the COVID-19 pandemic accelerated the push towards the program. 

Universal school meals became the reality for schools nationwide in 2021, thanks to federal funding from the Consolidated Appropriations Act and the American Rescue Plan Act. 

But the federal program ended after the end of the 2022-23 school year, so the Vermont legislature decided to implement Act No. 151, providing free breakfast and lunch to all Vermont public school students during the 2022-23 school year. Act 64, which is wholly similar to Act No. 151, implements the universal school meals program on a permanent basis. 

“Suddenly, the idea of going back to the old, I would say, inferior, kind of broken system, became much more acute,” Brady said. “And so that certainly helped create the urgency and the momentum that we had two years ago to do a one-year extension, and then this past year to make it permanent.”

With Act 64 and universal school meals here to stay in Vermont, educators are asking about the sustainability of the program’s funding. 

Sustainable funding

As passed by the Vermont Senate, Act 64 appropriates $29 million in fiscal year 2024 from the state education fund to the universal school meals program. This estimated amount of funding assumes student participation rates of 45% for breakfast and 65% for lunch across the state. 

Brady said adding the universal school meals program to the top of the education fund for FY2024 was the “cleanest” way to do it. 

“It’s just rolled into the [education] fund right now,” she said. “The education fund is so robust and running in surpluses so that’s a very manageable piece. Of course, over time we’ll have to see how that may change.” 

BFA-Fairfax elementary school principal Tom Walsh has concerns about how sustainable the funding is on a multi-year basis. 

“This is a fantastic thing, but can we sustain it? Can we do this over time? Because if not, I worry it will be more challenging to go back,” Walsh said. “I worry that this will be a quick thing and they’ll not be able to pay for it, and we’ll be back to where we were.” 

The universal school meals program is ultimately federal; Vermont is one of nine states to sign on to implement the program this year. With that in mind, Brady said requiring Vermont schools to go through the federal program allows the legislature to maximize federal funding.

“As more and more states continue to do it, eventually it could become an entirely federal endeavor, but at least, I don’t see us losing the federal funding, I see us gaining more federal funding, bringing down the cost to the state,” Brady said. 

While Act 64 provides free breakfast and lunch to all Vermont students, application forms for  free and reduced school meals are still being sent out. If the forms are filled out, Vermont schools are eligible for reimbursement for those meals from the federal government, based on income. 

The free and reduced school meal forms include details on a family’s income, sources of income, number of children and other information to determine eligibility. 

Georgia Elementary and Middle School (GEMS) director of communications Corrina Favreau said that of the free and reduced school meal forms sent home on the first day of school, about 50% of them have been turned in to the school, showing a need in Georgia for school-provided meals. 

BFA-St. Albans principal Polly Rico said it is imperative that her school receives free and reduced school meals forms back from parents to get this federal funding. 

“A lot of families are thinking, ‘Oh, it’s free, the state’s paying for it, why do I have to fill out these forms?’ But what we really want to communicate is that it’s a result of these forms that the state receives more money from the federal government,” Rico said. “The more we can support this program the better, but in order to do that, we really need those forms to come back.” 

Yet Rico and BFA-St. Albans food service provider Megan Lavalley also said that the forms are often exhaustive, leading to parents often not wanting to fill them out, even with an online application option. 

Rico said that, the more free and reduced school meals forms that are turned in, the more data that can be returned to the government to understand the need for the program. 

“If schools start being more directed towards being data driven, the more data we can collect that this is in fact important and needed, the more that we can communicate to the legislature that this is something that we absolutely need not to get rid of,” Rico said. 

Implementation in local schools

GEMS director of teaching and learning Karen Lehning said that Act 64 has allowed for a much greater number of GEMS students to have free breakfast and lunch provided. 

Previously, GEMS had about 130 students, based on income, qualifying for free and reduced lunch. Now, about 630 students are able to participate in the universal school meals program at the Georgia school daily. 

The school has plenty of options for the students to choose from; look around, and you’ll see a mix of salads, soups, pizzas, yogurt parfaits and daily lunch specials for students to stack their plates with. 

Similarly, at BFA-St. Albans, around 600 students are provided with the free breakfast and lunch option everyday.  And like at GEMS, the food options are plentiful. 

BFA-St. Albans offers a daily lunch special to students, such as a turkey sandwich and mashed potatoes, as well as more permanent fixtures like hamburgers, hot dogs, housemade pizzas and deli sandwiches, as well as a soup bar and a salad bar. 

Lavalley said that with the students knowing their families won’t be paying for their meals, it may make them more likely to choose more adventurous food options.

“That’s what I have noticed, that kids seem way more exploratory,” she said. 

BFA-Fairfax has similar options to the two schools when it comes to lunch. Walsh said that one positive he sees coming from Act 64 is its normalization of the free school meals at his Fairfax school. 

Reducing stigmas 

Elementary and middle school students are especially cognizant of what their peers are thinking, and having breakfast and lunch offered for free universally can reduce some stigma against students who might have been in the free and reduced lunch program, Walsh said. 

“When every kid is eating a meal, it destigmatizes the student or the family that looks as though they’re getting something different or something special. Taking away that stigma is really helpful,” he said. 

Brady agrees.

“If you had a really high poverty school, it may have been the culture that a lot of kids were eating in, but in a school where it’s really mixed, it may have been that taking that lunch was sort of an identifier of, ‘I may be low income’,” Brady said.

At BFA-St. Albans, just a few years ago, students who were on the free and reduced lunch program would receive a different meal than other students, marking them visibly as being part of the program. 

Though the school stopped giving free and reduced lunch recipients different meals five years ago, Rico said she never wants to see another student at her school having to worry about their parents being called regarding their school lunch account being in overdraft.

“We never ever want to see that again. Or to take a tray away from a child, because that used to have to happen too if they were over their limit of charges,” she said. 

Lehning said that that same pressure surrounding free and reduced lunches is also alleviated at GEMS through Act 64. 

“We’re a pre-K to eighth [grade] building, and I think as students go into the middle school, there’s more of a stigma attached to anything that identifies them as being different to their peers,” she said. “For some students, that anxiety they felt going through the lunch line is now dissolved.” 

County and statewide need

Though Gov. Scott allowed Act 64 to become law in May, he did not sign the bill, stating in an announcement that it was not fair to raise taxes on Vermonters to provide meals to students who come from wealthy families. The bill will result in a property tax rate increase of $0.03. 

Brady said that while similar sentiments were a concern in the legislature, Vermont students are not required to eat the meals provided for them by the school. 

“It’s not forced meals, it’s free meals,” she said.

Brady also said there is not similar pushback to other resources, such as laptops and bussing, being provided to Vermont students regardless of socioeconomic status. 

“We don’t say, ‘If you make this much money, you don’t need the school laptop.’ We don’t say, ‘You’re going to have to pay for the bus ride, because you live on this street’,” she said. 

With two out of five Vermonters experiencing hunger according to Hunger Free Vermont, Favreau said that there is real need for Act 64; not only at her Georgia school, but across Franklin County and the state at-large. 

“What it’s enabling is a whole student body to get what might be their only warm meal until the next day when they’re back at school,” Favreau said. 

With studies showing that food insecurity affects the ability of students nationwide to learn effectively, Rico and Lavalley said that providing BFA-St. Albans students with nutritious meals on a daily basis is essential. 

“A lack of food is an actual barrier to learning…it goes together,” Rico said. 

Lehning said that good nutrition, provided to students through universal school meals, is a crucial factor in ensuring Vermont public school students receive the best education possible. 

“What we hope is all students in our building have everything they need to be successful everyday, to have their needs met,” she said. “A piece of that is ensuring they have access to high quality meals so it’s not having an impact on their ability to access their education.” 

school, school lunch, act 64, universal school meals, education

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here