ST. ALBANS — Just 31 years ago the train tracks crossing Lake Street would rumble and shake as folks on the passenger train stopped in the city before heading up to Montreal.
Now, the tracks are much quieter with no passenger trains going northbound.
Amtrak’s Vermonter line replaced the once crossborder Montrealer service in 1995 and it made St. Albans the end of the line. With that change, the state lost a direct, easy connection to its northerly neighbors.
There are plans to bring back the rail line, however, it’s incredibly slow moving and requires coordination between the State of Vermont, Canada and the U.S. government.
Bringing the line back could give St. Albans and the greater Franklin County area an economic boost, with more people stopping to dine and shop.
“I think stopping here, going here and coming back, I don’t really see a downside to it — at least not yet anyway — it can only be good,” Maureen Brown, chair of St. Albans’ downtown board said.
From 1972 when Amtrak took over the Montrealer to its retirement in 1995, the tracks were in rough shape leading to a number of derailments, including a wreck in 1984 between Williston and Essex where five of the train’s thirteen cars fell into a stream.
Eventually, hearing demand for a daytime train service, and amid a budget crisis, Amtrak and the State of Vermont created the modern day Vermonter starting and ending in St. Albans and Washington D.C.
Today, Vermonters wanting to head to Montreal via rail take a slow route. Starting in Burlington, the Ethan Allen Express takes passengers south to New York State, where passengers hop off and get on the Adirondack line to go back north on the other side of Lake Champlain.
“Right now, the Vermonter goes all the way to D.C. and N.Y.C. and structures up to St. Albans stopping short of the border, but if you add the Montreal knot to it, it adds a major metropolitan area with a lot of people interested in traveling,” said Sean Jeans-Gail, vice president of government affairs and policy for the advocacy group Rail Passengers Association.
Add in those in smaller cities and towns without a municipal airport close by but are a part of the rail corridor and the route could connect people, markets and communities with more services without air or freeway traffic.
But, before those beneficial connections make an appearance, the line needs governments to work together.
Starting in 2012, the U.S. government lit the fire for rejoining the two countries via the Vermonter using $7.9 million to upgrade the existing rail lines between St. Albans and the Canadian border. By 2014, the tracks were restored.
One year later, both countries signed on to an agreement allowing for the establishment of a pre-clearance customs and immigration facility in Montreal. Riders on the Adirondack currently stop at the border for immigration procedures.
Following delays on both sides of the border, the pre-clearance facility remains the largest bump in the road for the Vermonter today.
“The current next step is the need for a design set of engineering plans for station renovations,” said Dan Delabruere, Vermont Agency of Transportation’s rail director. “We do not have a timeline for this as it is a very complicated set of plans. We are still several years away from construction of the new station and pre-clearance facility in Montreal.”
On the Canadian side, Tim Warmington, a spokesperson for Public Safety Canada, said a feasibility study in 2024 examined whether Montreal Central Station could host a pre-clearance facility and came to the conclusion more studies are needed before any work can get done.
“The government of Canada continues to be supportive of pre-clearance expansion in Canada, including at this location, provided that all the conditions associated with establishing and maintaining pre-clearance operations are met,” Warmington said.
While the work remains slow going, Elisabeth St. Onge, a spokesperson for Sen. Peter Welch (D-Vt.), said the senator remains in close communication with officials and advocates for the facility to drive economic growth in Vermont.
Along with the expansion north, the Vermonter could be getting a whole refresh as Amtrak is currently working to roll out new Airo trainsets to replace the aging Amfleet cars which have been in use for the last 40-to-50 years.
Indeed, an expansion of rail adds valuable economic benefits to the state. In a study from the Rail Passengers Association on a potential extension of the Downeaster train in Maine north to Bangor, the association found it would deliver $61.7 million in annual benefits.
“What we do when we do that kind of analysis is try and come up with one-time benefits that come with construction, building new stations and paying construction worker salaries to local governments, but then also recurring benefits which come from paying people to operate and maintain trains,” Jeans-Gail said.
Though the association hasn’t done a study on the Vermonter, Jeans-Gail said the picturesque landscapes of Vermont add into the recurring benefits and by giving people access from Montreal to Vermont, a lot of tourist dollars could be coming in.
In a similar sense, Amtrak opened up a newly-restored line in the south last year called the Mardi Gras connecting Mobile, Alabama to New Orleans. When the line was first proposed, Jeans-Gail said there was some resistance from the smaller city in Alabama, which feared investing in the infrastructure would not have a substantial return.
“There was a city councilor in Mobile who said no one will want to use the train because no one wants to come to Mobile. This guy was someone who lived there and was elected to serve the interests of Mobile and still didn’t see the interest in connecting travel markets to the downtown city he lived in,” Jeans-Gail said.
Since the Mardi Gras line launched in August, however, Jeans-Gail said the train has wildly overshot the original estimates Amtrak had for ridership, almost doubling and running out of seats.
“It goes to show there is this kind of demand for convenience and comfort to travel to smaller towns with a certain degree of charm, and if Amtrak — through public investment — can provide that connection, these small towns will be in a better place financially, have more sustainable tourists and be more viable to live long-term,” he said.
A strengthened connection up north could also allow the State of Vermont to save a few bucks on on road maintenance — an area currently causing headaches for the state.
“There are also the benefits of diverting cars off of highways, which reduces costs of road maintenance, reduces automotive crashes and costs of injuries and fatalities,” Jeans-Gail said.
Either way, Jeans-Gail said the logistics for a pre-clearance facility, in his eyes, are not too complicated, it’s rather an investment in cooperation and commitment to the project. The wheels are in motion, he said, with clear heads and clearly described benefits, the project could be leaving the station sooner than later.
Ridership on America’s rails continues to grow with Amtrak hitting a record 34.5 million riders in 2025 breaking its own record set just one year prior. The St. Albans portion of the Vermonter has seen growth since the COVID-19 pandemic as well, providing rides for nearly 4,000 people last year.
These rail corridors connect passengers efficiently from bigger cities to smaller towns just by virtue of traveling on the ground and being an efficient use of space. In the last 60 years, Jeans-Gail said U.S. transportation development has been intensely focused on highways and air travel, hollowing out the Main Streets in small towns.
“So much of how we developed our transportation system involved bypassing and flying over and around Main Street America,” he said. “We have this unique opportunity in developing passenger trail corridors to connect people to these spaces they might not know about.”
People will choose not to drive eight hours in peak Vermont leaf peeping season, Jeans-Gail said, but a comfortable seat with a ride that drops them off into the heart of downtown makes tourists more willing to do those trips.
It’s something Brown, the downtown board chair, has been thinking about.
Even though St. Albans is currently the end of the line, there are riders who hop off downtown to hang out for a couple days and experience the area. A lot of people, Brown said, have told her they come up on the train because they know there’s a hotel downtown and most of the attractions are nearby and walkable.
“The downtown board is looking at ways to promote that through advertising with Amtrak or whatnot to capture some of that leisure business,” Brown said. “Once people get to St. Albans there’s nothing but wonderful comments about what the city looks like, the vibe and restaurants. People really do like St. Albans, they just don’t know about us, so we need to get the word out.”
Had Montreal not withdrawn as a host city for the 2026 World Cup and the train connection was in place, Jeans-Gail said it would be the perfect example of how a crossborder train would help both countries and small towns between.
On the local level, Brown said the Vermont Maple Festival has always been a draw for Canadian tourists and the train connection to Montreal would allow for easier access to those looking to take a day trip to experience the festivities.
For a historical aspect, that old Montrealer line? It used to have a reputation as a “party line” due to the large number of skiers taking the train up and down to experience winter recreation in Quebec and Vermont.
When the connection resumes someday, Brown said the hope is for vacationers to extend their trip to St. Albans beyond a day or two.
“I think there are ways we can grow other businesses in St. Albans if that happens, whether through rental cars or taxi kinds-of-things or shuttles to cities in different outlying areas, if that were to become a reality, to be a destination place,” she said.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here