ST. ALBANS — Proposals on how to change policy to fix the ongoing crisis in the dairy industry for the longterm are still coming in to Dairy Proposals 2018, a website established by Agri-Mark to make the options available for all dairy farmers to read.
Most of the proposals fall into two camps: stabilizing the supply or changing the price formula. There are some other options, as well, such as paying farmers to build top soil to help manage floods and reduce nutrient runoff.
The fluctuation in dairy prices which has plagued farmers since the Reagan-era “reforms” of the pricing formula are largely caused by oversupply with just a small excess supply lowering the price paid to farmers dramatically.
Unfortunately for the industry, farmers are caught in a trap in which what is beneficial for the individual farmer – producing more milk – is bad for the industry as a whole.
When prices are high, farmers make more milk to try and take advantage of the high prices while they last. When prices fall, farmers produce more milk in an effort to earn enough to cover their fixed costs in land, buildings and equipment, while still paying utility bills and payroll.
For a decade, many farmers, including several from Franklin County, have argued that a supply management system which would discourage farmers from overproducing is desperately needed. Because such as system could be viewed as a violation of anti-trust law if farmers, or their cooperatives working in concert, did it themselves, they need the assistance of the federal government.
One of the oldest methods farmers have used to reduce supply, paying farmers to slaughter their herds, has been the target of anti-trust suits. The program was implemented by a group of cooperatives working together.
Controlling supply
Dairy economist and Agri-Mark Vice President Bob Wellington has put forth a supply management proposal in which farmers would have a production base determined by their historic production. When prices drop below $20 per hundredweight of milk, that base would be reduced. In addition, the price farmers receive for any production over the base would be reduced. The lower the prices go, the greater the price penalties and the more the base would shrink.
The base would be determined monthly with a three year average for that month. For example, the August 2018 base would be based on August production in 2017, 2016 and 2015. However, once the base was set, that’s where it would remain until the all-milk price was above $20 per hundredweight for an entire year. At that point, farmers could choose to recalculate their base based on new production numbers.
Bases would not be transferrable. All new farms would receive a base of 1,000,000 pounds.
The Wisconsin Farmers Union has revived the Dairy Price Stabilization Program (DPSP) from nearly a decade ago, when farmers last took a serious run at creating a supply management program.
In its proposal, the union argues that changes in dairying have made it much easier for farmers to ramp up production in response to higher prices, or a need to produce more to offset lower prices. In addition, the only way to lower the supply has been for farms to go out of business. But each downturn leaves only the most efficient farmers standing. As a result, “each new downturn has to be that much more severe in order to get a supply reduction. Eventually, after collectively sacrificing billions of dollars enough production is removed from the industry and the price recovers, only to start the cycle all over.”
Authors of the DPSP wanted to reduce volatility while not creating barriers for new farmers or a new asset in a production base.
Under the DPSP:
The DPSP was also proposed by the Holstein Association, USA.
Two Franklin County farmers, Jacques Rainville and Phil Parent, have issued a proposal that cuts to the heart of the issue quickly. They propose that the Federal Milk Marketing Order administrators immediately instruct farmers in their orders to lower production by 15 percent and to keep that order in place for the next six months. If prices have not risen to the average production nationwide, then the order would remain in place for another six months.
They also call on the U.S. Secretary of Agriculture to form a commission with farms of all sizes and from all of the milk marketing orders to draft two proposals for addressing supply, at least one of which should include a two-tiered base system. Farmers would then be given the opportunity to vote on the two proposals, with the winner sent on to Congress.
A proposal from farmer James Larkin would combine a base system with a surcharge on dairy products of 5-10 percent which would go directly to farmers. He said the industry should be transparent about the reasons for the surcharge and where it is going.
Another approach focusing on post-production excess supply comes from the Dairy Pricing Association, a cooperative that attempts to manage supply by purchasing and donating dairy products to reduce oversupply. The focus of their efforts is block cheddar cheese.
Membership is voluntary and interested farmers can learn more at www.dairyprosposals2018.com
Changing the price formula
On the price side, the National Family Farm Coalition Dairy Committee proposed the Casey Act, named for former Pennsylvania Senator Bob Casey who authored the bill, but was unable to get it passed.
Under the Casey proposal, the class system would be reduced from four classes to two. Class I would be for fluid milk and Class II for manufacturing, regardless of whether the milk was used for cheese, powder or ice cream.
The Class II price would become the average cost of production nationwide. The Class I price would be the Class II price plus the Class I differential in each order. The USDA would set the differential for states, such as California, which are outside the order system.
The make allowance – in which farmers are charged to help pay the cost of manufacturing facilities such as the St. Albans Cooperative Creamery’s milk powder facility – would end.
An inventory management system, which can only be implemented if imports exceed exports, would pay farmers half of the Class II price on up to five percent of their production.
New farmers would be exempt from the inventory management system for the first full year of production.
The National Family Farm Coalition has already lobbied the government to set a floor price of $20 per hundredweight on milk used for manufacturing and to begin purchasing excess dairy products.
More controversially, the coalition called for a temporary moratorium on the use of federal dollars from the EQIP for projects at confined animal feeding operations (CAFOs).
The coalition has also asked for immediate hearings on the dairy crisis and for Congress to pass and implement the supply management program killed by then-House Speaker John Boehner.
Other options
A group called LandStream, Inc. proposed paying farmers to build top soil in order to improve watersheds and ecosystems. Those topsoils would benefit communities by reducing nutrient runoff and flood risk, removing carbon dioxide from the air and trapping it in the soil, and recharging groundwater.
There are more proposals than could be covered here. Those interested should visit www.dairyproposals2018.com where all of the proposals are posted. Readers have the option of asking questions and commenting on the proposals.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here