FRANKLIN COUNTY – It’s the same old song and dance. Twice a year we change the clocks, but is daylight savings still needed in 2025?
The jury is still out; opinions are varied.
Taking it back to its original intentions, the biannual change was meant to help conserve energy, though research shows today we use more. There is also the long-held myth that it was designed to help farmers, but the industry today is mixed on the issue..
“Do I think it needs to continue? No. I don’t,” said Wendy Brouillette, owner of Breezy Acres Farm in Montgomery.
The advent of daylight savings actually had nothing to do with farmers. Instead, it was born out of wartime necessities. Copying the Germans from a few years prior, the U.S. implemented Daylight Savings Time in 1918 before repealing it just one year later.
The U.S. reinstated the system permanently during World War II. States at the time set their own dates for when to switch between the standards until Congress stepped in with the Uniform Time Act in 1966.
Only two states ignore the time shift — Arizona and Hawaii.
Perhaps the greatest defender of the energy argument is Benjamin Franklin.
Franklin is credited with the idea after he observed people sleeping during the sun-lit mornings and burning candles for light in the evening. He would go on to argue if people changed their schedules to be active earlier in the day during the summer months — when the day is longest — wax could be saved.
In 2025, however, the argument seems to have shifted.
“The [Vermont Division of Efficiency and Energy Resources] department doesn’t have analysis on energy savings from Daylight Savings Time, mostly because the prevailing wisdom is that it doesn’t save energy,” director Alek Antczak said.
Ironically, there’s research on the time switch’s effects on health, safety economics and even stock market performance, yet very little on energy consumption, Antczak said. Rather he pointed to research done by a University of Vermont alum and another researcher at Yale from 2011.
In the study, the two researchers took aim at Indianna, looking into energy consumption during daylight savings time.
The duo found that contrary to popular belief, the change resulted in a 1% increase in residential electricity demand.
“In particular, Daylight Savings Time causes the greatest increase in consumption later in the year, with October estimates ranging from an increase of 2% to nearly 4%,” the researchers wrote.
While the time switch in the spring does decrease the electricity needed for lighting a room, it increases the energy needed for heating and cooling. Over the course of the year, the researchers found it costs the residents of Indiana close to $9 million in increased electric bills.
Although just a rumor, the “farmers fought for daylight savings” myth has stayed prevalent in the cultural zeitgeist. In reality, Vermont’s farmers are mixed on the idea.
For some, like Brouillette, there’s no real upsides to the change.
“We hate it actually,” she said. “We only like it this time of year because the sun comes out earlier, but the days get shorter.”
The Montgomery farm, however, is juxtaposed to the Blodgett Family Farm in Fairfax which has a far more favorable view of daylight savings.
“For Vermont, [it should continue] because I don’t want it to be dark at eight something in the morning,” Dawn Blodgett said. “If you think about it, the sun comes up in December around seven in the morning. If we didn't turn the clocks back it would be at eight.”
When it comes to the actual work benefits, however, the two farmers said it really doesn’t change what they do.
At Breezy Acres, Brouillette said the animals feel a slight change, but it’s minimal. Chickens meander into the coop earlier as daylight gets shorter, the pigs go to bed early and the cattle wander in before dark.
But mostly, the change in routine hits the farmers themselves.
“[We do] evening chores a little earlier because we don’t want to be out in the dark,” Brouillette said.
Down in Fairfax, Blodgett said their work is not as impacted because it's more pattern-based. The animals follow routine, and so do the farmers throughout the year.
“For a farmer, we milk at four in the morning and three in the afternoon so it's still dark for us,” she said. “I can get so much more done in the morning without daylight than in the evening when it's dark.”
Really, Blodgett said the cows don’t know time, it’s all patterns. Farmers adjust their milking schedules to the cows as well as seasonal practices.
Both farmers, however, agree completely on one thing; it’s time to put the myth to bed.
“[Daylight savings] wasn’t for farmers. It's a huge misconception that it was brought in to help the farmers when it actually wasn’t,” Blodgett said.
This year, over five dozen pieces of legislation regarding the seasonal time changes were introduced in state legislatures across the U.S. While no bills on the topic came up in Vermont, some states have already put their residents on a path to permanent daylight savings time, pending federal approval or action.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here