The troubled history of Fairfax’s water/wastewater system

Posted

FAIRFAX – Back in December, Fairfax was forced to take “immediate corrective action” on its water and sewer utilities. 

Why? 

Long story short, some residents are arguing that Fairfax’s utilities have been mismanaged for more than two decades, costing Fairfax revenue and long-term growth opportunities. And now, a central player in a previous court saga — Jeff Blake — is running for selectboard this Town Meeting Day. 

The Messenger made multiple attempts to reach Blake for this story, but he did not respond to comment. 

A public meeting about Fairfax’s water and wastewater systems is scheduled for March 26. While residents await more information from the Town of Fairfax and the results of a state inquiry, here’s what to know about the history of the problem. 

Uncovering the issues 

Last summer, odors from the town’s aging wastewater facility on Hunt Street began to cloud over the municipality. What followed was a months-long endeavor by former public works director Brent Sheets to clean up and improve the system. 

“I’m trying to fix everything at once, which is hard and difficult but it needs to be done,” Sheets told the Messenger in August. 

While working on the system, Sheets said he discovered it had been over a decade since the stinky sludge layer at the bottom of the lagoons had been cleared. In total, the town dug out 21,000 gallons of sludge in three tanker trucks. That work cost the town an additional $9,000. 

Just three months later in October, Fairfax’s utilities were back on the selectboard’s agenda. 

This time, Sheets uncovered a prohibition on water connection allocations which started in 2002, but was never lifted. Because of issues in the town’s system then, the selectboard put a self-imposed moratorium on both water and wastewater. 

While the town still approved wastewater allocations regardless, the moratorium on water has blocked new customers from hooking up to the system and stopped new revenue from funding needed upgrades. 

Adding to the confusion, the water facility is not close to capacity, Sheets said at the time, with the town able to run 72,576 gallons a day but using an average of 34 to 36,000 gallons.  

All the problems added up to a tipping point in December when Town Manager Mike Bishop was forced to take “immediate corrective action” on the town’s utilities and entered into a contract with Laramie Water Resources to take over management of the system while the state evaluates its needs, addresses compliance issues and implements improvements. 

A private developer, however, is worried about what the selectboard might do next. After dealing with an extended lawsuit with the Town of Fairfax that stretched almost three years, Gabe Handy alleges Blake could return to the board and cause even more difficulties for Fairfax’s growth, including discouraging developers and costing the town more legal fees. 

Water wars

In 2006, when Handy took on a senior housing project on Old Academy Street, questions and accusations around water led to lawsuit after lawsuit across three courts, two years and four judges. 

The results: Fairfax had to pay Handy’s attorney fees and damages including late fees and interest which Handy told the Messenger totaled over $200,000. But, the town couldn’t pay the steep price tag and instead negotiated a way out. 

As a result, Fairfax gave the Handy development two years of free sewer, beginning the process of the town subsidizing the system and not having a fully user-sustained utility. 

Nearly 20 years later, Handy said the actions taken by the selectboard at the time left a bad taste in other developers' mouths, most-likely eating into profits Fairfax could have had. 

“It was a bad experience. It was all over the news,” Handy told the Messenger Feb. 17. “A lot of people chose to hook up a well and do on-site septic.”

Central to the lawsuit was the suitable number of water meters for the 47-unit senior housing complex. According to Messenger reporting at the end of 2006, lawsuits quickly diverged from the original topic to more personal issues with alleged civil rights violations and age and racial discrimination. After the town and Handy couldn’t find middle ground, he sued Fairfax that December. 

Heading into the suit, Handy and the town were already quarreling around water rights. According to court documents submitted Sept. 13 of that year, the town had cut off water to the property at the beginning of the month. 

Fairfax’s water superintendent Randy DeVine was told to “shut the f***ing water off” by then selectboard chair Jeff Blake over water pressure testing, according to Handy’s attorney. After the test was submitted, water was turned off again over a “punchlist” of items including the meters, which led to the suit.

In the first court decision, made at the Chittenden County Superior Court under Judge Matthew Katz, the Town of Fairfax was court-ordered to install 95 meters and turn on the water, with Handy to pay for half of them. 

Following the decision, Fairfax counter-sued Handy, accused Katz of bias and brought a civil issue to the Franklin County Superior Court, alleging Handy or those employed by him removed a lock-out device and stole water from the town. As a result, Handy’s attorney accused the town of “Boss Hogg” culture. 

“Anyone who dares challenge this absolution will be subject to the campaign of bullying which, if necessary, will be directed even at the judiciary,” attorney John Franco Jr wrote. 

Judge Alden T. Bryan turned down a motion related to the case and said the ordeal had become one big “waste of money.” But then, Franco noted the town had still not followed the first court decision. 

By May 2007, Fairfax residents raised their voices over the heated dispute and asked for the selectboard to work to settle the issue as legal costs kept increasing. At the time, the selectboard made a motion to give the idea a try voting 4-1 with Blake the sole opposer. 

Any attempt for peace, however, was forgotten quickly at the end of May when the selectboard appealed, filing a motion to set aside the order to install Handy’s meters and turn on the water while denying any discrimination allegations. 

Weeks later, Judge Katz took a field trip to the Handy development, spending an hour in the building, looking at the water system configurations and listening to plumbing experts. Afterwards, he instructed the town to turn on the water immediately. 

Finally in July, the senior housing units opened with Vermont Gov. Jim Douglass and state representative Carolyn Branagan (R-Georgia) helping cut the ribbon. 

“I know there have been a few bumps in the road, but I know everyone appreciates your persistence,” Douglass said to Handy. “It’s going to make a lot of difference to a lot of folks. This is the first opportunity of this kind in this area. It really will mean a lot to a lot of Vermonters.”  

Man in charge

Although it was a town decision to sue and counter sue, Handy lays a lot of blame at the feet of Blake. He was chair of the selectboard when the first lawsuit was filed.

“It felt like the Gestapo. He was running the town and nobody dared stand up, they were all afraid of him. When he came, the town office was all shaking, one miserable S.O.B,” Handy said. “God help Fairfax if he gets elected again. He will set the town 20 years in the rear, if not more.” 

According to court documents filed by Handy’s lawyer at the time, there was a mob-like mentality around the project from the selectboard to town staff, and threats were common if people didn’t fall in line. 

In the documents, selectboard members had allegedly told then zoning administrator Charles Taylor his job was in jeopardy if he granted the project a certificate of occupancy to begin leasing units. 

DeVine, who was on the selectboard at that time, also cast a lone vote in support of Handy in an earlier meeting. He was later told by a board member that the town was looking to replace him as water superintendent with a private contractor. 

The Messenger made multiple efforts to speak to Blake, but he could not be reached for comment to confirm or deny the allegations. 

Handy, however, argues the lawsuits the town got into were allegedly caused and catalyzed by a personal disagreement between him and Blake. According to Handy, a Christmas party at the Blakes’ started with the two as friends with common goals in mind, but ended with the two in a bitter rivalry. 

Still in the midst of the Old Academy Street project, Handy said he had to turn down the idea to develop property owned by Blake at the time. That event, Handy alleged, started the whole dispute. 

“When I went to the meeting to get water turned on a week later, he went from someone who called me once a week to chat with me as a friend – I walked into a hornets nest,” Handy said. 

Handy is now warning town residents to avoid placing Blake back into power where he said he can hinder progress and growth. 

“The town needs to know,” Handy said, clarifying why he wanted to speak publicly. “A lot of new people in Fairfax and this goes back 20 years. A lot has been done since then and Fairfax has grown 50%, so a lot of new people don’t know what happened with this guy, but it needs to be highlighted.”

water utilities, jeff blake, fairfax, gabe handy, selectboard

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here