ST. ALBANS — A 64-year-old woman in Newbury. A 13-year-old rider in Swanton. A 16-year-old Burlington teen killed on Pine Street. And a juvenile in Weathersfield just this past week.
Each one was involved in an accident while riding an e-bike.
Almost everyone has seen the vehicles zipping around town as e-bikes and e-motos become a semi-regular sight on Vermont’s streets. And in response, city officials across the state have heard concerns from residents, catalyzing public discussions in St. Albans, Colchester, Winooski as well as both Burlington and South Burlington in recent weeks.
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, too, has tagged their increasing popularity as an emerging issue.
“The landscape of vehicles and their abilities is changing so dramatically that the pace of change for tech is changing faster than they can regulate it and plan for infrastructure that supports it,” transportation engineer Corey Mack explained.
And it’s happening everywhere. Even in the bike-loving Netherlands, Amsterdam instituted a ban of “fatbikes” — a type of e-bike known for their wide wheels and speeds of up to 25 mph — just this past May to curb dangerous behaviors.
But will laws make them go away? It’s hard to say.
The new landscape of fast-moving electric bikes has come to Vermont — and the rest of the world — thanks to a confluence of cheap parts, targeted ads and emerging transportation demands. Drivers may need to adjust accordingly.
The first reference in the Messenger to the modern “automobile” made it into an article published in 1896, as part of a carnival attraction associated with Barnum & Bailey’s street parade. At the time, they were introducing the wonders of the “horseless” age.
Two years later, general commentators were sharing their thoughts in the paper about upcoming changes in transportation needs.
“Motor vehicles are evidently bound to come into more general use in this country,” the Messenger reported in 1898. “It is probable that the story of horseless traction will, in a sense, repeat the history of bicycling, which made small headway during the first few years following its introduction.”
In the same way, e-bikes have been around for a few decades, but there’s been an increasing interest as they’ve gotten cheaper and more capable. The most recent spikes of concern, however, likely align with the emergence of what many bike experts are labeling “e-motos.”
Unlike a typical e-bike, e-motos are made to go faster — usually over speeds of 30 mph — and they’re outfitted with footpegs instead of pedals. In many ways, they’re more like motorcycles, or mopeds.
At Bootlegger Bikes in downtown St. Albans, Josh Schneider doesn’t sell e-motos, but his staff is used to talking to people interested in e-bikes. The typical customer tends to be older, usually over the age of 50, and they’re interested in how the electric bicycles can help them enjoy riding again. The customers may have mobility issues, or maybe they don’t have as much interest sweating over big hills as they used to, Schneider said.
To help, he’ll recommend either a Class 2 or Class 3 e-bike, which differ by degrees depending on how the pedal-assist function works with an onboard wrist throttle. E-bikes are also regulated, with industry standards set to ensure that onboard batteries and the overall systems that rely on them are safe and reliable.
And then there are e-motos, which are unregulated.
Schneider will sometimes get younger people in Bootlegger taking a closer look at what the shop has available, and they’ll ask questions, trying to learn more about specific models. Some of the e-motos advertised to teens are brands he’s never heard of before. So Schneider said he jumped online to check out the competition to see if they are legitimate.
“All of a sudden, I’m looking at Amazon, which has bikes for like $500 that say that they qualify for the UL,” he said. “There’s no possible way. It’s either somebody slapping a sticker on it, or they’re just lying.”
To meet the UL standard for batteries, devices are evaluated, tested and certified in order to be safe for customers. Without the designation, consumers don’t know if the battery they’re purchasing could overheat or catch fire.
Schneider suspects the modern Internet, with its hyper-targeted advertising mechanisms, is flooding teens with ads of these models and devices, which can be shipped straight to a person’s home.
“To them, ‘this must be a big brand because it came up in my feed 50 times.’ And I’m like, ‘I’ve never heard of that in my life,’” he said. “And of course, all the reviews on their own website say this is the best thing since sliced bread.”
Local Motion, a transportation advocacy group, has also tracked the emerging phenomenon, especially as parents and institutions increasingly seek out answers about the new devices. Communications specialist Val Cyr said she can also understand the e-moto’s appeal to teens, as their office sits next to the Burlington Greenway, and they regularly see teenagers zooming by together in groups.
For many, the devices give teens an expanded sense of freedom, they said, especially when so much of the United States and Vermont is heavily-wrapped up in car culture. Without a vehicle — especially in car-centric rural areas like Franklin County — it’s hard to do just about anything without wheels.
Younger people worried about having that newfound freedom taken away are likely being a little rebellious when they hear complaints around safety.
“I’ve seen some of the self-policing among them, like the older kids, trying to pump their hands to tell them to slow down. And there’s a bunch of people out there with an awareness that the great world is seeing what they’re doing is wrong,” Cyr said.
Schneider spent a Monday night talking to St. Albans City Council about his experiences with e-bikes, appearing as part of a public discussion held Aug. 10.
According to St. Albans City Mayor Trudy Cioffi, she has been hearing more and more citizen complaints about the machines. As the city considers what to do to ensure people stay safe on the sidewalks, they set aside part of the council meeting to consider regulation suggestions. Residents, too, came out to tell their stories.
“I see kids being totally wreckless,” Melyssa Bailey said. “I was heading down Lake Street one time and this kid came up next to me and looks over to me and says ‘How fast can your bike go?’ I said ‘My bike’s limited at 20.’ He says, ‘Mine will do 40,’ And he just shot right off.”
There are legitimate reasons to have e-motos, as they can function as off-terrain vehicles. One of the top well-known brands, Surron, has a stock model that can breach 70 mph, although it’ll cost you up to $25,000 to access one.
Many of the commentators heard by council, however, were more concerned about the impacts of e-motos on downtown foot traffic, as multiple people told stories of almost getting hit by a speeding e-motorist while they were walking down the sidewalk.
The City of St. Albans does have an ordinance outlawing people riding bikes from the sidewalk, and anyone worried about navigating downtown traffic via the roadway is instructed to walk their bikes through downtown.
For that reason, city residents speaking to city councilors recommended more enforcement to try to chomp down on bad actors instead of expanding on local regulation. In line with Local Motion’s recommendations, residents expect state or national legislatures to eventually step up on regulating the vehicles — maybe even incorporating some sort of training and testing process that’s similar to what registered drivers of motorcycles or mopeds already do.
Even so, Cioffi said the local conversation will likely continue as they try to find a solution. Some younger riders, too, are likely trying to do the right thing, she said, but they may not have the experience or knowledge to navigate the streets safely.
In that case, the answer to safer streets will likely come as more and more people — both automobile drivers and teens — learn more about the devices and change their behaviors accordingly.
The other way to make streets safer is to separate the differing vehicle types by creating multiple paths that fit their behaviors best. But that’s easier said than done, transportation engineer Corey Mack, of METHODS Consulting, said.
He’s been heavily involved in some of the planning processes being completed for St. Albans Town’s Health Path. The infrastructure project aims to connect Collins Perley Sports & Fitness Center with the Hard’Ack Recreation Area via a shared-use path.
Mack has also been watching the increased attention on electric bikes play out, although it’s been hard to track exactly how their introduction has impacted transportation at this point. Due to mostly being available online, e-motos aren’t currently regulated or tracked in any extensive way, so it’s hard to tell how prevalent they’ve become.
Additionally, crash data rarely makes the delineation between an e-moto or e-bike, although accidents on electric bikes have been confirmed to be typically more dangerous than standard bikes due to faster speeds and heavier impacts.
Accidents involving e-motos are likely even more dangerous for the same reasons, although the regulation remains something of a “wild west,” he said.
“Motorcycles are dangerous in their own way. If you wouldn’t expect to see them on a shared-use path, then you shouldn’t expect to see e-motos,” Mack said. “We really don’t want people mixing those speeds.”
With that said, Mack expects people will likely tamp down on dangerous behavior over time, especially as slower e-bikes continue to become more ubiquitous and people start taking notice of the dangers of e-motos. Educating teens and their parents — before they purchase an e-moto based on info from an Internet ad — might too prevent another tragedy.
“E-bikes are not going anywhere. They’ve kind of changed the game and made biking more accessible,” he said.
There’s also plenty of historical precedent that points to a wider-scale adoption of e-bikes, that could mean an increase in demand for things like bike paths or other shared-use connections. In St. Albans, for example, there are at least three under development — one for the east side, one for North Main Street, and one for Federal Street to eventually snake up to the Missisquoi Valley Rail Trail.
“Even with traditional bikes and e-bikes, there’s always been this challenge of shared modes of travel with people,” he said. “You already see ATVs using trails when they shouldn’t. It becomes a matter of enforcement and resources.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here