The care of strangers

Posted

A good friend, from a small town in Vermont, wrote me the following: “Here half the population is griping that the other half of the population won't wear a mask. The non-mask wearers are griping that their fellow citizens want to strip them of their constitutional rights.” As a retired physician and a believer in the good will of Vermonters, I find this disquieting.

So, what about the cloth masks, the surgical masks, and the N95 respirator masks? Who benefits from them?

Healthcare workers benefit from N95 masks. Respirator masks (e.g. N95 masks), if worn continually by healthcare workers are effective in protecting the workers, while surgical masks are not effective, and cloth masks even less effective (MacIntyre et al (Int J Nurs Stud. 2020).

Can masks protect others? The evidence is mixed. One study of nine patients, found that surgical and N95 masks were equally effective in filtering influenza virus (Johnson et al Clin Infect Dis. 2009). A study of four patients showed no effectiveness of surgical or cotton masks in Blocking SARS–CoV-2 (Sung et al Annals of Internal Medicine 2020). These are relatively small studies that seem to support or not support the use of masks to protect others. So, what are the Recommendations?

President Trump announced on March 27th that people in the U.S. should wear face coverings in public to slow the spread of the coronavirus. The World health Organization (WHO) interim guidance (April 2020) suggests persons with symptoms should wear a surgical mask. They stress hygiene, and social distancing, and do not recommend that asymptomatic individuals should wear surgical masks and add that there is no good data on the efficacy of cotton masks. The Vermont Department of Health (April 2020) recommended the use of cloth face coverings to help slow the spread of COVID-19  The Center for Disease Control (CDC) currently recommends wearing cloth face coverings in public settings where other social distancing measures are difficult to maintain (e.g., grocery stores and pharmacies) especially in areas of significant community-based transmission. 

I stand with the CDC, and I am remembering the title of Charles Rosenberg’s book (1987), “The Care Of Strangers: The Rise Of America's Hospital System”. The wearing of a mask in public is not an issue of our constitutional rights, but a sign that we are all in this together and as Vermonter’s we respect each other’s health, and the care of strangers.




Michael Rosengarten


Richford

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here