ST. ALBANS — A first of its kind body mass study conducted last fall in schools throughout Franklin and Grand Isle counties revealed 41 percent of local first, third, and fifth graders are overweight or obese.
Members of the local medical community, along with RiseVT and the Vermont Department of Health partnered with local school districts across Franklin and Grand Isle to conduct a Measurement Study, where they collected the height and weight of students to calculate their body weight index.
“In Vermont we don’t collect BMI data. There’s legislation that says the schools can, but there’s no systematic way to do it. So we knew we had to do something,” said Judy Ashley, district director at the Department of Health.
The goal was to develop valid scientific research data that could possibly represent Vermont as a whole. There was a lack of previous data, and holes that needed to be filled in order to help the county and state conquer the goal made by the RISE Coalition: to increase the overall health of the population by decreasing overweight and obese individuals.
Gathering the Data
The group started meeting in January of 2017 to brainstorm how the study was going to be conducted. Dr. Elisabeth Fontaine, of Northwestern Medical Center, who serves as the Rise VT Medical Director, suggested a method used by the France-based EPODE organization that works to engage the whole community in efforts to combat obesity. Because of its success rate, the EPODE model is now being implemented in more than 500 communities in multiple countries.
“But Vermont is the only EPODE-based model in the United States,” Fontaine said.
The model guided the group to physically go into the schools then measure children in grades 1, 3 and 5. Because of the stigmatization of obesity in general, the group had to tread carefully before proceeding. They sought approval by an institutional review board, an ethics committee designed to approve, monitor and review all research of human subjects.
“We were doing everything we can to make sure no one was harmed or hurt. An important thing to note is that we weren’t looking at individual children. We looked at population, so when we collected the data no names were collected,” Ashley said.
The group was required to go through lengthy training on the equipment and to follow strict protocols so all the data was collected in the same way at each school. The group met with the superintendents beforehand, sent letters to the principals, and to the students’ homes; a script was given the teachers to be read to the students the day the measuring took place.
Schools, parents and students all had the option to opt out of the study. In the end 19 out of 20 schools participated, with only the Grand Isle school not taking part. At total 1,708 were measured, resulting in 89 percent of the possible survey group participating.
The Results
The Measurement Study used the Center for Disease Control and Prevention’s (CDC) definition of overweight and obese. A BMI that falls at or above the 85th percentile is considered overweight and a BMI that is at or above the 95th percentile is considered obese. The overweight and obesity rate for the collective group surveyed was 41 percent.
“That was surprisingly high,” Ashley said.
It’s a shocking statistic in itself- but even more shocking when paired with the CDC’s prediction that two thirds of these children will continue to be overweight throughout their adult life.
Obesity is a risk factor for a variety of chronic conditions, which, according to the Department of Health, are responsible for 56 percent of deaths in Vermont. In 2016, an estimated $2.2 billion was spent on medical care related to chronic illnesses, accounting for 40 percent of the total health care expenditure of $6 billion. The Department of Health predicts costs will continue on this path, increasing 75 percent from 2010 to 2020.
All this comes as the state is working to implement a new health care delivery and insurance program, aimed at making people healthier while ultimately cutting health care costs. Known as the All Payer model, by the year 2020 the majority of health care providers will be paid a flat fee to keep Medicare and Medicaid patients healthy, shifting away from fee-for-service care. As hospitals like Northwestern Medical Center (NMC) work to evaluate the population they will have to serve on a per person basis, the focus is changing from treating sicknesses to preventative care.
With 41 percent of kids at an unhealthy weight, local medical professionals are worried about future trends. But because n o similar studies have been done before in the state, there remains more questions than answers.
“Is obesity happening at a younger age, so therefore when we get into the teenage years are we going to start seeing signs and symptoms of chronic conditions earlier in life? What is our healthcare system going to look like when these kids start facing all these chronic diseases? Healthcare is actually going to balloon higher in cost if we don’t do something about it,” Jill Bowen, NMC CEO said.
This is the fundamental motivation behind the 2015 launch of Rise VT, and the reason community members across the board met to discuss this data. They have the results, and though they may have been startling, the focus now shifts towards change.
Taking Action
“It’s not just the schools that are responsible for fixing this, but they do have a role,” said Denise Smith, project manager at Rise VT.
Part of the success attributed to the EPODE model is the collaboration of the community as a whole. That’s how the group behind the Measurement Study plans to combat these numbers.
Right now the focus is on policy. Smith along with Rise VT team members have been busy meeting with superintendents of schools, presenting at school board meetings, as well as leadership meetings with school principals and other staff members.
“We are working to implement robust wellness policies at every supervisory union and then working with individual classrooms to implement classroom based wellness policies. The goal is to have these groups really valuing a health culture within their communities,” Smith said.
On the classroom level, RiseVT is working to introduce a healthy snack policy for celebrations.
“Think about if you calculate every birthday in every classroom for every year, then multiply that from kindergarten to eighth grade. How many cupcakes would a child eat by the time they graduated?” Smith said.
Another methodology being used is mindfulness breaks.
“We’re constantly reminding teachers how to instill movement breaks and kinesthetic learning into their classrooms,” Smith said.
To measure how well classrooms are participating in wellness policies, RiseVT has developed a scorecard based on the Whole School, Whole Child, Whole Community wellness plan created by the CDC.
“It has all the things we want to see in classroom behavior and change,” Smith said.
Supervisory unions were also strongly encouraged last June by the Agency of Education to develop their own wellness policies. Their policies were then evaluated based off of the CDC’s WellSAT wellness policy evaluation tool.
Right now, the highest scoring wellness policy in the county lives at Franklin West Supervisory Union. In the Measurement Study, FWSU also had the least amount of students with an overweight or obese BMI, and had the highest amount of students at a healthy weight.
“They started two years ago making cultural shifts around wellness, and they’ve really prioritized wellness,” Smith said.
It’s a sign that though the numbers may look bleak, with strong community collaboration and a shift in focus, the future can still be changed.
An unsure future
Vermont’s All Payer Model is aimed at lowering health care costs while improving the overall health of the population. The plan caps annual healthcare spending to a growth rate of 3.5 percent or less, while also outlining three fundamental population health goals: reducing suicide and drug overdose, better access to primary care and decreasing the prevalence of chronic disease over the course of five years, which will be measured by studying the prevalence of hypertension, diabetes and chronic obstructive lung disease — three diseases very much related to obesity.
According to the CDC, over 75 percent of hypertension cases are directly related to obesity and more than 80 percent of people with type-two diabetes are overweight. Dr. Fontaine, one of the few doctors in the world certified in Lifestyle Medicine, says the majority of these diseases are caused by lifestyle choices.
“This is what makes Rise so important, on a prevention front,” Bowen said.
Such programs require investment and often more money, and, as health care is capped at hospitals around the state, it’s putting many medical care providers in a difficult spot.
“The first thing that always goes are the programs that don’t produce money,” Bowen said.
It’s a fact that leaves health care on both the county and state level at a shaky spot. But it’s why local community members from a variety of sectors are gathering together to discuss the importance of this BMI study and the need for change.
“The health care system is not going to be prepared for the actuality if more places across Vermont don’t start measuring these kids,” Smith said.
To subscribe to the Messenger call 802.524.9771 ext. 101.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here