ST. ALBANS – The Vermont State Board of Education approved the final draft of their statewide education plan during a Wednesday morning meeting held in the auditorium at Bellows Free Academy – St. Albans, which includes the consolidation of nine school districts in Franklin County into three unified districts.
In what is likely to be the final meeting of the State Board of Education ahead of their Nov. 30 deadline for issuing a final statewide consolidation plan, the board voted 7-2 to confirm their provisional decisions regarding school mergers made during the weeks leading up to yesterday’s vote.
Only board members John Carroll and William Matthis dissented.
Under their final plan, the state education board confirmed decisions to join Missisquoi Valley Union (MVU) High School’s member districts – Franklin, Highgate and Swanton – into a single unified union district, combine Montgomery and Sheldon with the Northern Mountain Valley Union school district and pair the Richford and Enosburgh school districts together.
The board also approved a statewide default articles of agreement, providing a guiding document for those state-mandated consolidations. Those articles include a mechanism for amendment by respective unified districts, so long as the whole district is allowed to vote on those amendments.
In approving the statewide education plan, the board openly wrestled with historic opposition to mergers in the districts they were consolidating. That conversation stemmed from a prepared statement read by Carroll, who spoke in the wake of the board’s confirmation of its decision to consolidate the MVU district.
“By my count, the state board will impose mergers on more than 30 Vermont communities which have explicitly opposed mergers,” Carroll read from a statement he summarized as ‘Mergers versus the Will of the People.’ “That means thousands of Vermonters are being told, not explicitly in these words, that their votes don’t matter.
“One would certainly think that they should matter,” he said.
Carroll also expressed reservations at what appeared to be a bias from the state board of education against proposals under Act 46’s Section 9, which afforded school districts uninterested in a merger a chance to craft an alternative governance structure (AGS) that could meet Act 46’s goals absent a merger.
Under Act 46, an AGS would have to substantively prove it could meet Act 46’s goals of improving efficiencies and educational opportunities without the requisite merger.
In most of the districts where an Act 46 merger was practicable and a Section 9 proposal was submitted, the state education board decided on consolidation.
Matthis shared Carroll’s reservations, stating that it appeared as though the board took the recommendations of then-Secretary of Education Heather Bouchey’s statewide plan for granted rather than genuinely consider those districts’ proposals under Section 9.
“We have to have some burden of proof… and we never asked for the burden of proof,” Matthis said, using Montgomery, a school that was adding students and where the community voted twice against a merger, as his example.
“The secretary’s report claims no facts had been presented… but they had 84 pages of carefully documented work,” Matthis said, referring to Montgomery’s Section 9 proposal. “The countering facts were never presented… [and] we were working on inadequate information on that.
“Without looking at those [Section 9 proposals] fairly and openly, I don’t think we have done right by this.”
Carroll and Matthis’s comments won applause from the handful of community members – less than a dozen – present to protest a forced merger.
Other members of the board, however, felt strongly that they were in the right on these mergers and defended the fact that they had considered towns’ Section 9 proposals before ultimately agreeing with Bouchey’s recommendations.
According to board member Oliver Olsen, many of those Section 9 proposals didn’t properly map an alternative governance structure and just argued in favor of the status quo. Many of those, he argued, weren’t proper attempts at a Section 9 proposal.
“There were actually relatively few valid Section 9 proposals,” Olsen said. “There were a lot of comments and proposals, but a lot of them weren’t actually technically Section 9 proposals.”
Board member John O’Keefe also wondered how it would be fair to those districts that voluntarily merged under the threat of a forced Act 46 merger if the state education board excused unwanted mergers from its final plan.
“I’m not quite sure how these other communities have come to the realization that if they don’t act… they’ll be excused,” O’Keefe said. “I understand where John [Carroll] is coming from, but at the same time, we have to look at these other towns.
“All these other communities that did merge… what do we tell them?”
As the board continued to parse their final education plan, controversy reared its head again only when it came to the board’s preliminary vote on the Elmore Morristown Union School District and Stowe merger. That merger was one of the few times the board disagreed with the recommendations of Bouchey’s statewide plan, with the board voting in favor of consolidating the two districts.
The decision to uphold that preliminary vote was split down the middle. Four members voted in favor of striking that merger from the statewide plan, and five voted in favor.
Opposition to that merger drew the most protest from the public; two of the three speakers during a public comment section spoke out against the Stowe – EMU merger.
The only other community member to provide public comment was Franklin’s Jay Denault, a former member of the MVU school board who previously helped lead an attempt by some residents of Franklin to close their school in a bid to preclude an Act 46 merger.
“Despite your repeated comments to the contrary, a forced merger will lead to the closure of Franklin school,” Denault said. “You are committing a despicable act against everything we stand for as Vermonters.”
There is no known effort on the part of the state or Franklin’s surrounding communities to close Franklin Central School. Act 46 grants the state no authority to close schools, which may only be done by a vote of the voters in that school district. While rumors circulated that Gov. Phil Scott sought to close schools with populations below 150 people, the Messenger previously confirmed with Gov. Scott’s office that Scott had made no such comment. Nor, of course, does the governor have the power or authority to close schools.
Denault spoke one more time, telling the state board that “the courts will decide” what legal authority the board of education has in the consolidation process before walking out. As the board continued their conversation, Denault left the auditorium.
A final state board of education meeting was warned for Friday morning, just in case the board had any other significant concerns to hammer out in a final draft. Barring that, the board gave its chair, Krista Huling, the authority to edit for grammar and has approved its draft of the plan.
While the board’s passage of a statewide plan signals the end of a years-long process under Act 46, controversy related to the state’s merger law is likely to continue.
While the filing of litigation against Act 46 hasn’t been announced as of publication, the statewide organization Vermonters for Schools and Community has nearly 30 towns and school districts as plaintiffs for a pending lawsuit to be filed against the state over Act 46.
Several other schools have threatened closure over the threat of consolidation as well, though none of those schools reside in Franklin County.
An attempt to do so earlier this year in Franklin was overwhelmingly defeated during a special town meeting.
Draft Articles of Agreement
The state board of education also approved the articles of agreement that will govern mergers mandated by the Act 46 process. Consolidated districts will have the option of amending those articles as needed, so long as they did so with a district-wide vote.
Those articles offer protections for districts’ real estate, demanding that, should a district decide to close a school, its assets would need to be offered to its respective town for $1.
The articles also forbid the closure of a district merged under Act 46 for the first two years of the consolidation process, unless agreed upon by the individual town where the school is located. Under those articles, once that two-year deadline is over, only a vote from the entire unified district could close a school.
“There is protection in place for two years, but after that it would be up to the local community to amend the articles in some way to extend those protections,” said the Agency of Education’s Donna Russo Savage. “After two years, statutory law kicks in.”
The unified district assumes both the assets and the debt of the forming districts, according to the articles of agreement.
The articles further outline the structure of a transitional school board.
A draft can be found online at the Agency of Education’s website.
Be informed. Be involved. Subscribe to the Messenger.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here