'Stabilize people and give them hope:' Reflections on the complicated legacy of the Sheldon Poor Farm

Posted

SHELDON — On a dirt road past the Sheldon Elementary School, a cemetery is shrouded in neglect with fallen trees, broken headstones and overgrown grass. 

This is the Sheldon Poor Farm Cemetery, the final resting place for some of Franklin County’s poorest Vermonters. 

Founded in 1833, the cemetery’s neighboring poor house and farm were the last resort for folks in need of basic necessities and assistance. 

Inmates of the poor farm system around Vermont lived in hard times, cut off from a town on remote and distant roads often on less desirable land. Poor homes were tax-supported institutions which required people to stay if they couldn’t support themselves.

Poor farms and houses, which also doubled as a location to house mentally ill and physically-handicapped members of society,were an attempt by communities to care for a growing and marginalized class of people in the state. 

For 171 years, the experiment of poor homes continued. The Sheldon Poor Farm was the last of the era in the state, closing in the latter half of the 20th century. 

After the American Revolution, Vermont was left searching for a solution to a growing population of poor community members. In 1797, the state legislature passed a law allowing for the creation of poor farms to keep, “correct” and set beggars, lewd, idle and disorderly people to work and prevent poor inmates from moving between towns. 

In simpler terms, the Sheldon Historical Society said the state tasked towns to “relieve, support and maintain their own poor.” In a time without nursing homes and mental hospitals, these poor farms became a permanent home for a community’s sick, old, deaf, mentally ill and disabled. 

The Franklin County town was not the first to build a poor farm, but it was the last to close — in 1968. The towns of Fairfield, Sheldon, Swanton and St. Albans came together in 1833 to create the Sheldon Poor Farm/Sheldon Poor Home Association.

By 1883, eight towns interned people at the Sheldon location. 

Poor Farm history

When the farm first opened, people saw the poor farm concept as a chance to provide food, medical attention, clothing and shelter to the inmates inside. In exchange, they would provide free labor around the farm and house. Entire families occasionally occupied rooms with some children born, living and dying at the farm at some points. 

“​​The original intent was, you’re poor, you need food, you need work and you need a place to live. Well, here's the food, but you have to help grow it. You don't have a job, so you're gonna work on the farm,” Sheldon Historical Society board member Harold Smith said. “The basic premise was not bad.” 

As the years went on, it became harder to ignore the realities of the farm. It started to see conflict and years of neglect. 

The St. Albans Daily Messenger said in 1897 the farm allowed the inmates to “exist, not live, in a place that has been befouled for five decades by hundreds and hundreds of filthy people.” 

Investigations into poor houses across the U.S. found the facilities to be filthy and poorly-ventilated. Inmates were largely idle and lacked medical care, with management corrupt, negligent and brutal. 

The Sheldon institute was no stranger to brutal conditions. Regulations in 1867 saw food withheld from any inmate who refused to work, according to the Vermont Historical Society. Excavations of one of the original buildings after the farm closed down, found skeletal remains haphazardly buried in the ground and handmade nails and newspaper used as insulation. 

Smith said the overseers at the time saw their work as “just a job.” What early overseers would be interested in, would be getting paid. 

“There wasn't a hell of a lot of care during that period of time, from the people who are providing the care, as opposed to, let's say, the social organizations outside of the farm, committed to things like Christmas, Easter, church services and all that kind of stuff,” he said. “The actual people who governed the day-to-day activity of the farm, some of them, were found to be bad people.”

Issues with living conditions saw residential buildings burn twice while in operation, in 1913 and 1962 from inmates inside. Still the poor farm went on. 

As mental health facilities and state correctional facilities began to open up, poor farms began to decline. In a 1937 study, 90% of the inmates in poor homes were over the age of 45, and for inmates above that age, they often chose not to leave. 

The opening of these locations brought about change, turning poor homes mostly into senior nursing homes. Inmates got older and couldn’t provide the labor necessary and in the end the least able-bodied of elderly were left in the homes. 

Poor farms really began to burn through their goodwill when overseers and government officials began to use the concept as a way of making money and as a business rather than a way to help. 

“It was flawed when the people who were associated with it saw greater opportunities for themselves, and I think there were people taking advantage of the situation,” Smith said. 

Many towns in Franklin County pooled their resources into the poor farm concept, but day-to-day management ruined its main drive. Smith said management before its last 40 years probably put an extra burden on the people inside. 

In interviews gathered by the Vermont Historical Society and Sheldon Historical Society, Florence Nolan, the overseer of the Sheldon Poor Farm from 1947 until its closure in 1968, said when someone was brought to the farm, generally, the family would go and forget about them. She remembered an inmate in his 90s with 16 daughters in Sheldon, who only ever had one visit him. He died as an inmate of the farm. 

“[The inmates] had no other home, knew no other home. Home was here,” Nolan said, after the farm's closure. 

In the last 40 years of its existence, the poor farm was dictated by overseers who by all accounts used their limited resources to take care of the poor inmates and advocate for them. 

“Had the poor farm had this kind of person [Nolan] going through its entire history, it would’ve probably been a better experience for most,” Smith said. 

As the years progressed and Vermonters began to change their attitudes on helping people and state and federal social welfare systems were established, poor farms began to disappear. The 62 total farms in 1916 dropped to 37 by 1928. 

Eventually, the legislature passed The Welfare Act of 1967 which ended local responsibility for the poor, transferring the work to the state. One year later, on Oct. 1, the Sheldon farm was empty.

A new age for welfare

The Welfare Act officially abolished the elected office of overseer of the poor and transferred poor relief fully to the state and federal welfare agencies. 

The Great Depression in the 1930s was a time for the federal government to step in to improve poor-relief services. President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s administration created federally-funded programs for economically-challenged people with the Civilian Conservation Corps providing work.

New Deal programs by the FDR administration put intense demands on towns to take care of the large increase in poor and unemployed people. Legislation from the New Deal worked to shift the cost of local relief to federally-funded and financed programs to be administered by Vermont local and state officials. 

Into the 1960s, federally-funded programs expanded with Medicaid, food stamps and other welfare programs. This commitment to federal social welfare continued the push to close local poor farms. 

“Our means of dealing with these persons and their issues successfully continues to elude us,” the Sheldon Historical Society said. “The Sheldon Poor Farm represents one effort, successful at the time to a limited extent, and then rendered obsolete not by the elimination of poverty but by new found methods to deal with it.” 

An overlooked cemetery

The cemetery at the end of Poor Farm Road is almost hidden. Past the Sheldon Elementary School to a fork in the road, going right leads to the cemetery. Trees line the area and a fence sticks out to alert drivers of its presence. 

Vermont law allows people to be buried in any location so long as the remains are shrouded and buried, according to local cemetery rules. This was and is the case today. 

The cemetery by the poor farm was an example of that. Many of the grave stones are broken, turned over or have trees and other foliage lying on top of or around them. The poor farm cemetery is not considered active today. 

“If you die, your relatives are taking you out back and burying you in a hole in the ground, as long as you have a shroud over your head,” Smith said. “I got to believe that any number of things that happen to a poor man’s grave, I guess, is not somebody’s concern.” 

The cemetery remains an important part of history for the poor farm in Sheldon, although it was nearly abandoned. After efforts were made to clean the cemetery, it was found to hold more graves than originally thought. 

After the farm’s closure, the cemetery was in poor shape. Volunteers who pushed away downed trees and brush revealed more gravestones. Many of the headstones now are legible, although there are some still that are cracked, unreadable or some having fallen on the ground having few, if anyone, to care for them. 

“That's one of the points. Nobody goes there. Who's gonna go there? We're going to remember poor Uncle Fred from 1875?” Smith said. “Some of the people who may have died were really not even that well-known. One marker per person with nothing more than the name and date.”

For many, the cemetery was the last of the line. They had no relatives or siblings and for those who did, Smith said they would be forgotten about and moved on. 

Of the 235 memorials in the cemetery identified, the Sheldon Historical Society found at least one child aged 10. 

A complicated legacy

“We’ll always have the poor, and we've never found a way to defeat poverty,” Smith said.  

To put it bluntly, Smith said the legacy of the poor farm was that it didn’t work. 

It should’ve, he said. Everything that made up the poor farm system was a recipe for success. It had legislative input and overseers who had the power to give inmates social calls and events like Christmas parties.  

No matter what has been tried — from Lyndon B. Johnson’s “War on Poverty” to the poor farm concept — poverty remains unsolved. Smith said although poverty can’t be cured, each attempt has allowed people to find resources to help the poor. 

For example, Smith said the poor farm concept and other similar welfare programs helped allocate resources, slowly, toward decreasing child hunger, each attempt building off the last. 

“Could we eliminate poverty? Probably not. Why? Because there isn't a physical condition,” Smith said. “Do we need to provide care for people who are in poverty due to circumstances beyond their control? Definitely, yes.”

Although the poor farm has a complicated history, Smith said it’s an experiment that worked to a certain degree. There were people in the community and some overseers who cared enough to at least try and take care of people in need. 

“When we were doing this thing with the poor farm we were attempting to, I think, stabilize people and give them hope. Stabilization comes from a lot of money, hope you can’t buy,” he said. “For the people who were really, really sincere about their wanting to take care of the poor, I think during those periods of time, the poor farm worked. Not only have you got to care for people, you've got to advocate for them.” 

For Smith, that sentiment rings as true today as it did in prior centuries. 

#sanltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here