ST. ALBANS TOWN—The Town of St. Albans Selectboard has approved the sale of its old town hall, located at 579 Lake Road.
Town Manager Sean Adkins said Mitch Montagne – a former town selectperson – is looking to buy the building for $175,000 and has plans to create commercial space on the first floor with the second floor devoted to housing.
The closing date for the sale is scheduled for July 28. Residents have a 30-day window to appeal the move after the selectboard gives notice of the sale.
Montagne could not be reached for comment.
The former St. Albans Town Hall has sat largely empty since the St. Albans Town administration moved out of the building at the end of 2022 to take up residence at its new space on Georgia Shore Road.
Montagne has expressed public interest since at least early 2024. At the time, Montagne said he had made a gentleman’s agreement with the town manager to purchase the building for $175,000 in order to develop the property, but the deal ended up sputtering out after he learned the selectboard was considering another option.
Adkins said Montagne expressed renewed interest roughly a year later.
After 2024’s fallout, Adkins said the town released a request for proposal to bring on a real estate broker to help find the right buyer, eventually leading to working with agent Rachel Smith throughout the last year. After getting a few tentative leads, the town moved forward with Donohue & Associates in 2025, which led to this latest deal handled by commercial real estate broker Meg McGovern.
“Mitch came back into the fray shortly after that and we essentially struck the same deal for $175,000,” Adkins said.
If everything moves forward as scheduled, Montagne would be the first private owner of the building since the brick edifice was constructed at the tail end of the 19th century.
At the time, the Village of St. Albans was moving through the necessary legal requirements to become an official Vermont city after half of downtown St. Albans was destroyed in the 1895 fire. By 1897, city hall was completed, and construction for a new town hall down at the bay began soon after.
Due to its role in early local government, the building has many architectural features common to the period, including stylized brickwork and expansive windows. The 6,000 square foot interior, however, has seen a hodgepodge of changes over the decades as each new selectboard approved various repairs and fixes to keep using the building.
This latest selectboard’s challenge was finding a new buyer who could essentially tackle the necessary modifications, while also dealing with the building's historical shortcomings. Unlike most modern buildings, the lack of an elevator makes it more difficult to fill upper floor tenants, while the lack of a dedicated water/sewer system in the bay limits business capacity.
Consequently, finding the right fit has been a consistent challenge for town officials since they moved. A few early ideas and entrepreneurs kicked around the idea of either bringing in a school, or potentially a daycare, although those ideas gained little traction in the long run.
Other ideas floated by the public included a coffee shop, retail space, or some other business that complements the existing Bay Store and nearby Bayside Pavilion.
Either way, the use would need to be the right size to be able to best utilize the 1,500 gallon holding tank for the building’s wastewater system, which was updated in 2010.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here