Solving everyone's problems? St. Albans and Swanton police tackle more tasks and shifting expectations

Posted

FRANKLIN COUNTY — Cpl. Michael Fuller is a team player. 

An athlete all through high school, he took on a career in law enforcement to work with others in service of two shared goals: keep people safe and enforce local laws.

When I got into the passenger seat of his St. Albans police cruiser in mid-December, the heat was blasting and his iPhone was plugged into the aux and music set to shuffle. 

Fuller wasn’t who I had been scheduled for a ride-along with, but some changes to SAPD’s patrol shifts meant he had to alter his afternoon plans and take part in my journalistic mission. 

As a police officer, he’s trained to adapt, but I still had some sympathy. 

“I like the unpredictability of it,” he said. “We could get another shooting right now while you’re in the car. We could respond to a crash…People call the police for all sorts of reasons. You name it.” 

None of those things happened that day, but the St. Albans Police Department has responded to its share of high profile incidents recently. The week before our meeting, a Massachusetts man was shot in a downtown apartment. In late November, several convenience stores were robbed, and in October, police conducted a raid for stolen firearms. 

At any given moment, police officers can be called in any direction, literally, but also more personally, as they are tasked with balancing new expectations for use of force and mental health crises. That might be a reason why there are now just 1,103 fully-certified police officers in Vermont, a number that’s dropped since 2020. 

“Law enforcement has gotten to the point where we’re expected to solve everybody’s problems, and that’s just not reasonable,” Fuller said. 

At the Swanton Police Department, Sgt. Tyler Badeau agrees. He’s seen how components of the job have changed and demanded more since he entered the profession 15 years ago. 

“It's gone from law enforcement to social worker,” Badeau said. 

Because of the culture and the communities’ changing needs, local police departments say their current staffing levels are no longer adequate. 

In 2023, Fuller responded to more than 700 incidents. When I started to ask what would help most day-to-day, he answered before I finished my question: “More officers.” 

But just three years ago, Burlington, a city more than six times the size of St. Albans, cut its police force by 30%. This past month in Swanton, residents’ concern over increased expenses pushed the village administration to reconsider how to move forward with a regional expansion of Swanton police, at a time when police already operate on a shoestring budget.

“We are fully-staffed, but that fully-staffed is also minimally-staffed,” Badeau said of the Swanton department. “If someone were to call out tonight, there would be one officer for 64 square miles. Not only is that not safe, you’ll burn your employees out.” 

Hiring and retention 

On the ballot this March – as part of St. Albans City and Town’s larger municipal budgets – is the first budget for a joint police department, which would add four more uniformed officers and a two-person street crimes unit to SAPD operations starting July 1. 

City Manager Dominic Cloud said the department has already begun recruiting, hiring three new officers and sending one to the police academy. He guessed the applicants were attracted to SAPD by its new, state-of-the-art facility and leadership in Chief Maurice Lamothe. 

“Knock on wood, we’ve been having good luck recruiting,” Cloud said. 

Fuller is coming into his 10th year in law enforcement. He started young, at age 20, part-time with the St. Johnsbury Police Department. 

At the time, he had a newborn son to support, and as a former athlete, he was attracted to the similarities between a police department and a sports team – the uniform, emphasis on physical fitness and that feeling of achievement from a big play. 

Fuller moved to St. Albans from St. Johnsbury in 2019 to be closer to family. The two communities are similar from a police officer’s point of view, he said, as the police departments are similar in size, and both cities have a hospital, domestic violence shelter and correctional facility.

Badeau was introduced to law enforcement in elementary school when a K-9 handler visited his Boy Scout troop. He recalled immediately deciding that’s what he wanted to be when he grew up. 

“I love animals deeply,” Badeau said. “At 6, you see a big German Shepherd doing bite work and you think that’s pretty cool.” 

He joined the Burlington Police Department in 2008, right after college graduation, and eventually fulfilled that childhood dream by becoming the department’s K-9 officer. 

There for more than a decade, he saw Vermont’s biggest city face a swath of challenges. As president of the police union during some of his final years, he said the tightening of the department by the progressive city council was an “absolute nightmare.” 

Seated now in the Swanton municipal offices, Badeau is soft-spoken. And there’s a hint of bittersweet to his voice when he talks about those latter years at BPD.

“I’m very grateful for the time I had there,” he said. “The way I put it is, I didn’t leave the city. The city left me.” 

The jiujitsu club 

“What do you like to do when you’re not working?”  I asked Fuller as he drove south on High Street. 

He works the day shift, 6 a.m. to 6 p.m., so there isn’t much free time in his schedule, but I figured there must be a way he decompresses given the stress and danger of the job. 

At first, he mentioned just catching up on dirty dishes and laundry, but finally, I got him to get a little more personal. 

“I coach my son's fifth and sixth grade basketball team,” he said, a smile coming to his face. “And me and a couple of other guys train jiujitsu.” 

Turns out, Badeau has the same hobby. Coincidence? I don’t think so. 

“It’s one of the most exhausting things I’ve ever done,” Fuller said, laughing. 

He practices at “The Club,” run by Loudon Granger in St. Albans, and Badeau goes to the United Fighting Arts Institute in South Burlington. UFAI has law enforcement-only hours when officers can train for free. 

While Brazilian jiujitsu is what Fuller and Badeau turn to for fun, it also has physical and professional benefits. ​​The grappling martial art teaches practitioners to utilize their leverage, grip and position to control a resistant opponent — including those who may be larger or stronger.

“It’s an excellent tool for law enforcement,” Badeau said. “Jiujitsu is a great way to control someone without ever causing any kind of harm.” 

As a police officer, almost every day is filled with some sort of confrontation, whether it be physical or verbal. That takes a mental toll, Fuller said, and can even induce panic. But the martial arts teach calmness, and that lesson can be applied with practice. 

“If someone assaults you…were you to get sucker punched…you have to stay calm and work your way out of it,” Fuller said. 

Since the 2020 murder of George Floyd by a police officer in Minnesota, law enforcement's use of force tactics have come under public scrutiny – both across the country and here at home. This past December, Franklin County Sheriff John Grismore had his law enforcement certification taken away after he kicked a man in custody. 

But, use of force is part of the job, whether we like it or not. So the question is: how do police do it better? Fuller and Badeau agree the answer lies with jiujitsu.  

“The arm bars and other things work, when everything goes perfectly, which is almost never,” Badeau said. “There's 6,000 some odd moves in jiujitsu, so if something doesn't work, you have 5,999 others you can try.”

The Vermont Police Academy still teaches the Monadnock Defensive Tactics System, a basic self-defense and subject-control program that utilizes counter-attacking skills such as a punch, edged fist, palm-heel strike or front kick. 

Fuller said he finds that style out-of-step with how the St. Albans Police Department and others are thinking about use of force, and that’s created a tension police have to live with. 

“We’re kind of in limbo with a lot of our use of force stuff because the academy hasn’t switched over,” he said. “It is something that I feel we [St. Albans] are trying to get ahead of.”

‘Times when I’m stumped’ 

I didn’t get to see any use of force in action during my time in Fuller’s cruiser, but I did get to take part in a jolly holiday parade. 

“This was kind of pushed on me last minute,” Fuller said of being the caboose to the Vermont National Guard’s Santa Convoy. Twelve holiday light-bedecked military vehicles and trucks were lined up in the Walmart parking lot, ready to escort Mr. Claus from St. Albans to Winooski.

“To drive on that sidewalk or not, that’s the question,” Fuller said, attempting to get his cruiser to the back of the line. 

When the convoy took off, Fuller acted as security detail to Santa, a role so obviously not in the job description. Families stood along Route 7, and a little girl waved to me as we rolled by.  

Before the parade, we’d started talking about the increased role police are playing in mental health care. As we neared BFA, the conversation resumed. 

“I try to be reasonable with myself,” Fuller said. “I can’t solve everyone's problems. I do think I have adequate training with mental health, but there are times when I’m stumped.” 

​​It’s those more challenging situations when he is grateful for Sam Weber, SAPD’s embedded mental health clinician. She joined the department in 2021 and rides with Fuller often. He said as a pair, they can look at situations from different perspectives, which ultimately creates a better outcome for all parties involved. 

It’s estimated that at least 20% of police calls for service nationwide involve a mental health or substance use crisis. Why so many? A Department of Justice report points to the deinstitutionalization movement and closure of psychiatric hospitals. 

Badeau has experience in law enforcement both before and after the closure of the Waterbury State Hospital in 2011. 

“The evolution of our response to these things sort of predicated on that closing,” he said. “It became an issue that we (police) needed to solve, because no one else knew what to do about it.”  

Swanton Police Department doesn’t have a mental health clinician, and while officers can turn to Northwestern Counseling and Support Services for help, the staff there is stretched thin too. Overall, Badeau thinks the resources to help people with mental health crises are lacking in Franklin County.

But could that change? 

Brooke Rainville, a senior at Northwest Career and Technical Center, wants to be the next Sam Weber. As part of the school’s public safety program, Rainville has met lots of professionals in various emergency fields, but none stood out to her like Weber did. 

“I met her last year, and like ‘woah,’” Rainville said. “She is who I want to be when I grow up.” 

Last words

My drive with Cpl. Fuller was my first ride-along in a police cruiser. Sitting with my notebook in my lap, I admired his ability to multitask. To follow with his eyes a man jaywalking Lake Street while simultaneously telling me about the uptick in juvenile crime. To ignore the exhaust in his eyes and scan the interior of a vehicle while asking for license and registration. 

It’s experiences like this when I am reminded of how cool my job is. It’s also when I am most reminded of my responsibility. If I am going to have an opportunity available to few others, I better use it wisely and share it meaningfully. 

Sitting at my desk now, I reflect on the heroism of police and the ways in which the profession can improve – both of which can be true simultaneously. My own understanding of the job of a police officer changed during this project, but that change was only possible because I spoke face-to-face with the people who live it everyday. 

“People forget that we’re human,” Fuller said. It was dark then, the volume to the rap song playing turned down low. 

“I'm not just here…arresting bad guys and doing all these other things that people think we do. I go home and I make dinner and I tuck my kid in just like everybody else does.” 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here