Sheriff answers questions on finances; Grismore appears at House Special Committee

Posted

MONTPELIER — Sheriff John Grismore appeared as a witness in front of the House Special Committee on Impeachment Inquiry for the first time Monday to respond to questions about his office’s bookkeeping.

The legislative committee is currently investigating the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office for potential financial improprieties after a state audit prompted a Vermont State Police investigation. 

Grismore’s visit to the committee, however, was the first time the state legislators provided public insight into what exactly had prompted state financial investigations. During the six-hour hearing, Grismore also delivered a strong message to the seven-member board, as he said he intends to challenge any efforts by the multiple state agencies to remove him from office.

“I’m not concerned with what people outside of Franklin County are worried about or what they have for opinions or what they think they're entitled to,” Grismore said.  “I’m responsible and accountable to the people who voted me into the office and that’s what I intend to do. “

Financial problems?

After winning the sheriff’s election this past November, Grismore has faced multiple challenges across Vermont’s state government stemming primarily from an Aug. 7 2022 incident when Grismore kicked a handcuffed man in custody. 

Since then, it’s been an uphill battle to repair any damage to his reputation – both personally and professionally. Just days ago on Dec. 7, the Vermont Criminal Justice Council voted 15-1 to “permanently revoke” Grismore’s Level 2 law enforcement certification following a use-of-force hearing on his actions, and he still faces a simple assault charge in Grand Isle Superior Court. Monday morning, the Vermont Sheriffs Association also publicly denounced him for giving others in law enforcement a reputational black eye.

“The public often doesn’t see the difference (between agencies). And so an action of a sheriff or sheriff deputy will equally impact the Vermont State Police, the Department of Motor Vehicles, the Department of Fish and Wildlife, the Brattleboro Police Department, the St. Albans Department,” said Mark Anderson, Windham County Sheriff and president of the Vermont Sheriffs’ Association. “It’s just, we’re the cops.”

But there’s been much less public information available about proposed financial irregularities spotted by state auditors. 

The Special House Committee on Impeachment Inquiry hasn’t helped. Deciding to release info in a piecemeal fashion, the group has held most of its meetings behind closed doors. Chair Martin LaLonde (D-South Burlington) has said repeatedly the committee has done so to protect the personal info of state employees, but the result has been little to no evidence of the state’s claims on what exactly is going on at the Franklin County Sheriff's Office. 

The questions posed by the committee Monday, however, helped reveal the outlines of the state’s concerns – primarily that Grismore may have been double-dipping into retirement funds.

Questioning around the financial improprieties was led by attorney Tim Doherty of Downs Rachlin Martin. The legal firm had been hired this summer to look into documentation provided by the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office. 

As Grismore explained to Doherty, he was initially hired with the sheriff’s office back in 2019 primarily in an administrative role, which categorized him as a county employee. But he also went on patrol due to his law certification, giving him access to sheriff’s office funding.

This created a situation where Grismore was paid out of two funds – which is not uncommon. 

But the problems arose when the sheriff’s office considered how to deal with Grismore’s retirement funding. Due to news reporting, he said he knew the state pension fund was in dire need, and so he talked to then-Sheriff Roger Langevin about a potential 401K alternative (which never came to fruition).

A set of emails provided by Doherty, however, seemed to surprise Grismore. Obtained by Downs Rachlin Martin, Doherty said they showed a January exchange between sheriff employee Tina Ploof and pension plan administrators that had approved a $20,000 payment into VMERS, the state’s pension fund, to cover a supposed lack of payment from the office to cover its portion of Grismore’s retirement.

If proved to be true, Doherty categorized it as “double compensation.”

Grismore said he didn’t have any knowledge of the exchange or any other legal problems with his retirement funds as he had understood any portion covered by the office would have already been paid. He stressed any action about retirement and payrolls were results of multiple conversations with Langevin, as well as check-ins with an attorney. 

He said he also needed time to look at some of his own financial records, as he hadn’t looked at any of his retirement accounts in major detail before coming to the day’s hearing, nor was he employed by the office when the email exchange took place.

The Langevin question

One of the bigger questions to come out of Monday’s hearing is how Grismore’s former boss, Roger Langevin, plays into the state’s investigations.

Grismore has contested in the past that much of the resulting public fervor that arose from the Aug. 7 incident occurred because the video was unfairly provided to the County Courier by Langevin, and he was also unfairly fired before any use-of-force investigation could be completed.

After Monday, legislators most likely have some insight. 

Langevin spoke briefly as a witness Monday via video conferencing before the committee entered executive session with him still on screen ready to give testimony. It’s also unclear how Langevin was involved in the different matters being investigated by the committee, as Grismore kept mentioning his name during the committee’s questioning.

For example, Grismore explained how his office changed when he first took over the office, and one of the first things he said he did was approach each town that the office had contracts with.

Grismore said he told town officials – in the interest of transparency – that the sheriff’s office likely could not fulfill the entirety of its contracts, so he would start billing them by the hour. As a result, Enosburgh town officials reached out to the state delegation to see what could be done to get better coverage from the office, as they were getting complaints from residents that there were no patrols being done.

Grismore contested that assumption, and he said he had patrol records that could prove otherwise. As for the existing town contracts, Grismore said Langevin had initially made the agreements, and he was in the process of renegotiating them. 

Grismore said his contracting efforts have helped expand the office’s coverage into Sheldon and Franklin. Highgate – which is losing St. Albans Police Department coverage this July – has also reached out.

Next steps

To impeach Grismore, the House Special Committee still needs full approval from the Vermont House of Representatives before conducting an impeachment trial in the Senate. 

Grismore, however, has signaled his intent to keep fighting against those efforts, portraying their actions as unnecessary oversight that signals to law enforcement a lack of support. Before the day’s questioning, he submitted a public statement as part of the day’s documentation.

“There is nothing more anti-democratic and autocratic than the effort in this room to override the votes of 8,900 Franklin County residents and replace those votes with a backroom fancy of a handful of political insiders in Montpelier,” he said. “This spits in the face of representative government.“ 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here