JAY – When Jay Peak’s general manager asked Canadians for their thoughts about the U.S., he got an earful. In four days, 6,000 emails had arrived in his inbox.
“What’s affecting us most isn’t necessarily the tariff,” Steve Wright said Tuesday afternoon. “It’s the rhetoric, and the erosion of trust that is underneath that.”
A few days after trade negotiations between the U.S. and Canada fell apart, Sen. Peter Welch (D-Vt.) brought business leaders from across the state to Jay Peak to discuss the economic impacts, effectively pushing for legislation to stop it.
Because more damage to Vermont’s bottom-line is expected to come next Monday.
From Canada’s Department of Finance: “Effective September 8, 2026, Canada will impose 15, 25, and 50 percent tariffs … with individual product rates based on the matching U.S. rate for the same goods.”
“This year around trade policies, (Canadians) are angry,” Wright said. “And you can't talk to anger. You can have no conversation with anger, and it's understandable.”
Arranged in the conference center of Jay Peak, Welch’s event featured business leaders all reeling from their latest revenue projections.
Jasper Hill Farm’s Mateo Kehler, for example, explained how the cheese business had spent roughly a decade making connections in Montreal before their work went south just this past year.
“What looked like a million-dollar year for us went absolutely cold,” he said.
Meanwhile, an ongoing construction project at Jasper HIll Farm in Greensboro started getting surprise bills. Equipment arriving from Canada soon came with an extra 50% tagged onto the cost thanks to President Donald Trump’s tariffs.
“Trying to manage costs in a construction project in this environment that’s both inflationary and where your costs, your tariffs, are changing like week-to-week and month-to-month, it becomes almost impossible to manage a budget.”
“So the 50% tariff on incoming-materials is ‘anxiety-producing,’” Kehler said while looking for words. “It may be the polite way of saying it.”
Alongside Welch, Kehler and Wright were joined by Abby Long representing the Northeast Kingdom Collaborative, Bob Montgomery of Hill Farmstead Brewing, Kara Soulia of the Vermont Country Store, State Rep. Michael Marcotte (R-Coventry) and Tim Egan, the vice president of the New England-Canada Business Council.
Mike Desmarais, of TRACK, Inc., also joined the group, taking a stand behind the podium about halfway through the event to “speak from the heart.”
His company sells specialized snow vehicles, with offices employing roughly 25 people in Wisconsin, Vermont and Quebec. The latest trade tariffs, he said, will slowly crush his business over time if allowed to continue.
“You know, when I first bought this business in 2010, it was open borders. The Canadian dollar was at par. Things were flowing back-and-forth across the border,” he said. “Since Trump’s second term has started, it’s been nothing but headaches.”
Sales shrunk by a third a year after Trump took office, Desmarais said, and by another third last year.
“We want to work with local companies here in Vermont, throughout the United States. We sell our products all over the U.S., from Arizona to Alaska … but we can’t do it with tariffs,” he said.
Meanwhile, Trump was making headlines about renaming Lake Ontario, snubbing Canadian culture in the process. On Monday, Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney effectively told him to grow up.
“When the Americans stop doing memes, stop throwing shade, stop trying to be tough and start being serious about having those (trade) discussions, we can have those discussions,” Carney said.
Hours later, the U.S. Secretary of War, Pete Hegseth — a former TV personality host — jumped on social media to post a picture of “Canadian cadets,” presumably after he had approved more missile strikes in Iran.
There’s no date on the calendar for trade discussions between the U.S. and Canada to start back up. Carney, notably, has also been one of the loudest international actors advocating for a wider economic break with the United States after seeing the writing on the wall, literally.
In August 2025, Trump hung up new White House artwork that labeled him as one of the “Tariff Men” in American history, arguing that his economic plans will protect American industries and help create fairer trade deals. Since that time, the U.S. Supreme Court struck down his first attempt to slap widespread tariffs on U.S. trade, but Trump was quickly back at it weeks later, leaning on a whole new legal framework based on trade disadvantages as part of his protectionist efforts.
In the White House’s official announcement of the most-recent Canadian tariffs, Trump specifically named the dairy industry as being unfairly treated due to Canada’s quota system on cheeses.
On Tuesday, Welch quickly downplayed the dairy argument by pointing to Trump’s other economic plans, which have leaned on tariffs as part of a larger economic strategy that Welch labeled as "reckless, dangerous and destructive.”
“I’ve never seen anything that is such a blow to an economy as what Donald Trump has done with his unilateral decision to impose tariffs,” Welch said.
To reverse the impact, Welch and other senators have been fanning out across the country trying to rally voter support around the BAD DEAL Act, which would repeal the law Trump is leaning on to impose tariffs, while also ensuring that all duties collected be paid back. Senators like Welch just need the Republican-led Congress to take action.
“There's nothing that holds (Trump) back from doing whatever it is he wants, and the only way we can get leverage is ultimately to have some of my Republican colleagues do what essentially Rep. (Michael) Marcotte did – to put his constituents before party identification,” Welch said, referencing a call-to-action made by Marcotte, a state representative, at the press event moments earlier.
“There is an energetic destruction on the part of the president, who’s taken these unilateral actions,” Welch added.
Bob Montgomery, manager of Hillstead Brewery, warned of potential “generational harm.”
“We are heavily dependent on visitorship,” Mongtomery said. “We have to find ways to work with Sen. Welch and other people to pressure the administration and our government to rescind these policies. So we can begin to rebuild these relationships and hopefully welcome people back…”
Allison Hope, representing the Vermont Maple Sugar Makers’ Association, said the maple industry is a good example of international players working together for everyone’s benefit. While some maple producers see Trump’s tariffs as protectionist, she worries that tariffs could dry up the U.S. market for maple syrup.
Vermont produces roughly one-eighth of the world’s maple syrup, with Canada making up three-fourths of the remainder. Because of the Canadian’s capacity, Hope said maple syrup is available in grocery stores across America. Without it, maple syrup could become a luxury good, especially if inflation and tariffs continue to push up the input costs of making it.
“If you shop in Arizona, and you don’t have the opportunity to buy maple syrup on the shelf, you’re not going to be a regular consumer of it,” Hope said.
Instead, there’s a chance that Americans will turn to artificial sweeteners, drowning their future pancakes in syrups manufactured in a factory far away from Vermont, due to their cheaper shelfspace and production costs.
“(Maple syrup) is like the gateway drug, right?” Hope said. “Like it doesn’t necessarily matter at the onset where it came from, as long as it represents the industry well, and it presents a doorway to introduction to Vermont producers.”
Other Vermont-produced goods that will see Canadian tariffs include beer cans, canned beans, canola oil, cardboard, chainsaws, chocolate, crops seeds, farm equipment, grain, hiking boots, hockey stocks, honey, lawn mowers, maple presses, paper towels, pasta sauce, plywood, salmon, sleds, snowshoes, softwood lumber, sports equipment, toilet paper and wool clothes.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here