Selectboard to sue City

Posted

ST. ALBANS — St. Albans Town is once again suing St. Albans City over water and sewer.

The town selectboard voted unanimously Monday night to bring suit against the city over the city’s affiliation fee ordinance, which took effect on Nov. 15. This is the third lawsuit the town has filed against the city in nine years.

The board also defeated a proposal last night for a town enforced moratorium on any new connections to the city’s water and sewer system.

At the same time, selectboard members Sam Smith and Bruce Cheeseman spoke about their ongoing negotiations with city mayor Liz Gamache and manager Dominic Cloud. “We’re in hopes we can come to an agreement and do away with the lawsuits,” said Cheeseman. He anticipates “an equitable solution that will benefit both the city and the town.”

The city council passed a moratorium on the sale of water and sewer allocations outside the city limits in 2011, after the town withdrew from settlement talks in their last lawsuit.

The municipal tax rate in St. Albans Town is 36 cents, said Smith, adding that the affiliation fee is “virtually doubling those taxes. In effect, new homes, new businesses will begin paying taxes in the city,” said Smith.

The moratorium ended last week. However, the city adopted an affiliation fee in which users outside the city pay an annual fee based on the value of their property. It amounts to 28 cents per $100 of assessed value for both water and sewer. Users of just water or just sewer will pay less.

The affiliation fee goes into the city’s General Fund. It applies only to new users.

The ordinance also does not apply to the town’s north end sewer district until an existing allocation given to the district when it was created has been used up.

The new city rule also contains a list of criteria for evaluating proposed projects. It is aimed at protecting the city’s tax base and economic development. The questions include whether the project could have been built in the city, and would it add to employment in the city. That list does not include zoning criteria such as aesthetics, noise, traffic or density, which the city is legally barred from considering when approving projects outside the city limits.

Selectboard member David McWilliams said many people don’t understand the amount of the fee and that it will be charged for the life of the property. He called the fee “taxation without representation.”

Cheeseman, too, criticized the fee. “It certainly appears that it’s a tax to me,” he said, even though the city calls it a fee.

“It’s still a three-letter word,” said Smith. “I don’t care how you spell it.”

After the soliciting comment from the other three board members, acting chairman Stan Dukas offered his view. “I’m also in bed with you guys,” he said.

Dukas indicated the town has spoken with attorneys about the city ordinance. “I think there’s some parts that are not legal,” he said.

Dukas then made the motion to take legal action against the city. The board members voted 4-0 in favor. Board chair Brent Palmer was absent due to illness.

The board then moved on to discussing a town ordinance from 2006, which requires anyone in the town wishing to connect to city water or sewer go through the town. The ordinance says the board may review those applications itself or designate a representative to do so. The town manager has always handled those applications.

Smith suggested placing a moratorium on the purchase of allocations by anyone impacted by the affiliation fee, that is all town residents and businesses outside the north end sewer district.

Cheeseman said he believes most businesses “do their homework” and understand what they will be paying. If they’re willing to pay the affiliation fee, the town should not stand in the way, in his view.

Smith replied, “You’ve got businesses that are going to be refused because they compete with a city business.”

Once they’ve paid the affiliation fee, the town can’t “unwind it later on,” said Smith, adding, “I don’t think they’re willing to (pay the fee); it’s that they’re forced to.”

“I’m not for another moratorium. We suffered enough,” said Dukas. “Neither community realizes what they’ve lost.”

Smith then made a motion to suspend purchases of water and sewer allocations from the city for six months to allow time for the two municipalities to reach an agreement. The motion failed 1-3, with Smith the only vote in favor.

At the end of the meeting, during other business, Cheeseman raised the topic of negotiations with the city. “We painted a pretty bleak picture tonight with water and sewer,” he said.

However, representatives from the two communities have been meeting almost weekly, and Cheeseman said he hopes the board would be able to bring an agreement to voters on Town Meeting Day.

“My problem with lawsuits is we debate what’s right and what’s wrong, and we don’t’ get anything solved,” said Smith. “The lawsuits probably prolong the situation and not solve it.”

At the most recent city council meeting, Gamache, too, spoke favorably of the negotiations. “We have spent quite a bit of time simply exploring common interests,” she said. “For the first time in quite a while there is a fair of evaluation of the value of water and wastewater to both communities.”

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here