ST. ALBANS TOWN – The St. Albans Town selectboard pulled together a full agenda Monday night as four of its members – vice chair Bruce Cheeseman was absent – debated failed motions to ban smoking in public parks and add harassment language to their personnel policy.
Since the reorganization of selectboard earlier this year, the St. Albans Town selectboard has worked to revise and update their personnel policy.
During last night’s meeting, a few of those revisions were formalized, including language that promised to make up the difference in pay for town employees called away for active military duty.
Selectboard chair Bill Nihan and selectboard member Stan Dukas were opposed to changes in the language on workplace harrasment, with both criticizing the proposed language as “too broad” and citing a lack of enforcement as reasons for their disapproval.
Dukas has historically disagreed with revising the policy due to his belief that it’d be impossible to enforce.
“You just keep getting thicker, and thicker, and thicker,” Dukas said. “They keep telling me ‘You don’t like to be regimented with laws.’ Well I love it when you’ve got a hammer to hit them with if they do something wrong.”
Nihan and Dukas expressed reservations about working under guidelines they said could qualify “raising your voice” as harassment.
“If you look cross-eyed at someone, it could be harassment,” Nihan said. “You could be considered harassing by raising your voice or interfering with somebody’s ability to do their work.”
“That’s insane,” the selectboard chair concluded.
Selectboard members Al Voegele and Brendan Deso, meanwhile, supported the changes in the policy, stating that they were necessary for creating a “professional office.”
“We have situations, not only in the town office but in other situations, where you do have employees fighting with one another. You have people coming in that have some form of authority that do create an uncomfortable position for the person who is the object of the criticism and also those people who have to listen to it,” said Voegele, who had initially proposed the changes. “We have to have a professional office and that’s all I’m asking for.”
Deso read the definition of workplace harassment that would have been used in the proposed change to the policy, which qualified workplace harassment as “actions, communication or behavior that mocks, demeans, puts down, disparages or ridicules an employee.”
“Find me a problem with that sentence,” Deso asked before suggesting that the vote be tabled for another meeting, when a full board could be present.
The motion to table that amendment was defeated in a 2-2 vote, with Voegele and Deso voting in favor of tabling the discussed amendment and Nihan and Dukas voting against it. The vote on the amendment itself fell along those same lines.
In cases of a tied vote, selectboard motions are considered defeated.
Following the defeat of the amendment related to workplace harassment, the rest of the updated personnel policy itself was adopted by the selectboard. Nihan, Deso and Voegele approved the policy, while Dukas abstained.
Later that night, the selectboard returned to their personnel policy, this time to question what authority individual selectboard members could have when making public comments to the press. While no votes came from the discussion, the selectboard said they’d likely return to the question at a later meeting.
“There are things in the conflict of interest policy… which address confidentiality,” Nihan said. “Bearing in mind that, in that discussion, we have to shield some of these discussions, legally. We have a lot of reasons for not putting something in the public domain.”
“The problem is, it seems that everything we’ve discussed in executive session have come out to the media and the public,” Voegele, who proposed the discussion, observed. “There’s some confusion among the public about where [we are].”
“As long as it’s qualified that this is their personal opinion, it’s not a selectboard view… the fact that they’re, to use a ‘Trumpism,’ leaking information, there’s nothing we can do about it,” Nihan said. “That’s up to one individual’s sense of what their responsibilities are.”
Voegele had previously told the Messenger that it wasn’t the place of the individual selectboard members to comment on the decisions of the selectboard, affirming that “a well-functioning selectboard should only speak with one voice” following a decision made by the board.
“It’s easy for the press to play us off each other if we’re talking out of this room, and that’s what bothers me,” Voegele said during last night’s meeting. “If we’re going to lead this town, we have to have a unified policy and really the chair should be the only spokesperson when we make a decision.”
Nihan defended some of the town’s recent confidentiality, which included denial of public records requests and a decision to reject a proposed deal on water and sewer with the city made in executive session, reportedly on the advice of legal counsel.
“A lot of the things we’ve been doing has been on the advice of counsel, and we’d be fools for not doing what the counsel advised,” Nihan said. “Some of the things we’ve suggested could and would put us at a distinct disadvantage.”
Voegele had also suggested that the town clarify, in a public meeting, some of its opinions on the town’s rejection of a proposed deal on water and sewer.
The selectboard agreed to speak more about these questions at a later selectboard meeting with legal counsel present.
Smoke Ban
Northwestern Medical Center Health Educator Amy Brewer also attended the selectboard’s regular meeting to pitch a ban on smoking in public parks, both to protect vulnerable people from second-hand smoke and help prevent some of the pollution caused by cigarette butts.
“Parks are great places where people gather – young people, old people, everybody in between,” Brewer said. “They’re also a place where people litter tobacco products.”
According to Brewer, Franklin County is considered a place of high tobacco use among both youth and adults, something that could be impacted by a ban on cigarette use in parks. She said that approximately 27 percent of youth in Franklin County use tobacco products.
She also reported that there were serious problems with pollution caused by people tossing cigarette filters to the side, as those cigarette filters aren’t biodegradable and, in the case of St. Albans Bay Park, can wind up polluting an important waterway.
Deso moved to ban the use of tobacco products in the park, as well as asked about building some kind of a ticketed fee structure similar to the one applied to dog waste in public parks.
“At the end of the day, smoking is a gross habit that can harm other people in the area,” Deso said. “Especially now that we’ve got more elderly folks coming down to use the path and walk it, and you’ve got kids.”
Nihan thought it was more appropriate to discourage cigarette use in parks rather than pass a blanket ban, as, according to Nihan, a ban would be difficult for the town to enforce.
“I think you can discourage, but you can never prohibit,” Nihan said. “You can’t control everything all the time.”
The Director of Public Works Alan Mashtare suggested that publicizing a place as a tobacco free area could lead to a reduction in smoking in the park, even if the town can’t reasonably enforce it all the time.
“I know that Taylor Park in the city is a smoke free zone, but… it’s limited,” Mashtare said. “When I worked in the city, I didn’t see a lot of smoking going on up there.”
He added that he previously reached out to St. Albans Police Department to patrol the parks more often to cut back on other illegal activities, meaning that there’d be a police presence that could help enforce a park ban on smoking.
“There’ll be a police presence,” Mashtare said. “I don’t think we’ll get it to zero, but it’s a chance to cut back on tobacco use in the parks.”
When it came to a vote, Voegele and Deso approved adding a ban on tobacco use in public parks to the town’s park ordinance. Dukas and Nihan shot down the ban, explaining that it wouldn’t be enforceable and could constitute a regulatory overreach.
“Part of this becomes the old ‘Big Brother,’” Nihan said. “’You shall not do this.’”
Voegele and Deso protested after the vote, with Voegele noting that smoking could exacerbate health problems for both users and those inhaling second-hand smoke, something that would be reflected in healthcare costs in the state.
“We have a public space down there and we owe it to folks who have health issues,” Deso said following the vote.
Instead, the selectboard came to a consensus to put up signs in the parks discouraging cigarette use.
Stay informed. Subscribe to the Messenger.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here