Selectboard adopts shooting ordinance

Posted

The Essex Selectboard on Monday unanimously adopted a revised firearms discharge ordinance that limits shooting in three municipal parks, ending a long and often contentious process that began more than a year ago.

The ordinance, which goes into effect immediately, prohibits shooting at the Essex Tree Farm and allows it at two town parks – Indian Brook and Saxon Hill – during a 60-day window covering deer hunting season: October 15 to December 15. The board agreed last month to expand the window at the request of hunters, who noted the initial dates didn’t cover all deer hunting seasons. The ordinance also codifies a 500-foot buffer around the high water zone, and the town planned to post new signage this week alerting residents to the changes.

Monday night’s meeting was a far different affair than those leading up to it. There was sparse debate or discussion from the crowd, which, at less than a dozen people, bore no resemblance to the packed meeting rooms seen over the course of the ordinance revision process. And the board had little to say, settling some of the more controversial issues at meetings over the last few months.

That included the recent decision to ditch rules about shooting ranges, in which property owners who shoot in their backyards would have needed to register with the town while also filing a notification form with a site plan of their property, an assurance that their range met NRA safety standards and proof of liability insurance with a minimum coverage of $500,000. The board removed the rules over concerns that it did not further the goal of safety while placing the town at risk of liability.

The ordinance’s passage wraps up more than 18 months of work on the latest iteration of revisions and arrives more than 11 years after Old Stage Road resident John Reiss was killed when a stray bullet entered his home from a neighboring backyard shooting range. The death prompted a reconsideration of the firearms ordinance, highlighted by a citizen task force’s recommendations in 2009, but the board never took them up.

The topic then resurfaced in 2016 at the request of former Essex police Chief Brad LaRose following a shooting incident that saw a Deer Crossing Lane resident finding a rifle bullet lodged in a wall of his home.

In a report that year, LaRose said the safest approach would be to ban shooting in town altogether.

“The growth and development in some areas has extended into, and adjacent to, areas of the town where shooting is authorized,” he wrote in 2016. “The probability of a fired projectile striking a person or property has increased significantly.”

Or at the very least, he said, the town should prohibit shooting around Indian Brook Reservoir and Saxon Hill Forest. But the selectboard eventually landed on the more lax approach, appeasing hunters who felt unfairly targeted by the new rules.

Supporters of the ordinance revisions have expressed disappointment in recent weeks over what they see as the selectboard caving to the interests of shooters.

“The selectboard ran away scared of these threats made by backyard shooters who resist accountability for accidents like the one that killed [Reiss] in 2008,” wrote Cecilia Polansky in a letter to the editor last month. “Why are you scared? Because of a threat of lawsuits — lawsuits that will be funded by the deep pockets of NRA. That is so sad. What most citizens want and need is not the overriding concern in this decision.”

Opponents of the ordinance, meanwhile, praised the board at its last meeting for listening to their concerns.

“Thank you for proving me wrong,” said resident Erik Bailey. “The board looked at hard facts and the winners will be both the public and the ecosystem in our parks.”

Last month, selectboard chairwoman Elaine Haney warned the board’s work is not finished, suggesting it may consider alternative ways to limit sport shooting, whether through a new noise ordinance or through the planning process. On Monday, however, she wrapped up the discussion on an appreciative tone.

“Thank you everyone for being here the entire time,” selectboard chairwoman Elaine Haney said after the vote. “Thank you for your engagement. Your recommendations. We hope to continue this conversation in the future. We appreciate you being here and taking part.”

#shootingranges #essexselectboard #town #hunting #indianbrookpark

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here