Scott Keever Is Building a Reputation Business for the Age of AI

Posted

The founder of Reputation Pros has spent years working behind the scenes on high-stakes search results. Now, as Google and artificial intelligence increasingly shape first impressions, his once-niche corner of digital marketing is moving closer to the center of public relations.

For someone in the business of shaping what people find online, Scott Keever is unusually comfortable with not being seen.

The founder of Reputation Pros works in a part of the communications industry where the most consequential assignments rarely become case studies. His firm says its clients have included executives, entrepreneurs, entertainers, athletes and high-net-worth individuals, people whose names can function almost like corporate assets and whose reputational problems can carry financial as well as personal consequences.

Keever declines to identify the firm’s clients, reflecting the level of discretion and confidentiality that sits at the core of its work.

That is largely the point.

“There are situations where the best indication that we've done our job is that nobody knows we were involved,” Keever says.

It is a decidedly low-profile philosophy for an industry built around visibility. But Keever has spent much of his career looking at reputation differently than a traditional publicist might.

He came to the field through search engine optimization.

Keever founded Keever SEO in 2015, years before online reputation management became his primary focus, and developed his expertise around one central question: Why does Google decide that one piece of information deserves to appear above another?

Today, that same question has become considerably more complicated.

People no longer learn about an executive, artist or company only through newspaper articles and television interviews. They Google them. They read Reddit threads. They scan review sites and social media. Increasingly, they ask ChatGPT, Google's AI products, and other generative systems to summarize who someone is and whether they should be trusted.

For Keever, that change has transformed reputation management from a specialized form of crisis control into something closer to digital infrastructure.

When a Name Becomes an Asset

A company's search results have always mattered. Keever argues that the same is increasingly true for individuals.

Before meeting a potential business partner, hiring an executive, investing in a company or signing an endorsement deal, it takes only seconds to search someone's name.

What appears next can establish a first impression long before the person has an opportunity to make one themselves.

For prominent people, the consequences are magnified.

A decade of professional accomplishments can sit beside—or beneath—a single damaging article. An old lawsuit may outrank more recent information. An allegation can become detached from its eventual resolution. A controversy that lasted several days in the news cycle can remain prominent in search results for years.

Keever began moving deeper into reputation management after recognizing that many of the tools he had developed as an SEO practitioner could be applied to those problems.

The technical principles were similar.

The stakes weren't.

Ranking a local business higher for a commercial keyword could generate more customers. Changing the information environment surrounding a CEO, physician, athlete or public figure could affect deals, employment, relationships and public perception.

That distinction eventually became central to Reputation Pros.

Rather than viewing reputation purely through the traditional lens of media relations, Keever approaches it as an ecosystem involving search engines, websites, authoritative publications, social profiles, structured data, reviews and other information sources.

It's less about placing a single favorable story than changing the broader body of information through which a person is understood.

The Reputation Fixer You Don't Hear About

There is a certain contradiction at the center of Keever's business.

Reputation firms need to establish their credibility publicly, yet their most interesting work is often the work they are least able to discuss.

Keever says many of Reputation Pros' higher-profile engagements arrive through private referrals from attorneys, publicists, business managers, advisers and other clients.

Those introductions often come after a crisis, but increasingly, in 2026, they are happening proactively, before reputational issues have a chance to escalate.

For wealthy families and public figures in particular, online reputation is beginning to be treated less like emergency cleanup and more like risk management.

The idea is straightforward: if a person's online presence consists of only a few authoritative sources, a major negative event can quickly dominate the available information about them. A deeper body of legitimate interviews, biographies, professional accomplishments, profiles and other credible material creates a more complete record.

“You don't want to start thinking about your reputation on the worst day of your career,” Keever says.

That philosophy has pushed the firm's work beyond conventional “suppression”—the practice of moving undesirable search results farther down Google.

Some clients, Keever says, don't have a crisis at all.

Their problem is that the person who appears online bears little resemblance to the person they are offline.

An accomplished executive may have almost no search presence. An entrepreneur may be associated primarily with an old dispute. A public figure's search results may contain years-old information while omitting a decade of more recent work.

Increasingly, reputation management is about filling those gaps before someone else, or an algorithm, fills them first.

From Google Results to AI Answers

Artificial intelligence has raised the stakes further.

For most of the modern internet era, anyone researching a person was presented with a list of sources and left to draw their own conclusions.

Generative AI changes that relationship.

A user can now ask an AI system a direct question about a person or company and receive what appears to be a definitive summary.

Who is this executive?

Is this company trustworthy?

Has this person been involved in controversy?

Who are the leading experts in this industry?

Those answers can draw from information scattered across the internet and compress it into a few paragraphs.

Keever sees that as one of the biggest changes his industry has faced.

His Forbes Agency Council contributions have increasingly focused on online defamation, reputation, investor trust and the effect of artificial intelligence on search and digital visibility. Forbes identifies Keever as the founder of Reputation Pros, although Forbes Councils is a fee-based membership program rather than Forbes editorial coverage. citeturn915745search5

The larger issue, Keever argues, is that reputation professionals now need to understand not only what ranks, but what machines conclude.

That creates a different challenge.

A negative story no longer has to sit in Google's first position to matter. If enough sources reinforce a particular narrative, an AI system may incorporate that narrative into its description of a person.

Conversely, simply flooding the internet with flattering material doesn't necessarily work. Modern search and AI systems place greater weight on sources they consider trustworthy, consistent and authoritative.

That makes the provenance of information increasingly important.

“Ten years ago, most clients were asking, ‘What shows up when someone Googles me?’” Keever says. “Now the question is becoming, ‘What does the internet think it knows about me?’”

Keever has also attempted to quantify how reputational crises play out in search. In 2026, he published a widely cited research paper examining what happens to executives’ Google results following negative press, tracking how quickly adverse coverage reaches the first page and how long it can remain there. The study has since become a useful statistical reference point for discussions around executive reputation and the long-term impact of negative news in search.

Reputation Can't Be Solved With a Press Release

Keever's view of reputation places him somewhere between an SEO strategist, digital publicist and crisis adviser.

His core argument is that reputational problems are rarely solved by any one tactic.

A favorable article doesn't erase an unfavorable one.

A new website doesn't automatically outrank established reporting.

Deleting or removing an undesirable result, when removal is even possible, doesn't address what may already have been repeated elsewhere.

Instead, Keever focuses on what he describes as the accumulation of credible signals.

Media coverage matters.

So do authoritative biographies, owned websites, social profiles, search rankings, reviews, structured information and consistency across the broader web.

Individually, each may have limited influence.

Together, they form the digital record algorithms use to understand an entity.

The concept is familiar in search optimization, where Google's systems evaluate thousands of signals before deciding what deserves prominence. Keever's contribution has been applying that mentality to individuals whose names carry business value.

Outside publications have also increasingly turned to him or his companies in discussions of online reputation. Reputation Pros has appeared in recent comparisons of reputation-management firms, while Keever has been identified publicly as the founder of the company and as an SEO practitioner who moved into reputation management. citeturn915745search0turn915745search2

A Career Built on Understanding Search

There is a playful episode from Keever's earlier SEO career that still follows him.

Years ago, he decided to see whether he could make Google associate his name with an entirely subjective phrase: “Best Looking Guy in Miami.”

The experiment worked.

What could easily be dismissed as an internet stunt also demonstrated something that would become central to his career: search results aren't passive reflections of the world. They are rankings produced by algorithms, and those rankings can affect human perception.

Keever eventually applied the same underlying principles to more serious questions.

What happens when an old news story becomes the dominant search result for a person's name?

Why do certain profiles outrank others?

Why does one publication become a source that dozens of other websites, and now AI systems—repeat?

And what can be done when the version of a person presented online is incomplete, outdated or distorted?

Those questions gradually moved Keever beyond conventional SEO and toward the work that now occupies most of his attention.

The “Best Looking Guy in Miami” experiment was playful, but the underlying lesson was serious. Search engines don't simply organize information. They influence which information people encounter first, which sources appear credible and, ultimately, how people form opinions.

Artificial intelligence extends that influence considerably further.

Instead of presenting ten blue links and allowing users to investigate for themselves, AI systems increasingly interpret those sources and produce an answer. For someone whose name carries economic, professional or public value, the difference is significant.

A search result can influence perception.

An AI-generated summary can begin to define it.

The Next Phase of Reputation Management

Keever believes that distinction is pushing online reputation management into a much broader discipline.

SEO remains part of the equation, but so are public relations, digital publishing, entity optimization, structured data, authoritative profiles, reviews, social platforms and the growing collection of sources AI systems use to understand people and companies.

In that environment, reputation is no longer simply about ranking positive pages above negative ones.

It is about building a sufficiently credible and consistent digital record that search engines and AI systems have enough reliable information to understand who a person is, what they have accomplished and what sources should be trusted when describing them.

That also changes the nature of crisis preparation.

For years, companies invested heavily in protecting corporate brands while executives often treated their own search results as an afterthought. Keever expects that distinction to continue disappearing, particularly for founders, CEOs, investors, physicians, attorneys, entertainers and other individuals whose personal names are closely connected to their businesses.

The internet has effectively created a second reputation for them: an algorithmic one.

It exists whether they actively manage it or not.

And unlike traditional reputation, which might once have been shaped through personal relationships, media coverage and word of mouth, this version is continuously reconstructed from thousands of digital signals.

A news article can influence it.

So can a biography, podcast appearance, lawsuit, Reddit discussion, company website, review, interview, social profile or database entry.

AI can pull those fragments together in seconds.

That reality helps explain why Keever sees the industry moving closer to the center of modern public relations.

The goal, he argues, shouldn't be to manufacture a spotless version of someone or attempt to erase every unfavorable fact. Neither search engines nor sophisticated audiences work that way.

The stronger strategy is to make sure one article, allegation, controversy or outdated chapter does not become the entirety of someone's digital identity simply because nothing more authoritative exists to compete with it.

For Reputation Pros, that increasingly means working before a crisis happens.

It means treating search results, digital authority, and AI visibility as assets that can be developed over time rather than emergency problems to address after something goes wrong.

It also leaves Keever in an unusual position.

He has built much of his career figuring out how to make people and information more visible while operating in a business where his most consequential work is often deliberately invisible.

That contradiction doesn't seem to bother him.

As artificial intelligence becomes another layer between people and the information they consume, the business Keever entered through SEO increasingly resembles something much larger: managing the digital record from which machines—and, increasingly, people—decide what to believe.

And in an internet capable of turning thousands of scattered pieces of information into a judgment in seconds, the objective is no longer simply to control what appears first.

It is to make sure no single result gets to tell the whole story.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here