VERMONT — The state of Vermont is taking a red pen to its education system.
Too complicated and too costly, Gov. Phil Scott says it is time for major change. Earlier this year, he challenged lawmakers and educators to condense the state’s 119 school districts into just five.
While many Vermonters agree revisions are necessary, finding a common ground solution is proving to be immensely difficult.
So how’s it going?
To sort through the process so far, the Messenger spoke with area stakeholders who are living this work every day. Here’s what to know.
Gov. Scott signed Act 73 into law on July 1, after many rounds of back and forth in the state legislature. The bill establishes a process for Vermont to transform its public education system so it features larger school districts and a statewide tax rate.
The goal? To devise a system that advances students’ academic performance and is less costly to taxpayers.
“We have too many districts, 119, serving on average about 850 students,” Scott stated in a recent commentary. “Under the current structure, it is nearly impossible to achieve any level of equity or administrative scale from district to district.”
Act 73 lays out a three-year timeline for transformation. The state legislature should approve new school districts in 2026 so they can begin operating in 2028-2029. The statewide tax rate and weighted student funding formula would go into effect alongside the new school districts.
Other components of Act 73, like statewide graduation requirements and class size minimums, will go into effect in the intervening years.
Act 73 also established the School District Redistricting Task Force to recommend new district boundaries and configurations to the legislature. Made up of lawmakers and education experts, the 11-member force has been meeting since August to take public testimony and consider the options.
The task force can propose up to three district maps for the state legislature to consider when it reconvenes in January.
Task Force Co-Chair Sen. Martine Larocque Gulick (D-Burlington), said the group has considered three possible layouts so far, but will need to finalize its proposals by Dec. 1.
“We'll put at least one map forward, and there will be a lot of qualifications with that map,” she said. “We are going to have a very detailed and long report that talks about the pros and cons.”
Gulick, whose senate district includes Essex Junction and Winooski, as well as parts of Burlington and Colchester, said she actually voted against Act 73 because she believed the timeline for transformation was too short and the makeup of the task force should have been non-partisan.
She eventually joined the group to bring her experience as a longtime school board member and former classroom teacher to the table.
The maps reviewed by the task force so far include one that creates new school districts by county and one that creates them by technical education centers.
The CTE model breaks the state up into 14 districts, nearly mirroring the 17 tech centers. In Franklin County, the hypothetical district would combine Cold Hollow Career Center in Enosburgh and Northwest Career and Technical Center in St. Albans.
The third map follows a BOCES model, or Boards of Cooperative Educational Services. The plan would create five BOCES regions of districts — not dissimilar from supervisory unions — which could share specific services, while also merging smaller districts.
Gulick said the task force nixed the idea of countywide school districts at its last meeting, Oct. 10.
“It’s too complex and complicated, because so many districts don't follow county lines,” she said.
Essex Westford School District’s board had openly opposed the county model, saying a Chittenden County school district would be disproportionately large compared to all others.
Gulick said the task force will look at a fourth map, built around regional high schools, on Oct. 28. This plan, she said, would keep elementary schools small and local, like many Vermonters prefer, while providing high school students with more choice and opportunities.
“It’s just really hard for small high schools to provide the same opportunities as large ones, whether it be Advanced Placement classes or a theater program or what have you,” she said. “There is an economy of scale when you get bigger, especially at the high school level.”
After considering the regional high school model, the task force will determine which maps to recommend to legislators. There is also still one more opportunity for the public to provide feedback — 6-8 p.m. Tuesday, Oct. 28 at Winooski High School.
As Vermont’s current school districts wait for legislators to decide on changes to the system, it is mostly business as-usual. Students and teachers are hard at work in school buildings every day, and administrators are negotiating staff contracts and building next year’s budgets.
Still, redistricting is on everyone’s minds.
“Teachers are already getting nervous, wondering if they are going to lose their job,” Amy Rex, superintendent of Milton Town School District, said. “We’re also hesitant to take on any new platform or make really systemic changes.”
This week, Maple Run Unified School District Superintendent Bill Kimball sent a letter to the Redistricting Task Force on behalf of the board which serves St. Albans and Fairfield.
In the letter, MRUSD questions how effective the task force can be given the breadth of public comment and its tight timeline. The board also supports its current unified school district structure, which has been in place for almost a decade.
“The Board recognizes that a larger district structure could provide some opportunities, such as economies of scale and shared costs for specialized programs,” the letter reads. “However, we have serious concerns about potential risks, including diminished community engagement, loss of local voice and longer student transportation times.
“At this time, the Maple Run Board does not support moving to a supervisory union model and believes that maintaining our current unified district configuration is in the best interest of our students, staff and community.”
Some school boards, on the other hand, are trying to get ahead by determining for themselves who they could best partner with. In its letter to the task force, Mountain Views Supervisory Union said it is looking to merge with Hartford School District and Windsor Southeast Supervisory Union.
While the position of the Milton school board has been to “wait and see,” Rex said she could see Milton aligning itself with Chittenden County’s other more rural districts, or the Franklin West Supervisory Union.
If done right, she said, some consolidation could be beneficial to students. Milton High School is a relatively small school and struggles to maintain a diverse selection of AP, world language and music classes.
But one option could be for neighboring high schools within the same district to have different specialties, she said, giving students an opportunity to explore and deepen their interests.
To meet the deadline set by Act 73 and the expectations of Gov. Scott, legislators have a daunting debate ahead of them when they reconvene in January under the golden dome.
To have new districts up and running by fall 2028, they will have to get into the details fast and furiously. And honestly, there are still more questions than answers.
What about funding for school construction? Gulick asked.
“I don't see how we can fix this system without investing in fixing the infrastructure we have, but preferably building some new infrastructure,” she said.
Rex wants to know what will happen to staff, transportation and food service contracts, which may have been signed into effect beyond 2028.
“Will there really be any savings? You have got to manage those,” she said.
There are also concerns for the Agency of Education’s capacity. Does it have the staff to support districts through all of these changes? And what about rising healthcare costs? Many school boards across the state say that is the real culprit of ballooning budgets.
“There are a lot of unanswered questions, and I think that is what’s providing the most anxiety for people,” Rex said.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here