RICHFORD — In response to recent allegations of an illegally held meeting, Richford Selectboard Chair Linda Collins denies any impropriety.
The issue was brought to light following accusations from residents regarding a specific selectboard meeting held on May 4. That meeting was called to discuss an ambulance personnel issue.
While meetings of a public body are declared to be open to the public at all times under state law, a subsection of the statute states that day-to-day administrative matters that don’t require action by the board may be conducted outside a duly warned meeting, “provided that no money is appropriated, expended, or encumbered.”
Collins says the meeting was to interview a witness to “a problem with some ambulance personnel.”
The interview specifically relates to an allegation of sexual harassment. Collins, who expressed surprise when asked about the allegations, says Richford’s lawyers have determined that the alleged claim doesn’t rise to sexual harassment.
“We’re not gonna let it go, but the lawyer says that doesn’t constitute sexual harassment,” says Collins.
The Messenger requested resignation letters from members of Richford Ambulance. Richford’s lawyer, Brian Monaghan, responded denying the request for records saying, “Any records the town may have regarding the above are exempt from disclosure under 1 V.S.A. § 717 ©(7) covering personal documents relating to an individual, including information in any files maintained to hire, evaluate, promote, or discipline any employee of a public agency,” writes Monaghan.
“This was just an interview of a person, a day to day routine thing, and did not need to be warned. This was from VLCT (Vermont League of Cities and Towns). This is the law. So, I’m going by this. It’s not a meeting. I don’t have to warn it. There was no time to warn it. It wasn’t a meeting, it was a discussion with a witness to a supposed incident,” says Collins.
However, Collins does admit that she “forgot” to warn a meeting on April 6.
“Yes, in April, I did not warn a meeting. I warned the regular select board meeting and we had another meeting and I totally forgot that we were going to meet on Tuesday to discuss Ambulance — to discuss overtime. So, it was in our minutes of our Monday night regular meeting, I reminded everyone to come to the meeting the next day, so it wasn’t a secret. The day after that I realized I hadn’t warned it,” she says.
Collins says the issue was cleared up at the next regularly held meeting on April 19. Minutes for that meeting show that the selectboard did invalidate the previous meeting and approved ambulance pay.
One accuser says that in Richford, “for several years ‘Executive Session’ was improperly used on many occasions to keep the public out of discussion and knowledge as to what ‘they’ were doing.”
The Messenger has asked the accuser specifically what meetings are being referred to. As of press time, no examples have been provided.
When asked if there have ever been meetings in Richford that haven’t been posted, Collins responded: “I’m sure, I’m telling you the two that I didn’t post. I don’t know about anybody else.”
As for the accusation regarding executive session, she says: “I know that executive meetings are not supposed to be used as frequently as they are, yes, and that’s why, when I became chair, we don’t ... the only time we go into it is personnel usually or real estate matters. Those are the two things you go in for.”
Jared Carter, a professor in the law department at Vermont Law School, says because Collins acknowledged the mistake, any decision made during the meeting needed to be declared void and they need to go back and redo it.
“Under the law there are meetings that can be noticed after the fact if there’s an actual emergency, otherwise, regular meetings require 48 hours notice. Special meetings require 24 advanced notice and an agenda must be posted in or near the municipal office and in at least two other designated public places in the municipality,” he says.
Carter also says anyone that’s aggrieved has the right to appeal and if this has been a pattern or practice of city officials or town officials then those individuals could be individually liable or fined and the municipality could be legally liable under the open meeting laws, under the public record laws in Vermont.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here