BAKERSFIELD — At Bakersfield Elementary Middle School, grades are up and referrals for behavior problems are down. A new discipline model, built on accountability and dialogue, has curtailed behavioral problems, creating a learning community where students not only seem happier, but learn more and test better.
Called “restorative practices,” the school’s reformed discipline program is built on community-building and making amends, where instead of detentions and time-outs, students are met with empathy and the expectations that they’ll make up for whatever damage they’ve done.
With roughly 150 students, BEMS is typical of a rural school. Grades from preschool to middle school share the same building, where class sizes can be as small as eight students and rarely exceed 20. Students starting at lower grades like kindergarten or first grade will likely have the same classmates throughout their stay at Bakersfield, ultimately sharing the graduation stage at the end of eighth grade.
According to several teachers at BEMS, this presents one of the most difficult challenges to a learning environment like Bakersfield. Since students will have been together since elementary school, a conflict between students in earlier grades could easily come up again a few years down the road when those students share a middle school classroom. Traditional punishments, like pulling a student out of class, only break up those conflicts, but do little to prevent it from happening again.
Before adopting restorative practices, the amount of referrals teachers issued at BEMS never really surged, but they never really went down, either, according to BEMS teachers. The number of repeated offenses by students was also stagnant. Repeated offenders might have had their disruptive behavior interrupted, but nothing really kept that behavior or conflict from returning.
“We were having such a big issue with the same kids having the same problems because we were just putting a band aid over the problem… rather than getting to the real heart of the issue and restoring a relationship,” said Emma Stevens, the second grade teacher at BEMS.
Restorative practices, like those introduced by BEMS, work on several levels to address these problems. At their core are circles, where a class of students will be brought together to freely discuss whatever that day’s topic might be. Conversations could range from the mundane, like describing how your day is going, to the academic, like class themes or defining “respect.” Even if the circle trails of topic, the end result is still a stronger sense of belonging, according to teachers at BEMS.
“It really helps build the community aspect of the class,” said fourth grade teacher Mallory Jones. “When you have a large class like that, there’s so many personalities that come in. When you have a circle, it’s powerful because they all feel like they’re being listened to and being heard.”
When a conflict happens between students or a rule is broken, however, a smaller circle is formed between an observing teacher and both the offending student and the student they harmed. The teacher sets those students aside, checking first with the harmed student before speaking with the other student who had caused that harm. Rather than approach a conversation punitively, though, the teacher will focus on the feelings of the students involved before ever addressing the actual offense.
“We’re talking to the person who was affected first… and asking ‘What do you need to make this right?’” explained BEMS middle school teacher Kendra Pillsbury, who also helped introduce BEMS’s restorative practices program. “And then we talk with the [rule breaker]… starting with their emotional well-being. Then we ask them about [the rule that was broken].”
“With restorative justice, the question isn’t what you did but who you harmed,” Stevens added.
The idea, Pillsbury said, is to explain to the student how their actions impacted another student, to give them the chance to make it right without needing an intervention and to help them make whatever repairs the students’ relationship would need. The end result would be a clearer sense of accountability, with students becoming more self-aware of the impact of their actions.
“[By exposing the student to the harm they caused] it holds them accountable. It makes them understand their role in the process, and how their behaviors impact other people,” Pillsbury said. “I think it also gives kids an opportunity to make things right.”
If the offending student doesn’t try to make amends on his own, or the incident that occurred is severe, those meetings could take some time. According to Pillsbury, it could take hours of talking with the student, addressing both the damage they may have caused as well as the well-being of the student.
“Behavior is always a response to something else that’s not right. Kids don’t walk into school throwing pens at students. They do it because they’re not having their needs met. Whether they didn’t eat breakfast that morning or Mom and Dad were fighting all night and they didn’t sleep well, there’s always a reason for the behavior our students display,” Pillsbury said. “Restorative justice helps us better understand why they do the things they do so we can hold them accountable and help them make repairs.”
Since the introduction of restorative practices to the school, BEMS has seen a dramatic decline in both the number of referrals for broken rules and in the number of repeated offenses at the school, according to the school’s principal, Anissa Seguin.
Between the 2015-2016 school year, when these practices were introduced to Bakersfield’s middle school classes, and the 2016-2017 school year, the number of referrals dropped by two-thirds. As of January 2018, that number has declined even further, with the school only issuing approximately a fourth of the amount of referrals that they had at this time last year.
According to Seguin, the number of repeated offenders for major incidents, like fighting or bullying, has also steadily declined. There have been no major repeated offenses in the 2017-2018 school year, the principal said.
Prior to adopting restorative practices, BEMS relied on a Positive Behavioral Intervention and Supports (PBIS) model for discipline. Under PBIS, a U.S. Department of Education-endorsed system focused on correcting a student’s offending behavior, BEMS teachers might have removed a student from the class, sending them to the principal’s office or the school’s planning room, where they’d meet with a specialized faculty member that could walk the student through correcting their offense. A student might also be isolated from the class, temporarily removed to another classroom.
It was a system that could be demoralizing and incited complaints from the students, according to teachers at BEMS. With little being done to address the underlying conflicts between students or improving relationships, students expressed some discomfort with BEMS’s environment.
“Students would complain about it more than you’d think,” Stevens said, recalling a particular group of students’ criticisms. Restorative practices had relieved some of their complaints, though, Stevens added, as students started opening up more with teachers and some of the root causes for students’ behavior began being addressed.
BEMS still follows some of the standards outlined by PBIS, particularly during major offenses like fights or instances of bullying. The school hasn’t had to rely on these more punitive measures nearly as much though, according to Seguin.
“If there’s a major offense, you’re still coming to the principal for the final say. If there’s bullying and harassing, we still have to do investigations and send out letters,” Seguin said. “It’s just that we’re not using them as much, so the time can be spent in the classroom with kids.”
According to teachers at BEMS, the transition to restorative practices, while time consuming at first, has led to more class time with students. Students aren’t being pulled out of classrooms as often, and behavior has improved to the point where classroom disruptions have become few and far between.
“I can tell you that during my first year here, I spent probably… 20 to 30 to 40 minutes every hour of class managing and dealing with behavior,” Pillsbury said. “Now, my students come in, and I teach. They’re so invested in the community that they even settle some things on their own now.”
Since reformative practices were adopted, academic performance at BEMS has largely improved. Between the 2015-2016 and 2016-2017 academic years, standardized test scores for the English and language arts increased, with classes frequently scoring 10 percent higher than they had in previous years. Likewise, while standardized test scores in math may have decreased – Seguin attributes this more toward proficiency standards increasing than her students’ own performances – roughly 84 percent of students individually performed better in 2016-2017 than they had in the 2015-2016 school year.
Parents have also noticed positive changes within BEMS. According to Hollie Curtis, a former student at Bakersfield who now has sons in both preschool and second grade at BEMS, the atmosphere in the school has improved.
“I spend a lot of time at the school… Students seem more respectful to their teachers, and it seems like students are closer,” Curtis said. “[My second-grader son] knows it’s comfortable talking with Miss Stevens. If he’s got a problem, he knows that she knows how to help him.”
Currently, BEMS is working to address some of the needs expressed by the students during their circles and during conversations. The school has started a mentor program to work with students with more difficult situations, and breakfast is now provided in the morning for students who might not have had a chance to eat at home.
The school worked closely with the Franklin Grand Isle Restorative Justice Center, a nonprofit organization that works with both schools and the Department of Corrections in the application of restorative justice practices as a discipline model in schools and as a way to reintegrate former inmates into society. The Center provided training for the teachers at BEMS and moderated earlier circles – both community-building circles and conflict-resolving circles – as a sort of neutral party.
“We’re giving people a way to deal with conflict… [and] to deal with emotions,” said Nina Curtiss, the organization’s director. “How do you maneuver or navigate yourself through a conflict with a peer or a teacher? Or how do you apologize or accept an apology?”
With restorative practices being successful in Bakersfield, Curtiss says she is looking forward to advising other Franklin County schools in adopting the approach. Already members from the Center are working with Enosburg High School and Bellows Free Academy to start developing similar approaches.
“This is going to provide so much information for us… We’ll be able to answer questions about how this really works,” Curtiss said of BEMS’s restorative practices experience. “We’ll have data about what we put in place, and how the community responds to it and what the outcomes are.”
Meanwhile, in Bakersfield, school officials are looking to continue developing their restorative practices program. The successes of restorative practices has allowed the school to replace some of its behavior-oriented expenses like the planning room and its fulltime specialist with more on academic and best-practices pursuits. A guidance counselor at BEMS has been promoted to a fulltime position, and the school has afforded more support for its restorative practices program, all without extra funding, according to Seguin.
While considered successful by its staff, BEMS is continuing to build on its restorative practices initiative. The school is investing in a fulltime restorative practices advisor, a position it’s developing with the Center for Restorative Justice. Meanwhile, trainings continue for BEMS’s teachers, all of whom Seguin said have been supportive of the transition.
“There’s always a learning process. Your staff has to be totally committed,” Seguin said. “We’re starting to build, but it’s got to happen all the time.”
“[But] as the principal, it makes me feel like we’re doing something right to see [those numbers],” Seguin added. “When I see them, I think ‘This is working.’”
To read more of the Messenger’s education coverage, subscribe.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here