One way for Vermont to go ‘green’; Is solar too cheap to stop?

Posted

VERMONT — Vermont’s energy future might be a little less “green” and a little more “grey.”

A month after announcing over $60 million coming to Vermont via the EPA’s “Solar for All” program, the Vermont Public Service Department dropped another update. 

“All work and activities related to Vermont’s Solar For All program have been paused as of Aug. 7, 2025, and will remain paused until further notice.”

The program had been under development in Montpelier for over a year, established to bring residential solar installations to lower-income Vermonters, but federal action pulled the plug. No more money meant no more program. 

Despite the setback, Mike McCarthy — who recently became president of the Waterbury-based solar company SunCommon — is ready for another busy year of solar installations.

“We absolutely can’t fail as an industry writ large. If we fail, then we’re going to have a planet that’s too hot to live on, but just personally, like I’ve been through more adversity in the last year, professionally, personally, than I’ve had in any previous point in my life,” McCarthy said. “I am really feeling, like, resolved, determined and ready to just kick some butt next year.”

While the United States — under Republican leadership across all three branches of the federal government — has largely given up on “going green” in favor of the oil and gas industries, Vermont has stuck to its own efficiency goals — to have 90% of the state’s energy generated by renewables by 2050. 

And there’s plenty of people looking to make it happen.

Adapting to news

For many in St. Albans, Mike McCarthy is a familiar name, having served previously on St. Albans City Council and as the city’s state representative. 

Local residents might recognize him, however, from his time owning Cosmic Bakery & Cafe. He operated the Main Street business from 2009 to 2014.

“I still see people on the street, and I don’t even know their names, but I know that every morning, for like five years, I served them a cinnamon raisin bagel, toasted with peanut butter,” he said.

In the decade since — while moving through his career in state politics — McCarthy has worked for SunCommon. The Waterbury-based solar installer focuses on finding market solutions for Vermont’s renewable goals and this August, McCarthy was recently promoted to leadership to push forward the company’s commercial division.

As for its approach to the industry’s federal disruption, SunCommon has been trying to pull in the necessary funding to offer similar residential systems that the business had expected to install with federal support. The details around the program, however, are still being worked out.

“We have a couple of financiers that we are partnering with now, and we’re starting to learn their rules and are getting ready to roll out those lease products so that we can sell residential systems into next year with a very similar value proposition,” McCarthy said.

The new option would have a homeowner essentially lease the solar installation on their residence, giving a portion of proceeds to the financial backer until the costs are eventually paid back. As the company figures out the nitty gritty around the concept, McCarthy said they’re setting up for a year of commercial builds that had already been on the calendar, just rearranged after the federal news came down the line, thanks to the commitment of their customers.

And then, as the solar industry works out the nuts and bolts of creating a good market incentive, more rooftop residential installations are expected to return, as McCarthy sees the market helping property owners eventually perceive the value sans tax credit.

“No business wants to operate in an environment of uncertainty, and the Inflation Reduction Act gave us more than a decade of runway with a particularly good incentive that people understood in the marketplace,” McCarthy said. “Now, we’re going to have to go out and educate people and rebuild it.”

Vermont already has a burgeoning solar market to do the work. The Vermont Public Service Department’s annual report on the solar industry estimates that small-scale developers and installers have created over 18,000 jobs in Vermont, with over close to 2,500 businesses operating in the clean energy space.

Systemwide changes

This past summer, EkoBuilt business owner Paul Kealey came down to St. Albans to highlight a pre-fabricated build using his company’s system of interlocking thick exterior walls used to create extremely thermally-consistent residential homes.

“There’s no temperature swings, no drafty environment on the inside,” he said. “You can sit right up against the windowsills and comfortably read a book. It really is a house that not only is designed for optimal energy efficiency but optimal comfort.”

SunCommon participated in the build, setting up a 12-KW solar system to help cover energy costs. A comprehensive residential system would also include the installation of batteries, and McCarthy said some people are adding an electrical vehicle for more storage capacity for when solar generation is at its peak hours.

For McCarthy though, that’s just one vision of Vermont’s green future. What is more likely to happen than a wave of hyper-efficient housing is the retrofit of Vermont’s current buildings to help more households take advantage of solar cost savings, alongside the continued deployment of weatherization techniques to make buildings more efficient and expanded electrical capacity to help the grid.

Instead of green, McCarthy said, it’s more grey — finding efficiencies in already developed areas.

SunCommon, for example, already sees the potential of widescale adoption of batteries. If each household — or enough of them — end up installing them with their solar array systems, then Vermont could, in theory, have thousands of batteries distributed across the grid. 

“It allows them to do what’s called a virtual power plant, where they essentially dump a portion of the battery power in when they need it,” McCarthy said. “And so for our customers who are generating power up on the roof and then filling a battery, if the utility can take some of that energy when they need it, they’re saving everyone money.”

According to a tally by the Northwestern Regional Planning Commission, Franklin and Grand Isle counties could potentially generate 29 MWs of power if one-fourth of its buildings were committed to rooftop solar. 

That number, however, is likely on the conservative side, if new electrical efficiencies are taken into account. McCarthy said an average install these days is about twice the size of NRPC’s number, thanks to cheaper and more efficient solar panels driving the market.

For a comparison, a residential homeowner would have paid closer to $50,000 for 10KW of generative capacity ten years ago. These days, McCarthy said an installation of the same size today would be closer to $35,000.

The solar market

While solar costs have undoubtedly gone down, Vermont still has a long way to go to reach its energy goals. In Franklin County, for example, almost every household still relies on fossil fuels, as well as wood resources, as their preferred source of thermal energy. Only 5% lean on electric heat.

That doesn’t mean it’s not possible. Solar isn’t going away anytime soon.

As more and more investment was made into the technology, major inroads were carved in both Europe and Asia, especially by China which cornered the market on rare earth materials needed for solar panels. The Eastern superpower now has access to 70% of rare earth minerals, generates one third of the total capacity worldwide and has more solar energy generation per capita than the U.S., despite having four times the population.

Luckily, Vermont’s energy needs are a little smaller in scale, and its government is being a little more careful.

While chasing Vermont’s green policy goals, state officials have spent a lot of time talking to constituents to answer concerns and adapt policy to resident needs, recognizing that many Vermonters don’t want solar panels set up in prime agricultural land.

Instead, the NRPC recommends placement on existing structures or in already-developed sites, like landfills, brownfields or active quarries. To fulfill all renewable needs in the region, however, the planning commission expects commercial solar generation will need roughly 1,000 acres of solar panels by 2050 — spread across a two-county region — to hit its capacity goals.

“We won’t kick our dependence on fossil fuels by shaming people into using less energy, so companies like SunCommon need to offer people reliable energy solutions at a lower cost,” McCarthy said. “Every time I drive by SATEC, People’s Trust, or one of the many other homes and businesses we’ve helped go solar, I’m really proud of the work I get to do every day.”

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here