‘Nobody… has all the answers’; Legislators deal with week 2

Posted

RICHFORD — “So people ask me, what’s a normal day in Congress look like?”

U.S. Rep. Becca Balint’s voice echoed in Richford High School’s gymnasium. Located less than a mile from the international border, the combined middle/high school is a far cry from Balint’s state office — which is located just a hop from Burlington’s Church Street.

“So I wake up very early,” Balint said, talking to a group of roughly 200 high schoolers, sat up on two sections of bleachers. On Wednesday afternoon, some of them look exhausted, hunched over, with heads resting on their hands. 

“And my team tells me my meetings for the day,” Balint continues. “And then in between those meetings, I’m going to committees.”

While Balint talks to the students, my own smartphone pings and shakes. Another breaking news headline delivered to my inbox. 

After setting off a constitutional crisis around federal funds, President Donald Trump rescinded his freeze two days later. Balint, with microphone in hand surrounded by students, was already talking about old news.

So then…emergency averted?

“I spent the day yesterday talking about all the ways in which this is bad for Vermont,” Balint told the students. “Because we have programs at the University of Vermont that will have to be shut down because those funds won’t come. We have projects at BETA … they may not be able to build the next phase of their company.”

“What I try to do,” she added. “Whenever we’re looking at a policy that’s coming from Congress, or coming from the president, is always to put it into the lens of: How will it impact people here in Vermont directly?”

Two visits north

Franklin County got two visits from Vermont’s federal delegation this week. On Monday, Sen. Peter Welch brought a roundtable of business leaders to St. Albans City Hall to discuss the likely impacts of tariffs on trade with Canada, as St. Albans is uniquely located to see its economy hollow out due to the move.

And on Wednesday, U.S. Rep. Becca Balint visited Richford, getting a review of the Northern Tier Center for Health’s programs followed by a visit to Richford Junior/Senior High School.

During both events, the two legislators barely mentioned President Trump, nor was there much policy discussion about the dozens of other executive orders that had come down from D.C. two weeks after he entered office.

But the two legislative teams were definitely trying to get their message out; Vermont — because of its small size, its specialized economy and its overreliance on federal funds — is extremely vulnerable to the ongoing political tremors felt in D.C.

“What we’ll be trying to do is bring attention to the administration and the Treasury Department and others to say, ‘Hey this is really going to have a big impact,” Welch said at the Monday roundtable. 

During the event, Welch gave the floor to each business leader, letting them provide insights while he sat at the center of the table, listening in and sipping coffee.

Jake Holzscheiter, president of A.N. Deringer Inc., sat at Welch’s right. The customs broker is likely the largest importer in Franklin County, matching only Peerless Clothing in the amount of product it ships across international borders.

“I would say the Canadians, in particular, are shocked,” Holzscheiter told the Senator. “It was not part of the political campaign. So it wasn’t something that they had prepared for.”

Trump said repeatedly throughout the political campaign — starting in 2023 — that he would put a 10% tariff on all imports, regardless of origin, as well as a 100% tariff on cars made outside the U.S. and a 60% tariff on Chinese goods. His latest idea, however, is to establish a 25% tariff on Canada, which would go into effect by Feb. 1. 

Will it actually go into effect? Who knows.

Another round

A day after the Welch event — on Tuesday — Trump’s Office of Management and Budget unilaterally set off a constitutional crisis when he announced a freeze on $3 trillion worth of federal grants and loans.

“Financial assistance should be dedicated to advancing Administration priorities— ,” the memo from his administration reads “ —focusing taxpayer dollars to advance a stronger and safer America, eliminating the financial burden of inflation for citizens, unleashing American energy and manufacturing, ending ‘wokeness’ and the weaponization of government, promoting efficiency in government and Making American Healthy Again.”

Northern Tier Center for Health’s executive director Kathy Benoit almost went into panic mode after hearing the news, she said. She saw the memo, then state portals that allowed organizations to access Medicaid payments also stopped working. 

Under Benoit’s leadership, NOTCH serves 28,000 patients in Franklin County, and the nonprofit’s main building props up many community services that Richford residents rely on — like its grocery store, dentistry, pharmacy and thrift shop. Cutting off Medicaid, however, would have severely rolled back what the nonprofit could do.

Relatedly, Vermont’s entire healthcare system — which relies heavily on revenue from the federal program — would also have likely collapsed.

But then hours later, Trump’s administration clarified the problem was a technical error and unrelated to the federal freeze. It turns out NOTCH would be fine.

In general, cutting any federal grant the nonprofit receives can be painful for NOTCH, Benoit said, but it wouldn’t be game-ending in the same way that ending Medicaid would. Sure, they’d have to pick and choose which services they could use, but that’s not exactly an uncommon challenge in the nonprofit world. 

During Balint’s tour, she got a good look at what some of those services entailed, getting a rundown on the various programs NOTCH uses while Benoit and her cadre of employees provided info on what has worked best in Richford. 

NOTCH operates with a heavy focus on identifying and meeting a community’s needs, Benoit said, with nutritional and dental programs being a big part of their operations.

But it’s been difficult to secure resources and maintain staff. Local folks don’t always see dentistry as a career, she said, leaving the nonprofit with the need to bring in dentists internationally to fill out the gaps. 

“We have staff who are going to be impacted by these things. There’s going to be this snowball effect,” Benoit said.

NOTCH staff will also lean on Benoit — as the nonprofit’s director — for answers when a confusing directive comes down the line. But then, she said, if you don’t know something, or if the directive changes, the perception from others becomes you don’t know what you’re saying. 

So, it’s easier to put on a face, when you’re waiting for the next directive, the next order, the next whatever — while knowing you’ll never really know.

“I just assume everything is going to be fine,” she said.

Shaky ground

Near the end of her one-person presentation at Richford High, Balint got the signal from her staff to wrap it up. Another group was waiting on the Representative, so she put a point on her message.

“We have to see ourselves as Americans and Vermonters first,” she told the students. “And try to put the political stuff aside in our day-to-day interactions with each other, because we have really big problems we need to face from housing, to healthcare, towards education, and it’s going to require all of us, regardless of party, to try to solve those problems.”

In about 40 minutes, Balint’s talk with the students did add some energy to the sluggishness in the room. Many more students were sitting straight, listening and paying attention than had been at the start of the address. 

Her story had covered her own start into politics while emphasizing how easy it can be to run for office in Vermont. In Balint’s case, she worked as a teacher before finding a place in the U.S. House of Representatives.

The presentation also featured a few questions from the audience. While students initially provided hand-written questions, they were happy to ask a few when they got the chance. People were interested in the representative’s thoughts about housing, education vouchers, campaign finance, inflation and tariffs.

“I don’t want to get too wonky on you, but (it sounds like) a double cheeseburger is really putting a hole in your wallet,” she said.

Another student asked if she had met President Trump. She hadn’t, only getting a glimpse of him during the inauguration. Like everybody else, the most she hears from the president is whatever he tweets or says at a podium, and even that info is likely to change days later. 

“Whether it’s President Trump, whether it’s President Biden, these are all just people,” she said. “We’re all flawed. They’re not perfect, and we created the society that we did and the government that we did because we believe that regular people should be the people running the government.”

“We ourselves have something to contribute,” she added. “And nobody in government has all the answers.” 

#sanl

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here