No treatment for Carmi this year

Posted

FRANKLIN — An in-lake treatment system for Lake Carmi won’t be operational until next spring according to the Vermont Dept. of Environmental Conservation (DEC).

Before this summer, officials from both the DEC and its parent agency, the Vermont Agency of Natural Resources (ANR), said the proposed system might not be operational until next year.

Agency officials said the system could be delayed over concerns about how late-season operation could compound the lake’s stratification, the point in the season at which the lake’s inner layers turn over.

And that is, in fact, what’s delaying the system, according to Perry Thomas, who manages the DEC’s lakes program.

Thomas said installation could begin this fall so the system could be turned on as early as possible next spring, ahead of the summer tourist season — but an operational system in Carmi this summer is “not looking feasible,” she said.

Thomas said state agencies are currently modeling multiple types of artificial circulation in the lake, namely linear air diffusion, dispersed air diffusers and downdraft pumping.

State agencies have to release a final report — including the design of the system — no later than Aug. 10. The next step after that is soliciting proposals for the system’s installation. The DEC has $1.6 million in funding available for the installation.

Here’s the premise behind artificial circulation.

The public outcry in summer 2017 over Carmi’s condition, which initiated this unprecedented media coverage and legislative action, was based on unusually harsh cyanobacteria, or blue-green algae, blooms.

Those blooms feed on phosphorous, which lake sediments release during summer stratification when oxygen is scarce in the lake’s lower layer.

Artificial circulation increases oxygen in the lake by circulating more water for exposure to the atmosphere, the lake’s main oxygen source.

Diffusion is the process by which a lake draws oxygen from the atmosphere. Artificial circulation basically equalizes diffusion across the lake, mixing all the water layers together for equal temperature and equal oxygen.

Thomas said state agency workers participated in a “webinar” — an online seminar — on June 25 modeling how Carmi might react to the in-lake system.

“The model shows that physical and chemical parameters responded as predicted,” Thomas wrote in an email, “with the lake no longer stratifying in late summer and legacy phosphorous staying in the sediments.”

Since stratification depends on lake layers with different temperatures, and artificial circulation acts as an equalizer, the in-lake system could prevent stratification, which is a key factor, or the key factor, in the lake’s cyanobacteria blooms.

The lake’s legacy phosphorous, on the other hand, has been a topic of controversy at official meetings concerning the lake, because no one seems certain just how much legacy phosphorous is in Lake Carmi.

The ANR officially estimated Lake Carmi’s internal or legacy phosphorous loading at about 97 kilograms per year, according to the 2008 Lake Carmi Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) report. That’s 6 percent of the lake’s annual phosphorous load.

But the consulting firm the DEC hired in January to study in-lake treatments, Reservoir Environmental Management Inc. (REMI), said the TMDL might have underestimated the lake’s internal phosphorous loading. REMI pointed out the TMDL calculations did not include internal phosphorous increases in the fall because heavy rain in 2006 might have confounded the available data. REMI wrote that could mean the lake’s internal phosphorous levels are higher than the TMDL’s calculation.

Lake in crisis

The Lake Carmi TMDL Implementation Team, a committee of local volunteers and representatives from state agencies, plans a public meeting at the Franklin Homestead on July 19, the team’s first meeting since the legislature passed S.260 this spring.

S.260, also known as the “lakes in crisis” bill, ordered the ANR, Vermont Agency of Agriculture, Food and Markets (AAFM) and Vermont Agency of Transportation (VTrans) to co-design a “crisis response plan” describing how the agencies plan to resolve Carmi’s environmental situation.

That sounds like state officials could order the National Guard to fight the spread of blue-green algae, but official action is likely to be less aggressive: according to this “lakes in crisis” law, the crisis response plan could be just harsher water quality regulations, or stricter oversight of local property owners’ compliance with those regulations.

Thomas said the agencies’ crisis response plan has been drafted, not finalized, and that agency representatives plan to discuss the draft at this meeting.

Thomas said the crisis plan is essentially just the TMDL team’s pre-existing “action plan” renamed and circulated through the AAFM, VTrans and ANR for additional input.

She said from her perspective the main effect of S.260’s passage was greater cooperation between state agencies — which members of the public urged at nearly every official Carmi meeting.

Thursday’s meeting begins at 4:45 p.m.

Neil Kamman, an ANR senior policy analyst, plans to take questions about the legislative mandates behind the new law for 15 minutes.

AAFM Secretary Anson Tebbetts discusses inter-agency cooperation for 15 minutes.

Then Marli Rupe, an ANR agricultural water quality specialist, discusses the draft crisis response plan for another 15 minutes.

The last hour of the meeting, which is scheduled to end at 6:45 p.m., is open for public questions on the crisis response plan.

The results of official studies concerning how to manage the Mill Pond Dam, another source of uncertainty for Lake Carmi residents, is scheduled for discussion at the team’s October meeting.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here