ST. ALBANS – Nurses from the Northwestern Medical Center (NMC) gathered on the hospital’s lawn Thursday afternoon to announce that they had filed a petition with the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) to hold a union election, taking the first steps toward the formation of an NMC nurses union.
According to the nurses, the hospital was struggling with a high turnover rate and impractical staffing ratios, leading to an overworked nursing staff and stressful conditions that only exasperated staffing problems. They claimed that this environment trickled down into patient care, creating safety concerns for patients and their nurses.
By unionizing, NMC nurse Nicole Messier said, the nurses would be able to better negotiate staffing conditions and “frontline” suggestions from the hospital’s estimated 180 nurses, which would allow for both better policy from the ground-up and could help reduce the hospital’s high turnover rate among nurses.
“We’re here today representing the majority of our RN colleagues because we intend to bring a collective nursing experience to the table so that we can insure the decisions being made about the future of our community hospital prioritize patient safety and high-quality care,” said Messier, a nurse in NMC’s operating room with 24 years of experience.
“I want to be very clear here, we have great managers,” Messier continued. “They do the best they can to support us and advocate for our units. We simply feel that we can help them do their jobs better by organizing and setting policy in place through a fair contract.”
“We are struggling daily to maintain staffing,” said Erin Blake, a nurse who’s worked at the hospital for six years. “Often times patients are waiting in our emergency room – not for an empty bed, but for a nurse that can care for them.”
“Other times, patients are transferred to other departments and hospitals,” Blake continued.
“I think if nursing had a say… I think people would stay,” Messier said in a conversation that followed the announcement.
Workforce shortages have been a concern for hospitals nationwide, according to the American Association of Colleges for Nursing (AACN). AACN links the shortage to an increased need for nursing as the Baby Boomer population ages compounded by a loss of enrollments and faculty at nursing schools
It’s a national trend that, according to NMC Vice President of Community Relations Jonathan Billings, NMC hasn’t been spared from.
“Workforce shortages and turnover are a concern across hospitals, and it is something that NMC works very hard on to recruit strong nurses and to retain our staff,” Billings told the Messenger. “But it is a challenging workforce in our community, in Vermont and across the country.”
Similar challenges were referenced by the University of Vermont (UVM) Medical Center’s nurses when they went on strike this summer.
The nurses also suggested that policy changes often occurred at the hospital without consultation of the staff, a fact that drew criticism from many of the nurses who collected near NMC Thursday night.
“Many of our concerns come from policy changes that are done without the knowledge of staff,” explained NMC nurse Samantha McCarthy in a prepared statement. “This includes issues surrounding benefits, our schedules and the requirements for our positions.”
She went on to say that attempts to address policy from the grassroots level were brought up with the nurses’ managers, but those suggestions were ultimately bogged down in organizational and administrative barriers.
“We want the ability to not only have proper changes made for our staff and our hospital, but to know that these changes cannot be taken away on a whim and without discussion,” McCarthy concluded.
While the impacts of staffing ratios frequently came up in the nurses’ addresses, they also narrowed in on how difficult it was to sometimes acquire the tools needed to provide care, such as a bladder scanner in NMC’s Family Birthing Center. Messier described the birthing center’s acquisition of a bladder scanner as a “win,” but qualified that by saying “that shouldn’t be a win – that’s a tool that’s required to give those patients the care that they deserve.”
Before the birthing center acquired that scanner, Messier suggested that nurses from the birthing center would have to have scrambled to another unit and borrowed their scanner.
Acquisition of tools may be something a union could better advocate for than individual requests of managers, which the nurses said get lost in hospital bureaucracy.
“The current practice now is we go to our managers and our managers have to advocate for us,” Messier said. “Sometimes managers can get it and sometimes they can’t.”
“And our managers all advocate for us,” confirmed McCarthy. “But there’s only so much they can do.”
According to Billings, NMC’s leadership has been conducting “listening tours” around its units to more directly connect the hospital’s leadership to feedback from its staff. He said that the tours have been ongoing “for a number of months.”
“We’ve been working through thoughts and suggestions with our staff – both nurses and the rest of the hospital staff – and we intend to continue on that,” Billings said. “NMC prides itself on being responsive, and we need to be responsive.”
The nurses said their unionization effort had nothing to do with wages, with Messier noting that nurses at NMC were paid better than their counterparts in other area hospitals.
In order to create a union, a petition needs to be filed with the NLRB with signatures from at least 30 percent of those who’d be represented by the collective bargaining body. Once the election is organized, those who would be represented by a union vote as to whether or not they should form one.
A majority vote results in the formal creation of a union.
According to Messier, the petition was signed by an “overwhelming majority” of NMC’s nursing staff, meaning they were confident that a union election would result in the formation of an NMC nurses union.
According to Billings, NMC was contacted Thursday morning by the NLRB and would be working with the labor relations board to hold a union election “so our nurses can each have a say as to whether or not that’s the course of action they would want.”
While the nurses didn’t specify which union they would be joining, a Thursday morning press release iabout the organizing effort came from staff with the American Federation of Teachers – Vermont, a teaching union under the larger American Federation of Labor – Congress of Industrial Organizations (AFL-CIO).
The nurses said they approached the hospital’s leadership before filing with the NLRB, asking to voluntarily bargain rather than go through a union election process. The hospital reportedly said no, leading NMC nurses to petition for a union election.
Messier said they expect the hospital to fight the unionization effort.
A Thursday morning press release distributed by the nurses originally planned their announcement for NMC’s main entrance. Instead, the entrance was left vacant and nurses were forced to collect on the hospital’s lawn.
“They wouldn’t even let us walk through the door tonight,” Messier said, before reiterating that they meant “no ill will” to the hospital’s leadership.
When asked about whether or not the unionization effort will lead to frayed relationships between the nurses and the hospital, the nurses were optimistic.
“I think that may be,” said longtime NMC nurse Diane Greenfield. “But it doesn’t have to be.”
Billings said that, while NMC would be working with the NLRB to host those union elections, the hospital maintains that a nurses union wouldn’t be beneficial for improving the quality of care for the hospital’s patients.
“The hospital does not believe that inserting a union between the hospital and its staff is beneficial to anyone, particularly on areas such as how we care for our patients,” Billings said. “We’re hopeful that we can continue to work directly with our nurses and we’re really proud of the quality of care that they and the entire NMC team provide.”
The NMC nurses’ push toward unionization comes after a settlement between the University of Vermont Medical Center and their nurses’ union, which included 48-hour strike in July. Nurses have yet to vote on the proposed contract.
Though UVM Medical Center maintains a dialysis lab at NMC, NMC’s nurses say their efforts to unionize are unrelated to the UVM strike.
Stay informed on what’s happening in Franklin County, subscribe here.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here