Montgomery, Sheldon protest school merger proposal

Posted

NEWARK, Vt. — During a State Board of Education meeting in Newark last Wednesday, schoolboards and community members from Montgomery and Sheldon protested the acting Secretary of Education recommendation that they merge with the now unified Berkshire-Bakersfield school district.

Passed in 2015, Act 46 created a multi-year process that encouraged school districts to voluntarily merge with neighboring districts to reduce administrative spending and improve educational outcomes. Districts could forego voluntary mergers with the understanding that the state might order them to merge in the future.

As a part of Act 46, the Vermont Secretary of Education drafted a set of recommended mergers that the State Board of Education will vote on later this year. The board will ultimately decide which mergers to force this fall.

Both Sheldon and Montgomery have historically opposed the idea of merging with another school district. Montgomery voters rejected two merger proposals since the passage of Act 46 and, last November, town residents approved an item declaring their school “an existing district in an alternative structure” to meet Act 46’s goals.

In a similar nonbinding vote held from the floor last November, Sheldon also voted to remain an independent school district.

Montgomery

Montgomery School Board members Mary Niles, Catherine Howell and Christina Suarez-Pratt represented the town’s dissent to the education secretary’s recommendations, hinging their dissent on both their voters’ past rejections of merger proposals and on their assertion that the Montgomery Elementary School was too geographically isolated to make a merger practical.

The board also defended their community’s interest in maintaining local control over their school, echoing other school districts’ beliefs that, with a merged district, they’ll lose influence as a smaller town on a unified school board.

“We stridently stand behind our [alternative governance structure] and emphatically disagree with the secretary’s assessment,” Niles said, introducing the hearing as she read off a prewritten statement. “We have much to lose if forced to relinquish the autonomy of our board, our physical property and the agency to shape our school for the years ahead.”

An alternative governance structure (AGS) offers a way for schools to preclude a merger, depending on whether or not the district is able to present an AGS better suited for meeting Act 46’s goals of affordability and improved outcomes.

With Montgomery’s geographic isolation and relatively strong performance – Niles cited the school’s high teacher-student ratio and generally strong test performances – Niles reaffirmed their school board’s insistence that a merger was impracticable for the elementary school.

Citing Montgomery’s past rejections of mergers, Niles also echoed sentiments shared during a previous presentation by the Franklin Northwest Supervisory Union (FNWSU)’s school boards: that the forced mergers recommended by the secretary of education were inherently undemocratic.

“Our voters have categorically rejected both incarnations of merger plans,” she said, spurring a standing ovation from the audience behind her. “Dismissing this as ‘community sentiment’ is an affront to all who value the notion of one person, one vote.”

Niles, and later Suarez-Pratt, compared Montgomery’s recommended merger to Stowe’s excused merger, declaring a “socio-economic bias” that favored Stowe despite what they claimed was a similar case of geographic isolation that, ultimately, according to the secretary’s recommendations, contributed to Stowe’s continued independence.

“One of the most frustrating aspects of the AoE plan is how arbitrary and inconsistent the recommendations are,” “Stowe is ‘trusted’ to find a path forward. Stowe and [Elmore-Morristown Unified Union school district] are ‘an entirely unique situation.’

“Stowe’s admitted socio-economic and cultural distinctness isn’t seen as elitist or exclusionary, although, with a poverty rate of 10.7 percent, does that district truly meet the mandate of regional equity?”

“They get rewarded with maintaining their structure but we are not given the same,” Suarez-Pratt later summarized more bluntly to another ring of applause. “Many of my community members view this as inherent socio-economic bias on the part of the secretary’s recommendation.”

The secretary’s recommendations related to merging the Stowe and Elmore-Morristown Unified Union (EMUU) school districts had more to do with the nature of EMUU’s previous voluntary merger than it did Stowe’s geographic and economic situations.

According to those recommendations, EMUU’s request that “it be given time to adjust to the governance changes it voluntarily embraces… before the EMUU considers the additional challenge of further merger” was enough, when paired with the collaborative work between EMUU and Stowe’s districts, to hold off a recommended forced merger.

The secretary’s recommendations add that there were no other districts near Stowe with a similar Pre-Kindergarten through 12th grade structure with which Stowe could practicably merge.

“It not only denies the will of the electorate, but also our geographic isolation,” Suarez-Pratt said, decrying Montgomery’s recommended merger with Sheldon, Berkshire and Bakersfield before recommending that board members “travel our Class 3 or Class 4 roads where we have little state road access for children on buses.”

The secretary’s recommendations did consider the geographic isolation cited in Montgomery’s AGS, but ultimately concluded that it wouldn’t prevent a merger, as Montgomery already shares some staff with other Franklin County schools and sends half of its tuitioned high schoolers to schools outside of their supervisory union.

Suarez-Pratt also criticized the possible assumption of debt it could take on should Montgomery be forced into a recommended merger, calling it a debt ratio “on which Montgomery is certainly going to lose out.”

Under Vermont’s statewide education tax system, every resident is already paying for the debts of every school in the state, as those debts are paid out of the Education Fund, into which all education taxes go.

She and Niles ultimately criticized the whole of Act 46, with both stating that the shakeups of existing school structures could affect schools’ abilities to educate their students or, ostensibly, lead to closures of rural schools like Montgomery Elementary School.

No one with the State Board of Education or the Agency of Education has expressed any interest with closing the Montgomery Elementary School. Elsewhere in the state, mergers have led to school closures, but those schools were micro-schools with student bodies of only 50 or less, and those schools were closed with the approval of local voters.

Niles and Suarez-Pratt extended their criticism to mergers in other states as well, particularly citing those in Maine, West Virginia and Arkansas, where, according to the Montgomery School Board members, mergers had proven problematic in the past.

“As the Montgomery board considers the well-being of all children, I implore the board to either grant all AGS proposals or send this back to the legislature at the very least,” Suarez-Pratt called to the board.

Behind her, an audience ranging from Franklin to Charleston stamped their feet and hollered with approval.

Sheldon

Sheldon shared the discontentment expressed in a previous presentation from fellow FNWSU school boards, stating that its recommended merger was both a challenge to a unanimous nonbinding vote against school mergers as well as failing to account for the school’s low per pupil spending.

Added weight came, however, with the fact that the secretary’s recommendation included moving Sheldon to an entirely new supervisory union.

 

For the full story pick up a copy of Tuesday’s Messenger. 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here