Messenger FAQs: What's behind local business departures?

Posted

FRANKLIN COUNTY — As a newspaper company, we love to see people reacting to what we are reporting.

Each week, the Saint Albans Messenger publishes a few dozen articles, resulting in hundreds of comments received via social media, our website and reader discussions. 

As we watch conversations about our coverage evolve online, this new series will set out to respond to some of the community’s follow-up questions. Rarely is there a black-and-white answer to complicated policy questions, so we don’t expect to provide one. But we are hoping to bring data points, a few facts and some ongoing viewpoints from across the region to help clarify the debate where we can.

Your question: Franklin Foods is leaving Enosburg Falls. Does Trump or VT deserve blame?

President Donald Trump’s second term in the White House began this past year with plenty of economic turmoil as wide-ranging tariffs impacted global trade.

Meanwhile, the State of Vermont has obtained a reputation for being a small-scale state that regularly pushes back against large-scale development.

So why is Franklin Foods closing? Is it because of the turmoil on the national scene? Or is it because Vermont hates business?

We reached out to Franklin Foods to ask for a reason behind the move and didn’t get a response. But then, there are plenty of economic signs to consider. Franklin Foods is the third large manufacturer to leave the county this year.

Why are they leaving?

In its latest annual report, Franklin County Industrial Development Corporation noted that 2025 wasn’t exactly a kind year for the county’s plans, citing tariffs, high costs of construction and high interest rates as a few “strikes” against its economic future.

“Throw in the fact that the Canadiens are upset with the U.S. government for applying the tariffs and the rhetoric about making Canada the 51st state and we have an unofficial Canadian boycott on visiting the United States and buying U.S. products,” FCIDC executive director Tim Smith stated in the annual report.

Out of those impacts, the tariffs and rhetoric can be directly tied to Trump, although it can be hard to put a direct number on how much those impacts are playing out in Vermont. Econofact, – an economic news publication – relied on data tracking to estimate that tariffs increased the price of goods nationally by 0.7% this past year, although they admitted some companies were likely able to absorb the new tax to dilute the impact.

As a result, the United States government collected $287 billion via tariffs in 2025 — or about three times 2024’s rate  — through Trump’s tariff policy.

As for Trump’s rhetoric on Canada, experts in Vermont have tracked a decrease of 23% in Canadian traffic coming from across the border this past year, looking at the first six months of 2025 when compared to the same time in 2024, with northern areas of the state likely impacted more from the drop in travel. Roughly $150 million is brought into Vermont due to Canadian tourism.

As for high interest rates and high construction costs though, Trump’s responsibility largely wanes. In fact, the federal reserve is actively working to reduce the president’s influence on the federal interest rate, and as for high construction costs, building material prices have been increasing at a fast pace for the last few years likely due to market forces, although this past year’s tariffs likely haven’t helped, as much of Vermont’s lumber comes from Canada.

Looking at the factories

While Franklin Foods leaving is a big hit to the county’s manufacturing base, it’s not the only company that announced its departure in the last year. Prior to Franklin Foods, Perrigo — a baby formula production facility in Georgia — also reported its intention to leave its factory and eliminate 425 jobs in the county. Richford’s Kaytec — which produced vinyl siding — has already left without giving much detail about the company’s exit. 

Taking a closer look at all three, however, does provide some alarming context that companies could be pulling back on Vermont investments in light of economic headwinds.

In the Messenger’s original piece on Franklin Foods, for example, reporter Aidan Schonbrun noted that Franklin Foods was acquired by Hochland Group, a German cheese producer,  in 2017, but this year the group sold Franklin Foods to Wisconsin-based Schreiber Foods after citing a “lack of profitability” in the American market. Schreiber Foods, preparing for a new CEO, closed Franklin Foods not long after.

Meanwhile, by November at Perrigo, the company started undertaking "strategic review of its infant formula business.”

“This proactive review is about discipline and ensuring the Company’s portfolio is best positioned for sustainable growth and free cash flow generation. While our infant formula operations have stabilized, the external environment has quickly changed,” President and CEO Patrick Lockwood-Taylor said in a written statement. 

As for Kaytec, the company’s web presence has largely been scrubbed, although there are rumors of a new company coming into the region to take over the facility. 

So what does all that mean for Franklin County? It could be a rough few years.

Few will argue Trump’s rhetoric hasn’t had any impact on economic fortunes, but then, if manufacturers are waving red flags, then they’re likely finding limited options in Vermont to make the future profit trendlines work.

What’s happening in Vermont?

While Trump’s policies are impacting the national economy in various ways, Vermont is actively dealing with multiple concurrent affordability crises.

The two biggest cost-centers, however, are housing and health insurance. Both create major economic drag on companies and employees, as both costs raise the standard price of doing business in Vermont while lowering living standards for residents who can’t afford either.

The State of Vermont has spent millions on housing in an effort to change the trendline, but then again, the state’s regulatory policies across the board haven’t done much to encourage the pace needed to tackle its backlog, largely inflating the price of building and raising the cost of land as the problem persists.

The latest build in St. Albans City, for example, was completed with each apartment expected to cost over $300,000 to taxpayers.

Meanwhile, many middle-income workers in Vermont are pushing for raises to be able to cover their living costs. Some of the biggest increases to people’s bills seen in the last decade — education, healthcare and law enforcement  — are directly related to workers needing increased pay to deal with Vermont’s affordability crisis. 

Private businesses inherently feel the squeeze as they weigh how to react. Do they give their own employees a raise? Or will raising prices cut down on profits? 

Or do they leave Vermont entirely?

Last year, Vermont lost roughly 2,000 from its population due to people leaving the state after seeing its post-COVID-19 bump, according to recently released Census data, and the lack of a workforce is also still an issue from a demographic perspective. Over time, the decades-long trend has caused the average age of residents to creep upward, as young people seek out their economic fortunes elsewhere.

Ultimately, we can’t say definitively what economic obstacles – whether its national changes or Vermont’s business climate – are weighing more heavily on local businesses. Each industry inherently has many variables to consider when following its business plans, but if tough times are ahead as many expect, then this past year has signaled that Vermonters are now facing multiple concurrent economic headwinds incoming on both the federal and state level.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here