Merger opponents meet with Lt. Gov.

Posted

SHELDON – In anticipation of forced mergers recommended by the Secretary of Education earlier this year, residents from Franklin, Highgate, Sheldon and Montgomery assembled at the Abbey Monday afternoon to make their case against merging to Lt. Gov. David Zuckerman.

Those communities had historically opposed merging with their neighboring communities. In the case of Franklin and Sheldon, a nonbinding vote opposing a merger found unanimous support in floor votes, while Highgate saw a floor vote against merging win 103-1.

Two attempts at merging Montgomery’s school district with another were defeated in formal town votes.

Act 46 is the state’s law governing school district consolidation. Passed in 2015, the law set up a timeline for the merger process where districts were encouraged to merge. Those electing not to merge risked a forced merger at the end of the Act 46 proceedings should they be unable to prove they could meet Act 46’s stated goals as independent schools.

This last June, the acting Secretary of Education handed down a list of recommended mergers for the State Board of Education to ultimately vote on. Included in those recommendations was a governance merger of the Swanton, Franklin and Highgate with the high school they jointly operate, Missisquoi Valley Union, as well as the addition of Sheldon and Montgomery to a smaller unified district already created by Berkshire and Bakersfield.

Zuckerman had, during his time in the state senate, voted in favor of Act 46, and defended a part of the law that, when drafted, should have provided what he called an “off ramp” for schools that met the act’s goals – namely Section 9, which allowed districts to draft alternative governance structures that might better meet those goals.

“We knew that one size doesn’t fit all,” Zuckerman said. “We drafted a law to make sure there was an opportunity for communities that felt like the system wouldn’t work for them to be able to have a sort of right of appeal…”

Zuckerman also noted that, while he was meeting with troubled residents, the ultimate authority on Act 46 didn’t rest with the lieutenant governor’s office.

“You’re right, there is no one size fits all policy in the state of Vermont,” said Franklin’s Jay Denault, who argued that, with the way the populations were divided between the towns in the proposed MVU district, Franklin, with the smallest population, could lose its stake in a proportionally divided board.

He suggested that, based on the populations of the other member communities in Swanton and Highgate, a proportional board would be divided in favor of Swanton. Denault added that this could lead to both a loss of local control over Franklin Central School, as well as a loss of protection for that school.

A proportionally divided school district isn’t the only option for a unified district. Should the whole of a unified district be allowed to vote on each representative on the school board, a unified board could be divided evenly between the member communities.

Still, a situation where a board was formed proportionally according to population was enough of a fear for Franklin and Highgate residents that they raised the issue with Zuckerman, going as far as suggesting that it could lead to a scenario where residents in Swanton vote to shuttle Highgate students to Swanton and Franklin residents to Highgate, thus allowing the unified district to close Franklin’s school.

“For us it’s a real crisis,” Denault said.

When Zuckerman asked if there was record somewhere of a conspiracy to reshuffle the proposed MVU district to close Franklin, Denault admitted that there wasn’t but claimed Act 46 “set the stage” for that scenario.

Currently, with population growth in Swanton and Highgate and with increased student enrollment in each, it’s unclear if either school would be able to handle additional students from Franklin.

Enrollment in Franklin Central School, while not experiencing the upward trend of its neighbors, has maintained a constant student population around 120 students, something residents have noted in the past in light of the acting secretary’s recommendations asserting that Franklin was experiencing a “significant decline” in enrollments.

Denault did add, however, that Franklin was one of the best performing schools in the state, an argument made by Franklin residents when they previously protested the Secretary of Education’s proposed merger.

He also referenced a 2011 study that listed Franklin as “geographically isolated,” a condition Act 46 recommended the Agency of Education “be mindful” of when considering a forced merger.

The arguments made by these dissenting communities found support among state legislators, with state senators Carolyn Branagan, R – Franklin, and Randy Brock , R – Franklin, as well as a handful of representatives and candidates, attending Monday afternoon’s meeting.

“We have several communities that are considering turning themselves into independent districts, because they want so badly to keep their own school,” Branagan said. “I think you probably know from current research that, for these small towns… if you take the school away or change the school so that it’s no longer the heart of the community, you lose the sense of togetherness.”

Denault told Zuckerman that residents in Franklin had already submitted a petition to sell their school’s property to the town and convert the Franklin School District into a “non-operating district.”

Also present were members of school boards from Sheldon, Highgate and Montgomery, each hoping to make their own case against their recommended mergers to the lieutenant governor.

A recurring theme of dismissed votes and testimony was referenced by residents from each of the districts, citing a belief that their votes were dismissed by the State Board of Education when those communities testified to the board last month.

Shawn Stebbins, the vice chair of the Sheldon school board, criticized the Agency of Education for taking a “bird’s eye view” of their schools when recommending Sheldon merge with Berkshire, Bakersfield and Montgomery, a move that would realign Sheldon’s school district with an entirely new supervisory union.

“We understand our test results aren’t great,” Stebbins said before explaining that the school was dealing with significant special education challenges that could be exacerbated by the shift to a new supervisory union.

Special education is coordinated at the supervisory union level, and Stebbins cited work done in the Franklin Northwest Supervisory Union (FNWSU) that has helped address some of the special education needs at Sheldon.

A move to another supervisory union could dramatically upset that work, Stebbins argued. He added that the move to the Franklin Northeast Supervisory Union would also require Sheldon’s school to realign curriculum, effectively forcing them to “completely restart” their work that, according to Stebbins, had seen Sheldon’s test scores improve.

He also cited cooperation at the supervisory union level as proof Franklin Northwest’s schools, which include MVU’s member districts, were meeting Act 46’s goals.

“I just don’t understand it,” Stebbins said. “If they looked down and looked deeper – are there some things we could change, sure and we’ve identified that, but we’re already doing a lot of stuff.”

Zuckerman spent time setting the context that ultimately passed Act 46, explaining that there was pressure statewide to save money on educational spending despite the fact that, according to Zuckerman, preceding education reforms had impacted those.

What Zuckerman referred to as a “drumbeat for change” ultimately led to Act 46, adding that, even if there were rural schools in northern Vermont that did manage their spending and did produce good outcomes for their students, “the state can’t pass a law that says we’re going to treat some people differently than other people.”

He also argued that, with Act 46, “there are savings to be had,” but suggested that the arguments being made by present schools seemed to qualify those communities for Act 46’s “off ramp,” precluding them from a merger.

Zuckerman also noted that despite its high costs, Vermont’s education system was producing better outcomes than those from other rural states, and that it’d probably stay expensive due to demographic trends that kept younger people away from rural states like Vermont, which would in turn keep enrollments sparse.

Still, though Zuckerman admitted authority on Act 46 rested with the State Board of Education, he said he’d lobby the state board for information to at least better understand where they’re coming from in re Act 46.

“I can certainly inquire with respect to the report [the Agency of Education] put together and inquire the state board of education what kind of independent investigation they did based on what the Agency of Education provided them,” Zuckerman said.

The final remarks came from Devin Bachelor, a member of Franklin’s school board who previously criticized the state’s education plan as “discouraging” for looking to trim staff numbers rather than “look at it from the other side” and grow student numbers.

“It’s important to realize that we all support the goals of Act 46,” Bachelor said. “We can still get there under the Section 9 proposals.”

 

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here