ST. ALBANS — Judge Martin A. Maley sentenced Norm McAllister to nine months to a year, all suspended, with one year’s probation and multiple conditions, in Franklin County Superior Court today.
Maley said jail time was “not proportional” to the charge on which a jury convicted McAllister, prohibited acts, essentially prostitution, based on sentencing in other cases.
But the conditions of McAllister’s sentence are important. The court ordered he serve 25 days on a work crew, and that he complete a sex offender assessment, and follow its recommendations.
The court also prohibited McAllister from contact with the lead witness in the case, including coming within 300 feet of her, her place of residence or her place of employment.
And the court administered five standard probation conditions, including requiring that McAllister notify his probation officer if he is convicted of another crime.
But the court delayed imposing the sentence after McAllister’s defense, led by attorney Bob Katims, made a motion to stay his sentence. The court will delay ruling on the motion until state prosecutors can respond. The State’s written response is due within the next 14 days.
Outside the courthouse after the sentencing, McAllister told reporters, “I’m saying the same thing I’ve said from the beginning. I was innocent from the beginning. I think they’ve got this thing all wrong.”
Katims said McAllister’s defense team has already filed a notice of appeal to the Vermont Supreme Court.
Maley spent several minutes explaining his reasoning behind the sentence. He said this was a “unique case.”
“I don’t think I have seen a prohibited acts case, or anything quite like this, before the court,” he said.
McAllister’s defense team submitted a memorandum to the court containing letters of support from community members characterized as “glowing” by Maley. The judge also said he found McAllister “fairly charming” from his testimony in court, but added he found the lead witness’s testimony credible.
Maley said he found aspects of McAllister’s testimony “troubling,” specifically, McAllister’s assertion that he and the lead witness had a consensual and, for him, consoling relationship after his wife’s death.
“The notion… that that entirely explains his behavior… to suggest… that he felt that was [the lead witness’s] way of expressing affections for him… that was an awkward piece of testimony,” Maley said.
He agreed with state prosecutor John Lavoie’s assertion that McAllister has not taken responsibility for his actions.
Lavoie asserted that McAllister has a history of taking advantage of vulnerable women, based not just on this conviction, but on the entirety of the State’s evidence against McAllister, including allegations from two other women, which were not the subject of this trial. Lavoie asked Maley to consider McAllister’s alleged history of abuse in sentencing him.
But Katims argued that the defense violated legal procedure by not providing adequate notice of this request, and Maley agreed. “The court has to go back to what it has before it,” he said: a misdemeanor prohibited acts conviction, for which Vermont allows a sentence of up to one year and/or a fine of $100.
Maley noted that McAllister is 66, has no prior criminal record, served in the state legislature and was “re-elected in this community many times.” Then there were the “glowing” support letters the defense submitted.
“That’s the positive side,” Maley said. The question, he said, “is why someone who has that much compassion, [and is] that hardworking, can find himself in a situation where he takes advantage of a very vulnerable person…
“[McAllister] didn’t give much thought, if any, to the feelings of [the lead witness], in terms of how he was treating her. I don’t know how he can come to terms with that… The notion that this was somehow a mutually agreeable type of arrangement is not accurate.
“This is an abuse of power,” Maley said, though McAllister — “strangely, I thought” — testified that he was not conscious of his power and status in the community.
Maley said the fact that the State hasn’t charged McAllister again during the two years this case has run through the court system is “a good sign,” but that the court’s sentence still had to have a rehabilitative element, as well as an element of deterrence, especially because the case has been highly publicized and discussed in the community.
Katims, earlier, argued that a jail sentence was not proportional to the circumstances of this case, an assertion with which Maley ultimately agreed. Katims said probation might not even be appropriate.
“The court routinely sentences people to a fine only on first offenses, or even second offenses,” for DUI convictions, he said.
McAllister declined to speak on his behalf, but the lead witness made a statement to the court.
“As hard as it has been to relive every detail,” she said, “I feel it was worth it to get where we are today… It is a tremendous relief to know I will never again be subjected to any violation by Mr. McAllister, or his friends.”
She asserted that McAllister lied under oath, and urged the court to administer a penalty that “teaches him what he did was wrong.”
“Sometimes a man can confess his sins and not be reasonably held accountable,” she said.
Lavoie asked the court to include incarceration in the sentence. In-prison programming could provide a rehabilitative element, so a jail sentence for McAllister wouldn’t be purely punitive, he said.
“Given what we’ve learned,” Lavoie said, “it’s obvious his attitude toward women, particularly vulnerable women, needs correction and adjustment.”
He said a strong sentence would send a message to people prone to taking advantage of vulnerable women.
Lavoie based his urging that the court consider all the allegations against McAllister on U.S. v. Watts, a 1997 case in which a federal judge determined “acquittal is not equivalent with innocence,” Lavoie said.
“The defendant wants to remind you he’s done a service to his community,” Lavoie said. “A jury of his peers — his peers — have identified him as a pimp. And that’s what he is before this court.”
In addition to McAllister’s appeals, he will face the lead witness again in a civil case she has filed against him, which was delayed while the criminal case was resolved.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here