Maggie and Ella Dunigan find healing and strength in sports

Posted

Ella and Maggie Dunigan, twin sisters and members of the Class of 2026 at BFA-St. Albans, spent their high school years competing in three varsity sports–volleyball, basketball, and softball.

The duo was part of the state championship-winning softball teams and the history-making volleyball teams that reached program firsts at the semifinal and final games.

They were well-known for their quiet confidence, kindness, and dedication to their team and teammates. Their world was turned upside down midway through high school after the death of their father. The girls embraced opportunities to heal, grow, and flourish under the guidance and care of the caring and supportive BFA-St. Albans community.

Q&A with Maggie and Ella Dunigan

What did you most enjoy about playing three varsity sports together?

Ella: Our dynamic—people talked about how we could read each other, and we do. We know what the other person is going to do. We play off one another and uplift one another. As a twin, you always have someone to back you up and help you, no matter what. Always having that person by your side really helped us in these seasons.

Maggie: The best part was the dynamic we brought. People knew us, but this was another way to get to meet people. We loved doing the Comet camps and being an example for younger players. We didn’t have to be the best players on the court, but we could bring a great attitude and effort. We could show the culture of the sports we played.

What sport was your favorite and why?

Ella: Volleyball really turned into our favorite sport. We hadn’t played until our freshman year of high school, and we fell in love with it. The dynamic, the closeness of the team, getting to try something new together—it was hard and a little scary, but we had each other. As the years went on, it became a lot of fun for us. It was more than a team; it was a family. That became really big for that culture.

Maggie: I think the culture around volleyball was so special, and I loved watching it build over the last four years. We made it to the semis and the championship, and that team was such a family, especially after losing our dad. They lifted us up and supported us as family.

How has your bond of being a twin impacted your relationships with others?

Ella: When you grow up with someone and are around them your entire life, you’ve seen the best and the worst. You realize you want to do everything in your power to make sure they’re at their best. You want them to be happy and included. I want people to be their best selves. I want to do everything in my power to make sure others feel happy and seen. That’s impacted my view as a teammate and a friend.

Maggie: When you become so focused on being around someone and having the stability of having someone by your side, it makes you want to be that way for others as well. I’m used to sharing everything, making people comfortable where they are—even if it’s being a silent presence of support—just being there. As a twin, I’ve had someone by my side forever, and it makes me comfortable around others. That changes the dynamic and helps people feel safe and be comfortable with who they are. That’s really special.

How do you have fun with being twins?

Maggie: It’s so funny when we’re playing against other teams, especially in basketball. Seeing reactions and being asked if we’re twins. Our opponents can’t tell us apart unless they look at our numbers.

Ella: It’s funny when people call us by the wrong names and don't know we have a twin, or when they call us by the wrong names and we don’t correct them.

What are your favorite memories of playing together at BFA-St. Albans?

Maggie:

Volleyball: My favorite memory was right after we lost the state championship this year. It’s one of the most powerful memories. I remember giving Ella a hug, and we don’t usually hug each other. It spoke a lot, and we were so grateful for the time we had playing together. It was sad to see it come to an end, but it was such a great time.

Basketball: The biggest thing about basketball—it’s such a long season, and while we struggled, when we succeeded it was the best. We persevered through adversity, and that opened our minds—just because you lose more than you win doesn’t mean you forget how to win. It makes you work harder. You strive for it, and it has that ‘drive’ mentality. What can I do differently? Can I focus more on "we" than on "me"? I may not be the best player, but how can I help our team get back into a winning mindset—how can I help my team get better?

Softball: It’s such a dynasty and legacy to uphold, and it can be stressful. It didn’t feel heavy with those girls. The amount of fun we had and how we viewed each other—as one team, not as individuals. We’d do chants for everyone, and all had nicknames, and everyone had fun with it. It was the best part.

Ella:

Volleyball: We talk a lot about our home game against Champlain Valley Union this year. It was such a powerful game and one of the best we’ve ever played. It was a powerful memory because our sport has grown so much and the stands were full. In that game, everyone played so well, and we had such a great game.

Basketball: We played the sport because we liked it, but we played it for each other and our teammates. Before every home game, we’d dance, laugh, and have a good time. We were there to have fun together, to work hard, and to play for each other. We’re going to try to win, but at the end of the day, you’re only as good as the person next to you. Cheering for one another, helping people up off the floor—that was my favorite part about basketball.

Softball: Softball was incredible over the last two years—two undefeated seasons and state championships —but aside from the games, we had the best group of girls. I remember the moments we had in the dugout, with everyone cheering each other on and picking each other up. Being there with all those girls was something to look forward to every day.

How did the loss of your father in your junior year shape your perspective on life and sports?

Maggie: It gives a lot of clarity about what you can and can’t control. Who you are and what drives you makes a difference. We entered our senior year wanting to make the most of it. Looking at everything now, I think the world would be better if people worked for a cause rather than applause, and lived to express rather than impress.

Ella: You lose a lot in life, but you win a lot too. You hold onto wins and losses, but what you hold onto the most is the people around you. That stood out to us—just people being there for one another. Maggie and I had so many people around us. People told us they were sad because we had to grow up so fast, but it meant so much to have so many people around to help us and support us, and sports were a big part of that. It really helped us to get through that time. For me, after our dad passed and we jumped back into sports, I focused on putting my game face on. It worked for a while and gave us something to focus on. It helped us push forward as we were getting back into a routine. During volleyball and as it got closer to the end of the year, it got harder. We had such amazing coaches, and people reached out to us. It reminded me that we were people, not just athletes. Something so incredibly difficult happened, and it was time to acknowledge it—to be comfortable talking about what happened and to open up.

Do you have any thank-yous? Our coaches, our BFA-St. Albans Athletic Director Dan Marlow, BFA-St. Albans Athletic Trainer Megan Robitaille, our mom Heather, and our teammates, friends, teammates' parents, and all the people we’ve met through sports.

# sanl, bellows free academy - st. albans, comets, comet volleyball, comet softball, comet basketball, varsity, cancer, death, photography, teammates, twins

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here