Locals get first look at Exit 19 design; Hybrid roundabout would be ‘first of its kind’

Posted

ST. ALBANS TOWN — As Franklin County’s busiest intersection, the interchange between Exit 19 and state Route 104 in St. Albans has been on the shortlist for an upgrade for decades. But are residents ready for the first hybrid roundabout in Vermont?

The Vermont Agency of Transportation completed its first of two early public hearings on the project Wednesday night to gain local feedback on the question. Overall, people were hesitant.

While a few residents gave roundabouts positive remarks on Wednesday, others in the room worried about the impacts and potential accidents associated with free-flowing traffic.

Such concerns are expected to be addressed, consulting engineer Corey Mack said, as the engineering process moves forward and VTrans officials incorporate what was discussed Wednesday into the final design.

“As we’ve discussed here, there’s no simple solution that addresses every single concern,” he said. “There’s the pedestrian overpass. There are the right turns. There are a lot of different things, and we have to come up with a solution that addresses all of them as best as we can. So that’s the next step.”

Far down the road

As the intersection that essentially funnels interstate traffic to the rest of Franklin County, Exit 19 has been a consistent subject of study for Vermont’s Agency of Transportation.

VTrans completed its first scoping study to examine the possibility of an upgrade back in 2002. The document was then updated in 2009.

That data, however, is now 15-years-old, and state engineers are taking another look to see what improvements could be made. Issues identified at the intersection, Mack said, include a high crash rate, a complete lack of bike or pedestrian access and limited traffic capacity.

Mack presented three options to residents Wednesday that could help alleviate those concerns. They were a “do-nothing” approach, updating the four-way intersection with an improved traffic pattern or installing a roundabout.

Mack’s presentation included the simulated traffic numbers that would result from each of the three options, and he led an hour-long discussion between attendees following the presentation. 

The resulting information gleaned from the public hearing would then be incorporated into the final design, he said. In real-time, any actual construction is closer to four to eight years out, and residents will have multiple chances to voice opinions and concerns as the project progresses.

“If you look back to the previous studies, they said that it would be done by now. So that gives you a sense of where it could go, also,” he said.

Foot traffic

Out of the three options presented Wednesday, two of the three would include major construction projects at the intersection. 

The first would expand the roadway approaching the intersection, turning each approach into three lanes. The construction project would, in theory, result in less queuing as people wait for the light. 

The second design proposal would create a hybrid roundabout at the intersection. Mack presented a variation of a two-lane roundabout, with some differences for drivers choosing which lane to use in the north and south approaches.

Such a roundabout design would be the first of its kind in Vermont. All other roundabouts in Vermont are one-lane designs, he said.

Attendees voiced concerns about some of the various intricacies of which lane connects where. Mack emphasized that engineers could still change how a roundabout would actually fit in the space, leaving such comments moot until a final design is released.

The discussion, however, did leave state officials with a few more insights into how traffic patterns in the area are handled by drivers. At rush hour, the intersection can funnel thousands of vehicles toward some of the most highly-trafficked routes in Franklin County, and locals operating in the area expressed the need to take extra precautions when navigating the intersection.

A few wanted to see more initiatives to slow down traffic in the area, as many children and families utilize the nearby Collins Perley Sports & Fitness Center.

Multiple attendees also spoke on the need for better bike and pedestrian access through the intersection. A large obstacle in that endeavor is the St. Albans State Highway. The road often has fast-moving heavy truck traffic, including buses, and those in attendance voiced concerns that trying to cross that roadway on foot was akin to a deathtrap.

To address the issue, both proposed designs would install sidewalks in the area. The first of the two – the expanded three-lane approach – is estimated to cost $3.3 million. The hybrid roundabout’s price tag was set at $3.7 million. 

At least two residents in attendance pushed for expanding the project outside of those financial bounds to do even more for pedestrians. Instead of just updating the intersection, they wanted to see a full pedestrian bridge, or something similar, to better adjust to an expected increase of foot traffic in the area. 

In theory, the intersection project could then be paired with the Town of St. Albans’ Health Path project. The north-south walking trail is expected to form an expanded network of trails throughout St. Albans eastern side, eventually connecting Collins Perley with the Hard’Ack Recreation Area. 

The project has since completed a scoping study to examine the necessary pathway for that trail, and the town is pursuing necessary right-of-way permitting. Obtaining funding, however, is likely years in the future.

The bigger picture

Meeting attendees also voiced concerns about how a roundabout fits with other traffic patterns in the area.

The proposed design would require rebuilding the interstate’s southbound off-ramp to be located further east since a roundabout requires a longer approach. Trying to turn right into that northbound traffic exiting I-89 could end up being an issue.

Similarly, attendees brought up that drivers trying to turn left into either Jolley’s or Maplefields – the two convenience stores located at the intersection’s south and north ends – often have to wait to find a gap in fast-moving traffic.

Mack said the analysis conducted by VTrans doesn’t expect there to be an issue for those areas. Leaving the intersection unchanged, however, would likely end up with expanded wait times and more congestion.

“If we don’t do anything, we’re going to be in a pretty poor traffic condition,” he said.

Mack said neither design was a completely perfect solution. Traffic analysis of the two designs show the roundabout would likely function well throughout the day, but there could be some constraints during rush hour.

“In the peak hours, it doesn’t perform as well as the signal, but for the rest of the day, it’s like smooth sailing through this intersection,” he said.

Next steps for the design process include incorporating residents' thoughts into the final design, and there will be a second chance in later this summer for local residents to voice their opinions about what kind of a design they’d like to see for the intersection. 

Once the final design is completed, VTrans engineers will then present their work to the Town of St. Albans Selectboard to rally any public support for the project and to keep taxpayers informed about the progress.

Multiple stakeholders from both the city, town and state were in attendance Wednesday night to hear the conversation. They included Town of St. Albans selectboard members Jack Brigham and Bryan DesLauriers, St. Albans City Ward 5 Alderperson Erik Johnson and state Reps. Lynn Dickinson (R-St. Albans Town) and Matt Walker (R-Swanton).

Mack’s presentation and expanded information on the intersection’s traffic patterns can be found at the project’s website, at tiny.cc/m8j4yz.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here