This letter is from Walter Carpenter, a resident of Montpelier.
Emerson Lynn’s editorial “Choice between groceries and a doctor visit" (Messenger, January 30, 2026), was an excellent commentary to ask ourselves why we as a state and a nation persist in inflicting these “choices” upon our people. Mr Lynn wrote in his opening stanzas: “The stories abound. People who struggled to pay their health insurance premiums last year are finding it almost impossible. Those particularly vulnerable are the Vermonters who buy their health insurance through Vermont’s healthcare exchange. On average, their premiums have gone up 114 percent.”
The question implicit in this statement is what is it about our state and nation that we allow our people to be so vulnerable in the first place? Why do we force our fellow citizens to choose between the rising cost of groceries and the ever-growing bill from a doctor visit. Why is it that we seemed to have accepted this sociopathy as normal — that ordinary people, ordinary Vermonters, must choose between eating and staying healthy?
This is no theoretical problem. It is laws and policies that deliberately force the parent standing in a checkout line calculator in hand, wondering whether to put back the fruit or postpone a medical appointment; or the senior cutting pills in half, like my mother used to have to do, to make prescriptions last longer; or the worker ignoring symptoms, which I've been obliged to do before, because the copay alone would wipe out a week’s worth of food.
Those who profit very well from these situations tell us that these are “personal choices.” This, however, ignores reality. When wages stagnate, food prices climb, and health care costs spiral, these choices are forced upon us —not freely made. No society that considers itself humane should normalize the idea that preventive care is a luxury item like we in the United States of America have done to ourselves.
Access to affordable food and access to medical care are basic needs. The fact that so many people are so vulnerable should concern all of us, not just those currently facing the dilemma. If we want healthier communities, we must stop pretending that this vulnerability is acceptable.
Hunger and untreated illness are not signs of personal failure; they are symptoms of society and policy failure. They deserve better solutions than more of the same.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here