This letter is from Franklin County Sheriff John Grismore.
I am writing in response to your recent article titled, “So, you want to start a police force: Enosburgh charts course for town-owned crew” published on 04/09/25.
As the Sheriff for Franklin County, I think it is important to point out a few mistruths made in the article as it pertains to why the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office and the Town (and Village) of Enosburgh no longer have a partnership.
RELATIONSHIP & CONTRACT NEGOTIATIONS
Statement #1: “Enosburgh was contracted with the sheriff's office for years, but Woods said the relationship soured when the sheriff position transitioned from Roger Langevin to John Grismore.”
The relationship between the Sheriff’s Office and the town of Enosburgh as demonstrated through many positive correspondences between the Sheriff’s Office and town leadership, and in my participation in several selectboard meetings was efficacious until contract negotiations failed in the early summer of 2024.
In an 11/06/23 email to me, from Town Clerk Billie Jo Draper wrote, “thank you for the efforts, we appreciate it.” In an email seven days later, Draper wrote, “Hello – I wanted to thank you for attending the selectboard meeting on Monday, the 20th of November. The board appreciates your coming to answer some questions – we did not expect an audience, as we typically never have one, but your answers were clear that it is not just an Enosburgh problem. Thanks again, I look forward to receiving your proposed contract in December.”
Hardly appears like a “soured” relationship and certainly not once the sheriff position transitioned.
We faithfully and amicably completed our contract responsibilities when I took office in early 2023 until the end of the contract in June of 2024. In addition, we ensured that events like the Eclipse in April of 2024 were staffed with multiple deputies as well as adjusting our patrol schedule to accommodate Enosburgh’s needs.
The truth is that the contract negotiations failed when I refused to meet the town’s unrealistic demands during the negotiation process in the spring of 2024. The town insisted on a reduced term (6 months instead of three years as we had previously) and pricing model (which was not feasible – The Sheriff’s Office use the same pricing model for all police services contracts). We were very transparent as to where the new contract costs were derived. Further, limiting our office to a 6-month contract, as was requested by the selectboard, instead of the traditional 3-year contract, was not desirable given the challenges in retaining personnel (this was mapped out in an email to the Town Clerk on 04/11/24). Furthermore, it was discovered that the selectboard wanted a 6-month contract to give themselves time to identify another police services partner, leaving us high and dry after 6 months.
The other stipulation that we were unwilling to meet was that we were to provide cruiser GPS tracking data to the selectboard on a routine basis. This would have bene a violation of privacy for our deputies. Providing this data would contain the home residence information of our deputies and efforts to “scrub” the data to meet the town’s expectation would be extremely time consuming and was not something we had the resources to provide.
COMMUNICATIONS AND POLICE COVERAGE
Statement #2: “The shift to the Grismore administration saw a lack of communication and lack of police coverage in the town, Woods said, culminating at a point two years ago when the selectboard pulled the tapes at the outpost located inside the ambulance headquarters and saw there was no officer stationed in the town for nearly four months.”
The truth is that when I took office, the contract in Enosburgh (and in other towns) was not being completely fulfilled due to staffing shortages. This existed long before I assumed command. The difference is that when I took the reins, I was upfront with the town and village of Enosburgh about my Office’s inability to consistently fill the contract – again due to staffing shortages – something every police department was facing. Once I understood the totality of the issue, I promptly communicated it to the town (within the second month of my tenure). One example is contained in a February 2023 report issued to both the town and village of Enosburgh, on 03/17/23:
“Billie Jo, John,
Attached is the data for the month of February. As we have discussed, we still have staffing challenges with military leave, some attrition, paternity leave and vacations. As we also discussed, until we stabilize our regular 40 hour per week schedule, we will cease billing one month in advance and will only bill you at month end for services rendered. We are actively recruiting and have made some significant increases to our benefits in an effort to attract new talent. The good news is that we have received a record number of applications (submitted for any one month) in February, with a few of those being candidates that are already certified through the Vermont Criminal Justice Training Council. It does, however, take some time to vet them through the process. We are optimistic that we will have a few more personnel hired by late spring/early summer. The drug issue in the greater Enosburgh region continues to be a problem. We are working very closely with the Vermont Drug Task Force to identify and disrupt the illicit drug activities and the subsequent criminal activities associated. We expect to make several arrests in the coming weeks.”
As the existing contract at the time was a “pay-in-advance” model, we hoped to restructure the contract, as we had successfully done with other towns, to a “pay-for-services-rendered-model” to ensure that the town wasn’t being charged for services that were not being provided (as had been the case previously). Over payment by the town of Enosburgh to the Sheriff’s Office prior to my administration resulted in the need for the office to repay over $10,000 in billed for, but not provided, police services. My administration wanted to prevent this from happening again. Enosburgh Town leadership refused to accept a contract amendment to capture this. The Sheriff’s Office would proceed to bill for services rendered, not promised, going forward.
I had communicated multiple times with Town Clerk Draper starting early in my tenure and throughout the life of contract. As demonstrated above, I was upfront with the staffing challenges, provided monthly reports, to include the hours worked for that month, and attended several selectboard meetings.
The statement that there “was no officer stationed in the town for nearly four months” is baseless, misleading and false. As noted, I provided monthly reports, all of which contained the hours worked for each month. Here is the monthly breakdown of hours worked from when I took office until the contract ended:
Month/Yr: Feb-23 (32 hours), Mar-23 (17.5 hours), Apr-23 (80 hours), May-23 (18 hours), Jun-23 (123.75 hours), Jul-23 (141.25 hours), Aug-23 (86.5 hours0, Sep-23 (82 hours), Oct-23 (88 hours), Nov-23 (102 hours), Dec-23 (119 hours), Jan-24 (94 hours), Feb-24 (104 hours), Mar-24 (35.75 hours) Apr-24 (66.5 hours), May-24 (82.5 hours) Jun-24 (84 hours)
Further, regarding the statement about tapes being pulled from the outpost -it has always been our expectation that deputies assigned to a town are out patrolling, not sitting at an outpost or other office.
There was no month in which services were not provided.
CONTRACT PROPOSAL
It is important to note that our 2024-2027 contract proposal for 40 hours per week of service was $189,340 for year 1, $198,080 for year 2 and $207,320 for year 3. There was information provided to the public by a member of the Enosburgh Town selectboard at the Enosburgh Public Info Meeting on 03/01/25, that our contract proposal was over $200,000 and then “going up from there.” As noted previously, it wasn’t until year 3 that the cost went above $200,000 and those costs included dispatching costs, cruiser costs, equipment, training and insurances. Based on the math provided by the selectboard at this same meeting, the initial costs to start a police department will be more than $300,000 in year one alone not including such things as dispatching costs, cruiser costs and equipment.
I hope that this provides a more accurate picture than what has been communicated by Enosburgh Town leadership. I think that the Enosburgh Town and Village voters are being misled as to the actual costs required to create and run a police organization to say nothing of the challenges in recruiting, hiring, training and maintaining a police workforce.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here