Letter to the Editor: Second homes not an answer for Vermont's housing needs

Posted

This letter is from Rep. James Gregoire (R-Fairfield).

Good governance requires participants willing to come to the table in good faith. The devil is in the details. If we can’t discuss challenging topics without resorting to misinformation or personal attacks, our civic discourse suffers. I’ve heard several versions of —keep DC out of VT —many times over the past 24 years since first running for office and I try to live by it.

As we seek solutions to Vermont’s housing crisis, it is tempting to view our 51,000 second homes as an easy fix. Some of the conversation has involved turning these properties into primary residences. The reality is that the vast majority of these properties are functionally unusable for year-round residents. While we shouldn’t dismiss the conversation, we must separate practical reality from misleading talking points.

Many of these properties are seasonal cabins or ski chalets that lack winter insulation or year-round utilities. They also present a geographic and economic mismatch to our needs. A luxury mountain lodge won’t help a worker needing affordable housing near schools or employers in Franklin County, for example. Forcing high-end properties onto the market will not create the workforce housing our communities desperately need.

Analyzing how many second homes could truly serve middle and lower-income Vermonters quickly eliminates all but about 1,500 properties. Approximately 80% to 85% of these homes cost over $450,000, with many reaching into the millions, making them unattainable for most residents. Of the remaining homes valued under $450,000, about 70% are clustered around ski resorts or lakes, making them equally unavailable for regular workforce needs.

We must face the hard numbers. The Vermont Housing Needs Assessment shows we need to build 36,000 new homes by 2029 just to stabilize our market. Currently, we build fewer than 2,500 units per year. Relying on existing second homes is a distraction from the real work of building more housing.

Families still face pandemic economic fallout. Although inflation has cooled, it remains above the 2% target. High government spending and past supply chain issues permanently raised everyday costs for groceries, utilities, and building materials. Continued high federal spending keeps upward pressure on consumer prices. Additionally, Canadian lumber tariffs further drive-up construction costs. Experts predict these economic disruptions will last until the end of the decade.

Targeting second homes won’t lower household bills or offset inflation. Instead, we should focus on things like gentle infill zoning, reducing red tape, and upgrading municipal water and sewer systems through the Community and Housing Infrastructure Program (CHIP). At the end of the day, we need to build a lot of affordable housing. There is a difference between affordable and subsidized, though both have a place.

To make Vermont affordable again, we must protect working families from crushing costs, invest in infrastructure, and build the housing our workforce requires. We have endured six years of economic turmoil. Regardless of the national scene, the job of Vermont’s elected officials is to protect Vermont. Vermonters deserve a government that is both efficient and effective.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here