Letter to the Editor: Read a 'banned book' this week. There is nothing to fear.

Posted

This letter is from Cary Brunswick, a resident of St. Albans. Brunswick recently moved to St. Albans from Oneonta, N.Y., where he was a trustee for the Huntington Memorial Library.

When I studied American literature in high school back in the 1960s, the books I most enjoyed were contemporary novels about young people.

Holden Caulfield in “Catcher in the Rye” seemed smart-alecky as he trudged around Manhattan, and I remember thinking at the time how wonderful it was to have to read a book that teenagers could relate to, compared to the usual dry fare of Hawthorne or Emerson.

The boys attending a private school in “A Separate Peace” seemed worlds away but were our age, and the mystery surrounding a fall from a tree held our attention. Reading it was not the chore that Henry Adams was.

What my classmates and I didn’t know was that those books were controversial and had been challenged or banned in some schools because of profanity and sexual references.

And we certainly didn’t know that 60 years later the number of demands to censor such books would multiply. In just the last 15 years, the number of attempts to have books banned has tripled.

According to the American Library Association, there were at least 1,269 demands to censor library books and resources in 2022, the highest number of attempted book bans since the ALA began compiling such data more than 20 years ago.

Deborah Caldwell-Stone, director of the ALA’s Office for Intellectual Freedom, said, “This is a dangerous time for readers and the public servants who provide access to reading materials. Readers, particularly students, are losing access to critical information, and librarians and teachers are under attack for doing their jobs.”

That’s why it is important during the coming days to acknowledge Banned Book Week, the annual event of the ALA to promote people having the freedom to read what they want, and the importance of the First Amendment.

But even more disturbing is the fact that over the years obscenity and profanity have been replaced by race and gender issues as the primary reasons for censorship demands. Some people apparently believe that hiding historical and contemporary themes from their children will be beneficial.

Yes, let’s try to keep such topics locked away as taboo so we can have generations of young people growing up without an accurate understanding of them.

It won’t work, and in the pro cess a successful book challenge could be depriving young people of the opportunity to experience good literature that contributes to an understanding of modern issues. Whether we like those themes or not, they are prevalent and should not be censored.

Yes, you’d think we would have progressed beyond a Nazi-li ke authoritarianism that tries to repress free speech, whether it’s represented by a nation, a religion, the library, or schoolbooks.

In this age of the Internet and such a free flow of information, however, it is much more difficult for censors to keep ideas expressed in books or their digital versions away from youths and adults who might want them.

As a result, attempts to ban books have become largely symbolic, and often can have the opposite effect. It is like trying to restrict access to certain television shows and websites: censorship creates taboos, and its purpose often backfires.

Most library leaders agree with the contention that restricting access to books or other media should always be the job of parents. If parents want their children to avoid a book, they should talk to them to explain why, rather than try to remove it from a library shelf so it is not available to anyone. The freedom to explore a variety of viewpoints is at the core of democratic liberty.

Banned Book Week is Oct. 5 to 11 this year with the theme, “Censorship Is So 1984. Read for Your Rights.” Many libraries have displays to highlight books that have been banned or often challenged in the past. Take a look and, better yet, read a banned book next week and see for yourself that there really is no reason it should be tossed into the fire.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here