Letter to the Editor: Let’s ask the right questions about our health care and our schools

Posted

This letter is from Peter J. Wright, the President and Chief Executive Officer of Northwestern Medical Center.

As we digest the results of Town Meeting Day, the focus on taxes and school budgets continues to be the topic at every water cooler and community store.

There is no argument that employee wages and benefits are the single largest driver of school spending and within that, health insurance premiums and healthcare costs draw the most focus and attention. The real question is were we asking the right “why” when it comes to school spending and how much health care accounts for those costs?

Let me start by saying that our schools, just like our hospitals, are foundations to healthy communities. Pitting one against the other is not a recipe for success. In Franklin County, we want and deserve to have great schools. We also deserve great health care close to home.

Some will have you think that healthcare costs are being driven up by “out-of-control hospital spending”; however, the facts are healthcare spending is a simple equation, rate x volume. Both are relevant, but a deeper look shows a different story. For example, no Vermont hospital was granted a rate increase more than 3.4% for the current budget year. In point of fact, while individual rate increases do vary, Northwestern Medical Center (NMC), serving Franklin and Grand Isle counties, has been granted an overall average of less that 3.87% per year dating back to 2011. This is in line with inflation and below health care inflation. Furthermore, expense growth has averaged 3.5% for the last six years  demonstrating our commitment to  our employees and the need to be  very prudent financial stewards.  

At the same time, “case mix index” (a reflection of how sick the average patient is) of Vermont patients increased by 10.8% between 2014 and 2022. Think  about that for a moment, the average patient is nearly 11% sicker now than a decade ago. That is staggering. Obviously, a sicker patient is more expensive to care for.  

In addition, healthcare spend ing has been impacted by equally significant increases in volume. For the last several years, many Vermont hospitals came under fire for long wait times to get an appointment, NMC being one. Pre-pandemic (2014 to 2019) outpatient visit volumes dropped nearly 3% across Vermont. The directive from the Green Mountain  Care Board (GMCB) was to “open  access” and shorten wait time for  service. Hospitals and healthcare  providers across the state heeded the call. As a result, and excluding the obvious outlying drop of 12.2% in 2020, outpatient visits surged by 7.9% when compared  to pre-pandemic levels. Naturally, increasing access means more  patient visits and that added volume, which was significant at all hospitals and provider locations across Vermont, is reflected in the  significant increase in spending  that schools and municipalities have been experiencing as well. It’s undeniable that added volume and severity of illness are the  main drivers of healthcare spend ing increases, not out-of-control hospital spending. Other questions for Vermonters to think about are, how is your insurance plan structured? Are there incentives for  covered staff members to seek primary care first, then urgent care  and the emergency department as a last resort? Are staff members  encouraged to “price shop” services that are not urgent or emergent, i.e. diagnostic imaging, labs, therapy and specialty services?  You should know that there are no  such requirements and incentives  for government insured patients  (Medicare, Medicaid, etc.) whose  low reimbursements to providers contribute significantly to increased commercial insurance  premiums. Without these incentives (i.e. when price doesn’t matter), human nature is to seek the  easiest, most convenient location. 

So, as we continue our conversations with Town Meetings behind us, I urge you to know the “why”  and ask more questions. This will  be more important than ever as the  Legislature begins to raise questions of its own. There’s no doubt  that affordability is on all of our minds. For NMC’s part, we’ll continue to be the low-cost provider  in our state and strong financial  managers while still delivering the  highest quality care in an ever changing landscape. Our community deserves no less. 

Peter J. Wright, FACHE is the President and Chief Executive Officer of  Northwestern Medical Center in St. Albans Vermont. He is board certified in healthcare management and  a Fellow of the American College of  Healthcare Executives. Mr. Wright  received his bachelor’s degree from Lyndon State College, a master’s in  administration from St. Michael’s  College and a master’s in healthcare  delivery science from Dartmouth  College’s Tuck School of Business  and Geisel School of Medicine.

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here