This letter is from Rep. Mike McCarthy (D-St. Albans City), House Government Operations Committee Chair & Military Affairs Committee Vice Chair, Special Committee on Impeachment Inquiry
Nearly a full year ago, the Vermont House passed HR.11, creating a Special Committee on Impeachment Inquiry to investigate the conduct of two Franklin County officials. The matter of the State’s Attorney was considered resolved by the Special Committee after he resigned from office. We turned our attention to the matter of Sheriff John Grismore, hearing testimony at several meetings and conducting an investigation with the support of outside legal counsel.
House Resolution 18 summarizes the Special Committee on Impeachment Inquiry’s work, and I would encourage members of the public to read the 44-page report issued by the Special Committee to fully understand our findings and recommendations. I want to thank the members of the Special Committee and Chair Martin Lalonde for seriously considering the testimony and evidence brought before us. We weighed significant questions about the constitutional power of impeachment, the sanctity of our elections and the appropriate course to take when an elected official violates the trust of the public.
The committee investigated several areas of concern and found two to be quite serious. The first is well known, the inappropriate use of force which is currently the subject of a criminal trial and has resulted in the permanent revocation of the law enforcement certification of Sheriff Grismore by the Vermont Criminal Justice Council. We were relieved to find no evidence of additional use of force policy violations since. However, Sheriff Grismore’s continued claims about the appropriateness of his actions should give us all pause. Video of the unreasonable use of force incident circulated in the weeks leading up to the general election, and therefore could have been known to Franklin County voters. The Special Committee, while concerned about this matter and the impact it has had on Franklin County decided not to recommend an Article of Impeachment.
The second matter of serious concern was not known to the voters at the time of Sheriff Grismore’s election in 2022. Prior to his termination from employment at the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office, Mr. Grismore had payroll and check-writing responsibilities under Sheriff Langevin. During this time, our investigation showed Grismore wrote multiple checks to himself in the amounts that should have gone into the Vermont State Employees Retirement System, totaling more than $16,000. In January of this year, one of Sheriff Langevin’s final acts was to pay back more than $20,000 to the pension funds to make up for the payments Grismore had pocketed for himself. Again, while the committee is deeply concerned about this matter, it did not recommend an Article of Impeachment to the House. While these inappropriate payments were not known to the voters, the timing of the acts and the fact that Sheriff Langevin had at least the opportunity to review these payments on some of the paperwork obtained during our investigation, makes the case for an impeachment too uncertain for the House to pursue further.
The bar for impeaching an elected official is, and should be, quite high. Only resignation, impeachment or death can remove an official before their term of office expires. There are no professional qualifications set in the Vermont Constitution for County offices such as Sheriff. I remain dismayed at the Senate’s inability to advance Proposition 1, a constitutional amendment to allow the legislature to establish qualifications for these powerful county offices.
Given the seriousness of the use of force case and the highly concerning retirement payments, the House calls on Mr. Grismore to resign the office of Sheriff for the benefit of the people of Franklin County in HR.18.
I’m proud of the thoughtful work the Special Committee on Impeachment Inquiry did to address these matters. We cannot and should not normalize impeachment. Even in light of serious concerns about the character, professionalism and conduct of an elected official it is better to err on the side of respecting the democratic process rather than seeking to correct the outcome of an election absent clear evidence of crimes or acts of gross misconduct committed during an official’s term of office.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here