Letter to the Editor: Education reform will fall short if we keep ignoring healthcare

Posted

This letter is from Jack McCarthy, a member of the Maple Run Board of Directors and the Vermont School Board Association Board of Directors. 

Lawmakers have returned to Montpelier, and education reform is once again at the center of the policy debate. In this year’s State of the State address, the governor devoted his remarks to urging lawmakers to stay the course on Act 73 and to move forward with school district redistricting as the next major step.

The governor is right to acknowledge that Vermont’s education system is placing growing strain on taxpayers and that change is necessary. Questions about governance, district organization, and accountability deserve serious attention. But as this debate moves forward, there is a real risk of repeating a familiar mistake by focusing on structural change while avoiding the cost pressures that are actually driving education spending across the state.

One of the largest and fastest growing pressures on school budgets is employee healthcare. No amount of redistricting or consolidation will make that cost disappear.

In St. Albans, the Maple Run Unified School District experienced continual exorbitant increases in healthcare costs for employees. For example, in the 2025 and 2026 budget proposals, healthcare increased by 12% in each year. In the current 2027 approved budget, healthcare has increased by another 7%. Yet the 2027 MRUSD budget incorporates a mere 2.44% increase. This increase is one of the smallest in years. Healthcare costs represent over two thirds of the entire increase. That means that less than 1% of the increase covers needs in curriculum, payroll, busing, food service, maintenance, special education, athletics and so forth. Healthcare represents a major cost driver for Maple Run and all other school districts. District leaders have noted that even with careful spending restraint and relatively modest overall increases, rising healthcare costs place persistent pressure on the budget. This is not a St. Albans specific issue. It is the same dynamic confronting districts in every corner of Vermont.

This challenge did not emerge by accident. In 2018, Vermont moved public school employee health benefits into a single statewide bargaining system. The goal was understandable and widely supported at the time. Statewide bargaining was promoted as a way to reduce administrative complexity, strengthen negotiating power, and slow the growth of healthcare costs through scale and consistency.

Those savings have not materialized.

Since the shift to statewide bargaining, healthcare costs have grown dramatically, far outpacing overall education spending and local revenue growth. Rather than stabilizing budgets, healthcare costs have become one of the primary drivers of rising school expenditures and property taxes statewide. What was intended to bring predictability and savings has instead created a system in which costs continue to rise, while local school boards have little ability to manage them.

Recent discussions about district size and governance reinforce an important point. While organizational changes may address some inefficiencies, they do not address healthcare costs. Avoiding this issue only guarantees that other reforms will fall short of their promise.

Today, public school employee healthcare benefits are set through a single statewide agreement, yet local school boards remain responsible for balancing budgets and responding to taxpayers. This disconnect makes responsible cost management harder, not easier. Boards are left to make painful cuts in staffing or programs while the fastest growing expense remains largely outside their control.

There is a more practical and balanced path forward. The Vermont School Boards Association has proposed targeted reforms that would bring school employee healthcare negotiations more in line with how benefits are negotiated for most other Vermont workers. These proposals include modest adjustments to plan design options, changes to arbitration rules, and expanding who participates in negotiations. The goal is not to eliminate healthcare benefits or shift the burden onto any one group. It is to slow the rate of growth before costs overwhelm school budgets entirely.

Addressing healthcare costs requires acknowledging a difficult truth. Rising healthcare expenses affect both employers and employees. Sustainable solutions require shared responsibility, transparency, and a willingness to reexamine a system that has not delivered on its original promise.

If Vermont is serious about putting public education on firmer footing, lawmakers cannot afford to sidestep this issue. From St. Albans to the Northeast Kingdom to the southern counties, healthcare costs are an education issue, a taxpayer issue, and an equity issue. They must be front and center in this year’s debate.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here