This letter is from Vivian Warner, a resident of St. Albans City.
I read the Franklin County Democratic Committee’s Letter to the Editor from August 14, with interest. I challenge the Franklin County Democratic Committee’s connection between S.190 and property tax relief. The Democrats' argument is based on a policy theory that reducing healthcare costs could reduce school costs and lower property taxes. They go too far when they present S.190 as though that chain of savings was guaranteed. Voters are being promised savings that are uncertain.
S.190 was a healthcare bill designed to lower hospital costs by using a new pricing system to bring Vermont’s prices in line with the national average by 2030 (“S.190 Vetoed Bill Summary”). The bill sought to provide expedited insurance savings for public school employees and ACA marketplace participants by capping hospital payment rates and requiring those lower costs be directly reflected in reduced premium rates. The Governor vetoed the bill because he believed the bill would target savings to certain insurance plans rather than provide those savings broadly to all Vermonters. That disagreement over who would benefit from S.190 is important when considering the Democrats’ claim that the bill would have helped reduce Vermont’s high property taxes.
The Democrats claim S.190 was intended to lower costs for everyone. The cost of public education is one of the largest drivers of Vermont’s high property taxes. Lower insurance costs do not automatically mean lower property taxes. Those savings would first have to result in lower school spending before they could translate into lower property taxes.
Democrats frame the Republican vote to uphold the veto as a vote to protect the profits of the healthcare industry. The real issue was a substantive disagreement over how S.190 would have affected healthcare costs, insurance premiums, and taxpayers.
If the goal is to reduce property taxes, Vermont also needs to address the high cost of education. Taxpayers should be asking which Franklin County school boards have increased spending in disproportion to enrollment and inflation, and which of those increases have translated into higher costs for property owners.
Democrats Caroline Bright, Pam McCarthy, and Zach Scheffler are campaigning on the same assumptions I am questioning. These candidates are misleading voters when they package healthcare reform as property tax relief.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here